Pretty much agree. It is on the verge of collapsing under the weight of the myriad nobodies that are featured there, all doing basically the same stuff. From what i can tell, most people only care about Cinemasnob, Film Brain or Spoony and to a lesser extend Lupa and Phelous, all of which have their own sites now. Which makes the Nostalgia Critic basically the only one of interest on ChannelAwesome (as it is now called). But even that interest seems to have diminished after it was revealed recently ago, what kind of ugly, politics driven stuff is going on behind the scenes.
I personally got tired of it all a long time ago (and never was a true fan to begin with). Once you see the majority of their content for what it is, mainly derivative crap, focusing exclusively on nerd shit like movies and TV shows nobody gives a shit about anymore, or goddamn action figures, one can't but move on.