The only way I've found to successfully talk about politics and change TDS sufferers' minds even a little bit is to approach it as a leftie who has concerns about a given issue, from a leftie perspective, with leftie goals, and always including appeals to the right kinds of emotion.
(Background: I was a lifelong Dem voter, was a TDS sufferer, but got red-pilled over the last couple of years. Currently, I'm politically homeless, but intend to vote for Trump. I've kept silent on it, however, so everybody in my ultra-progressive social and family circle still thinks I'm one of them, and I'm fine with that.)
The Green New Deal (or, as I think of it, the Green Leap Forward) is a typical example. I've made some significant inroads simply by having read it (when nobody I've met who supports it has), knowing what insane shit it proposes, and thus being able to inform other people of what it actually entails. And I frame it as, "This is a great idea, but x, y, and z, as they are written, really concern me, given what I know about actually doing x, y, and z. Enacting these measures in their current form would create tremendous hardships for some of our most vulnerable populations for [reasons]. So I think it still needs a lot of work before it becomes legislation."
Or, with the latest stimulus package, which Pelosi is willfully holding hostage: "Yeah, yeah, Orange Man Bad, but there's a bunch of stuff in that package that has absolutely nothing to do with Covid-19 relief, it doesn't belong in there, and Trump will never let it through. If Nancy really wants to get that stimulus package through so it can help people, she needs to take out anything irrelevant--like x. Oh, and y, which, I mean really, makes no sense, and what does it have to do with helping people right now?And z, which may be a good idea, but it's only half-cooked here. I get wanting all these other things, but the focus right now needs to be on getting money to people who need it, not trying to push through a bunch of extras. Those can wait; the people who need that money can't."
But the shit of it is, successfully pointing out one set of absurdities surrounding one issue never kicks off the process of noticing the problems with other issues. It doesn't get them to read beyond the headlines, or actually read up on the details of intended legislation, or fact-check anything. So any gains I've made have been small and incomplete, which is immensely demoralizing and depressing. The people I talk to aren't unintelligent, but they're just like cult members in their blind dogmatism, and occasionally sneaking some facts or an alternative view through their defenses has only a limited effect because their thinking is so rigid.
I don't know why I keep trying, at this point. Misplaced optimism, I guess.
The problem is that all of the ultra progtards who suffer from TDS are overly emotional, and put everything on their emotional state rather than trying to listen to reasoned arguments. Trump is basically the accumulation of everything they hate. Whether it is true or not is another matter.
I mean, my family member's GF thinks I'm a Republican for simply digging into and challenging Democratic talking points. Like if you inspect something, you are guilty of supporting the opposite side to it. There's no middle ground with them. It is literally George W. Bush. Either you're with them or against them. Honestly, I never really encountered it in reality. It is way more horrifying to see and hear it in front of you. Because it really is like talking to a cult member. Trump is Satan. He is the personification of Evil. And they are the harbingers of justice, the angels of God. What, you're trying to scrutinize the angels? Then you must be an agent of Satan! It sort of went like this:
"Why are you defending them, Asshole? You've become really apathetic. What happened, you used to be so together on this. My GF thinks you're a Republican because of it."
"Oh, haha. I was just, ah, uh, playing devil's advocate."
"They don't deserve it, you shouldn't do that. People might think you...like Trump."
"Yeah, ok. It was just a prank bro. Please don't sacrifice me on the altar of white privilege to try to get enough human hearts to make the Green New Deal pass."
I don't even know how you do it. The danger of your family exiling you is quite real. For posters that don't have people or family suffering from TDS, it is pretty scary. Because they literally will look at all Republicans like the Devil. And I want to tell you, we both voted Libertarian in 2016. So I'm feeling his GF got him on the progtard express. And the influence of my younger self probably didn't help any. God, I used to be one of those that admonished other people for saying 'retard'. I didn't used to be this argumentative though. What really snapped me out of it was being very vulnerable in 2008 and witnessing what my so-called movement cared about. I saw genuine suffering and these fucks were chanting about whose turn it was to speak and critical race theory and garbage that had nothing to do with people dying and the crimes being committed. But that was me 12 years ago. I've already told him that I didn't vote for Obama for his second term (I forgot who I voted for). He still has this image of me that I really no longer exist as.
Oh forget about Pelosi. I tried convincing him that Pelosi already won and was just holding back stimulus to make a political point. I even pointed out it wasn't just me saying it, Dems were saying it too, as well as CNN. But nope. He got really frustrated at that and just shifted everything back to Trump. Even though he hates Pelosi. I mean, even emotionally, I cannot make any headway if he is completely blinded by his disgust for Trump. So even appealing to him as a leftist won't work, because there's little rational comprehension here. I mean, if you're listening to Snopes, which has long since abandoned any pretense of being impartial and you can't even see that CNN going against the grain and pointing something out is really telling, I'm not making any headway, ever. They'll never look into independent sources or try to think for themselves.
Honestly, with their thinking being so rigid and them being so emotional, I've just determined not to bother. For example, my other family members, many of whom dislike Trump, will get up and LEAVE THE ROOM if he starts talking rather than try to engage him in a political conversation. It isn't that people don't start talking about politics in front of him. They actively avoid him when he starts talking.
Not bothering is just easier, makes life less complicated and leads to less stress. It isn't worth ripping each other to pieces over something as stupid as politics. Even if they think it is. I'll just yes them to death and keep shitposting. But if they keep saying we should abandon the constitution because they're slave owners, I might go for the comedy option. "You know what, you're right. Fuck those people. If we didn't have slavery, we wouldn't have all these niggers here fucking the country up." Just to blow their minds. Not that I believe any of that of course. Just to say fuck progressivism and what its done to politics. Of course, if I say that, that's not just burning the bridge, that's nuking on it, pissing on the ashes and dying of radiation poisoning just to watch their reaction. But I guess that's what its all about, isn't it? Saying something you don't believe fully to make the other party lose their fucking mind.
I think I'm a member of the shitposting party.