I just had an idea:
TLoU2 follows the story of Abby, a tomboy with no friends but her parents, her dad specifically. Game is told from Abby's perspective, doing tasks for her organisation, missions, salvage operations etc. and sometimes tells flashbacks of her time with dad but with no mention of him being a doctor or killed by Joel. Other flashbacks tell the time she became a soldier after her parents' death when she had no other options, how she got muscular and even less popular with boys, how she learned to cope with killing people... Maybe put a mission in the middle where she saves her pet Asian from kidnapping. Maybe put a theme that the Asian kid feels frustrated at serving as Abby's emotional crutch 'cause she has no other friends. Maybe let Abby show some heroics. Maybe give her a hobby or make her an animal lover so she doesn't feel look like such a stereotype. Abby spends most of the time killing zombies not people because that's what a zombie apocalypse is fucking about.
At some point Abby learns she's immune to cordyceps. For now, she just shrugs and is happy she got something good from life.
In the second half, Abby gets intel about her dad's murderers and story is now about pursuing them. Joel dies or gets killed offscreen BUT NOT BY ABBY FFS. Abby kills/tortures lots of people to get at the murderer and is frustrated she couldn't get Joel, so she goes for his relatives to avoid emotional pain from just letting it go. The game and Abby don't know it's Ellie until the final face-punching confrontation from the leaks. Ellie persuades Abby from killing her friend Scrooge McDyke by saying she doesn't want to lose her family again. Abby swallows tears while preparing to skin NotJoel, says fuck it and leaves them. Abby thinks about the past and concludes Ellie was meant to be killed by her dad for the cure.
Asian kid asks Abby what now, she hugs him saying "Why it wasn't me?" - couch psychologists have fun interpreting whenether she meant getting killed instead of her dad or getting selected as a test subject instead of Ellie. Cut to Ellie leaving Magicka DeSmell to kill Abby for teh revengeance. Game ends.
It's still a shit on people who liked the first game but I think it follows the themes. Joel killed lots of people to "avenge" his daughter and to keep having a replacement family. Abby kills lots of people to avenge her father and to keep having a replacement family (give that Asian freak a purpose to the story, OK?). Like in the first game, nothing gets resolved, there's lots of pain and death and all we learn is that murdering shit after the apocalypse instead of building civilisation back makes more problems than it solves.
Nah, its easy to make a game about revenge is bad, and you should feel bad. Its just with the Abby leaks, its hard to symphatize with her, because she is connected to the surgeon in LOU, which Joel killed. and for most people who played LOU1, Joel did nothing wrong. So, with Abby killing Joel, its hard to symphatize with her because there's nothing to symphatize with.
I'll try my best to do some script doctoring to make it easier to symphatize with Abby
1.make abby a cute grill like elly. make her have a younger sibling to take care of. have their parents died from zombies, final words to abby is to take care of younger sibling
2. abby and the younger sibling trek across america to get to a fireflies safeplace.
3. along the way, the younger sibling gets infected. abby ties up and gag the younger sibling and carry on her back, to the fireflies hideout in hopes of the cure she heard that the fireflies were developing from other scavengers she meets along the way.
4. abby gets to the fireflies hideout but Joel murderized everyone. no hope for a cure.
5. abby then has to sobbingly old yeller her younger sibling. in tears she swears revenge on the guy that basically denied her the cure for her younger sibling.
6. blah blah blah, events happen, abby got a par 3 with joel. ellie swears revenge on abby
7. blah blah blah, events happen, elly and abby gets a final showdown
8. elly needs to let go of her lust for revenge, because cycle of revenge is bad, abby needs to let go of her younger sibling and live for herself
9. ending
10. 10/10 across the board, VGA video game story of the year award, blah blah blah
see. that wasn't so hard.