- Joined
- Mar 2, 2020
Oh I'm not denying the bathroom breaks are to alert a whale it's tip to open their wallet, or that the streak is kept alive through only a few whales.
What I am saying is that if the OnlyIcedCoffee leaks were true (For reminder, they claim 1. that Phil knows which whale will tip and when they will and 2. that Phil only genuinely panicked about the vest streak being in danger once) then I don't see how these bathroom breaks emergency calls could happen. That's not an indictment against the bathroom breaks being whale calls, it's an indictment against the supposed leaks.
Because the leaks claim Phil knows in advance when whales will tip, it makes no sense for him to be messaging his whales for them to tip towards the end of the stream because he would know they will tip and when already at that point - in fact according to the leaks it is the whales who tip to say when they will make it so the streak is hit, so they flat out say this shouldn't be how it works. This means the bathroom break calls could only be an emergency measure when a whale misses that pre-arranged time for tipping, except then the leaks also say Phil has never panicked except once, which would mean that whales haven't actually missed calls except that one time, which contradicts the theory the bathroom breaks are for rallying the whales because the streak is in danger.
The devil is in the details, both Phil knowing who in advance will save the streak and his water bottle waddle can be true. A couple quick ways that this can be true is either Phil is using his water break to reconfirm that his whale will save him (given that it usually happens around about the halfway point on a low tip night) or Phil is using his water break to call in a whale to save the goal which would still be advanced notice of when/where/how the vest streak will be saved that night.