Jerry Peet / Lily Orchard / Lily Peet / Valkyrstudios / Bhaalspawn / Tara Callie / "Mod Ebara" - Sociopath writer of pedophile fanfiction and cartoon reviews, faked getting raped to force a divorce, then mobbed and gaslit their ex off Tumblr, satanist neoliberal of the MovieSlob variety, also wants to fuck dogs and/or pokemon

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
+“While Nintendogal is experienced with it, Lily has long been uncomfortable writing smut. Something that 40% of the story consists of.” I haven’t read any of other Liliana’s works so I don’t know how many smut scenes are on them or how explicit they become. If they aren’t that many, this could be the reason why.
Funnily enough Jerry himself was the one who added this bit, as well as the one who created the page lmfao

TLDR Alchorative is Jerry.


Alchorative has a few different stories going for them. Most notably, the infamous Tara Callie claims this was them when someone talked about a fic they supposedly wrote;

which links to a riff some people did to said fic

Now, strangely enough, I could have sworn this google doc mentioned that the fiction was written by "Alchorative", not "Passion Fruit", so I guess Alchorative once again has plausible deniability...

...is what I would say, if I didn't realize that the link on the doc was a fimfiction link, when the story also existed on fanfiction. I'm pretty sure that doc originally mentioned Alchorative as well.

The riff was done by two people who aren't Jerry given that they have profiles that have more content and presence than Jerry's alts tend to have, so I have no reason to think they changed it, but... anyway

Archive of Alchorative's fanfiction.net page, containing A Mother's Love, A Daughter's Passion:

And of course, archive of A Mother's Love, A Daughter's Passion by Alchorative:

Feel free to compare this archive to the version on fimfetch and the version on the doc linked above. By the way, they were published on fanfiction and fimfiction within a day of each other, with the one on fanfiction by Alchorative having been published first, according to the archive.

Jerry is Tara:

Jerry claiming that the only proof of the connection is a shared IP address, despite the fact that Derpibooru staff claims sees more than just IPs

Bonus posts:
One of the lies Jerry's told to obfuscate the connection between him and Tara:

Jerry did to a fake ex-girlfriend what he's doing to Lizzy lmfao

Alchorative's comment on TVT claiming they're not Jerry
Despite the fact that they've not only made pretty personal edits about Jerry including numerous attempts to give RVI and Valkyr Studios their own pages separate from Jerry's (which failed completely), but even created the TVT pages for Jerry and Stockholm in the first place lmfao

There was also an OKCupid profile for Alchorative whose birthday was a day off from Jerry's, but I can't find it. Not like I need it anyway, heh

It's almost as if he knew the fic was fucked up so he preemptively wanted to give himself some plausible deniability by making sure Nintendogal was a scapegoat
 
Last edited:
This is a boring chapter because it’s mostly sex used for romance development. I’d say skip it entirely if you don’t care about that aspect of the story.

Chapter 5: P.S. We're Out Of Carrots

+Fluttershy feed the turtle pet of Rainbow and sits with her on the sofa. Nothing else is going on and suddenly:

“I’m a little stiff and it’s making my shorts uncomfortable,” Rainbow replied, “Mind giving ‘er a suck?”

+These segways.

+Fluttershy of course agrees and she sucks. But they are interrupted when Twilight knocks on their door. She is with Ascentia, who is carrying for her a bunch of books that Twilight is borrowing to Rainbow. Twilight spanks the ass of Ascentia. She likes seeing her wife carry books for her. Ascentia trips and falls to the ground. I think this is supposed to be slapstick because she makes a sarcastic comment afterwards about how she knew she had to stay in bed.

+Twilight notices Rainbow is still stiff and tell her they can continue doing what they were if they want. Ascentia supports her. Fluttershy is uncomfortable. Twilight say she is fine with this. Ascentia calls her a killjoy and Twilight threatens to slap her so she changes it to “you’re such a joy, sweetheart.” Then Twilight ask how they are. Ascentia still insist that they love each other and be happy forever. Twilight loses her patience and smacks her on the back of her head.

+Fluttershy and Rainbow are still on denial. Ascentia say they can still give them a show. Twilight smacks her some more. Comments that some day she is going to put a muzzle on Ascentia. Her hands apparently never get tired despite how frequent this is.

+Rainbow defends Fluttershy by saying they won’t do any of that, but ruins it the next sentence by offering they can still watch them make out, while commenting they are not as good as her blowjobs, like a creep.

+They talk about Twilight’s work in the library, that is going great, and also announces that she is pregnant. They used a sperm donor.

+Fluttershy and Rainbow are understandably put off by this because they had seen domestic abuse at least five times since they both appeared. They lie about going to the kitchen in the most clumsy, stupid way possible to talk about this. Twilight and Ascentia have this exchange:

“They’re going to talk about how we’re not fit to be parents, aren’t we?” Ascentia asked.



“Good for you,” Twilight said with a cheeky grin, “Why do people think you’re stupid?”



“...I thought we agreed no name calling,” Ascentia frowned, “Unless it’s ‘slut’ ‘whore’ ‘bitch’ or ‘slave’.”



Twilight was quiet for a moment, “...I’m sorry.”

+Fluttershy and Rainbow are concerned that Twilight will abuse the baby. Spoiler alert: she will and it will be somewhat handled, but only on the second fic and it won’t mean much in the end. But they don’t know for sure yet, so they resolve to let them know their concern without being accusatory, as Fluttershy wanted.

+Twilight acts incredibly dense on the next interaction, acting like she doesn’t understand why anyone would be concerned about them having a baby. She talks about how she is being concerned herself about it for months. It was Ascentia who suggested the sperm donor. Fluttershy asks if that means she “won’t be beating Ascentia anymore”, to which Ascentia tells them that she threatened to abandon Twilight if she did. The others are put off by this and Twilight thinks their reactions are funny. The sociopathic creep agrees that it would be funny if it wasn’t so fucked up. Ascentia yells on their ears that she likes it when she beats her and then snuggles with Twilight. Fluttershy says she likes seeing them like that, it’s “adorable.” Twilight tells her she and Rainbow are also adorable.

+During all of this Rainbow still had an erection, like a creep. Ascentia and Twilight now both agreed into peer pressure them to give a show. There is a implication that Twilight is blackmailing them to it, although I don’t know if Liliana realizes that is how it comes across when has Twilight mentioning “we know what you do behind Big Mac’s back.”

+Fluttershy finally yells at them to shut up while going on her knees to not leave Rainbow hanging. Twilight and Ascentia both agree if this hot even if they both prefer pussy. Whatever. Then Twilight has Ascentia sucking “her moist snatch”. Rainbow finishes first and both she and Fluttershy watches as Twilight does it too. Then she throws Ascentia to the kitchen table and gets a strapon “seemingly out of nowhere”. She suggest that Rainbow can use the mouth of Ascentia and Fluttershy gets possesive about it, to which Twilight mocks her but keeps fucking Ascentia. I don’t really understand how but somehow during this the back of Ascentia is smacking against the table in a way that looks painful. But Fluttershy and Rainbow think it’s pretty sweet still because Twilight sometimes says nice things on a warm tone.

+Just when Ascentia is about to cum, Twilight throws her over the table and her head does a hard sound. They don’t stop, though. When they are done Ascentia mentions she actually lost consciousness for a moment and Twilight just say “sorry”, which apparently is enough. Ascentia smacks her head agaisnt the table on her own.

+Rainbow offers one of her guest rooms so they can continue. They accept this and Rainbow comments she felts tempted to go with them. This prompts Fluttershy to insist that she is free to do as she wants and Rainbow asks Twilight if there is any blood. Twilight says the only blood is from Ascentia’s head injury. Rainbow just shrugs it off and goes to get her cock sucked because she is a creep. Twilight later offers Fluttershy to come join them and Fluttershy says no. She stays downstairs for a whole hour before just going out.

+She finds Big Mac, who ask her what is she doing outside so late at night. He offers a coffee. She declines. He offers her to give her a lift home. She accepts.

+On her house Fluttershy gets a pep talk by her bunny to admit she doesn’t want to share Rainbow´s cock and said pet writes a note in which name drops the name of the chapter. Fluttershy calls Rainbow to tell her she doesn’t want to share. Rainbow still has to ask if Fluttershy is downstairs or if she already left, because she is an idiot.

+Fluttershy tells her she doesn’t want to share her cock. Rainbow ask if she can continue the orgy that night as a creep and then tomorrow she won’t ever do it again. Spoiler alert: she does it again, but Fluttershy won’t have any problem with it at all and won’t be jelous about anything ever again so it’s all fine. Fluttershy agrees somehow and Rainbow says she got a girlfriend before going to fuck other people.

+They’re both very happy about this and Fluttershy snuggles with the bunny with human intellingence that won’t ever have any kind of relevancy during the entire fic ever again. The end.

Next Chapter: Count of Monte Christo Style Vengance

Estimated time remaining: 9 Hours, 45 Minutes
 
Last edited:
Nerds in 2015: "How come Finn and Rey can use a lightsaber?!"
George Lucas in 2005: "Hey, what if a droid was using a lightsaber? That'd be sweet."
Is Lilly trying to make it out that someone who has never used a lightsaber before wielding it like a pro is comparable to a cyborge (Grevious isn't a droid, fucker literally coughs all the time and ends the battle getting his heart ripped out) trained by Dooku wielding a lightsaber well?
Not!Starkiller from Fallen Order
I... I don't think Lilly understands how that joke works. You use 'Not!ThisCharacter' to say that said character is basically another character is everything but name. Cal Ketis is the furthest fucking thing you can get from Star Killer.
 
Its not even a dark joke, its stupid and light hearted if anything. I mean its completely normal for two grown adults to make stupid sexual jokes/puns, maybe a little bit immature but nothing to scared about ending a relationship over.

Also from what I've seen, no. I would assume Lily writes him off as being just like her mother in ideology if not a bit more distant. Especially since whenever she mentions familial abuse she mentions both of her parents and usually doesn't single out her mother or father. Father figures are also never blamed or even so much as given a second glance in most of her works so if I were to say what Lily probably thinks of her father it would be that she thinks he's abusive and cold/emotionally unavailable. She definitely has mommy issues/issues with women in general but for the most part I think she's actually a lot more OK with the men in her life than she would ever care to admit.

Can we actually believe Lily when she claims that her parents and her siblings are abusive?
 
Can we actually believe Lily when she claims that her parents and her siblings are abusive?
No, not really. Especially when you remember that Lily thinks that stuff like homework or doing basic tasks in the house or, God forbid, being taken on a shopping spree is abuse. To her, everything that she doesn't like is abuse. Yes, I get it, every teenager has at one point wished they didn't have to stay indoors doing homework or washing dishes while their friends have fun outside, but all these chores will pay off once you are an adult living by yourself, when mommy and daddy won't be there to do the laundry or dishes for you.

My guess is that her parents and siblings are actually chill, not the most loving family but a just ok family. Then Lily comes along and decides she's gonna be the bane of her parents' existence.
I firmly believe that her parents actually tried to raise Lily well and not grow up to be a shithead, only to give up once they saw that the kid was just a lost cause. I know that parents should love their children no matter what, but there is only so much one can accept until you realise, yeah, you can't fix this one.

Lily has a really warped idea of what raising a child properly is like, and it's been discussed in this thread before how Bonnie would end up an even bigger shithead of a kid if Lily raised her the way it was presented in the comic. Let's also not forget that she claimed temper tantrums are a result of bad parenting, when in truth every kid is gonna have temper tantrums at one point or another.

So ya, Lily has a very warped view of what constitutes as "abusive family". By her logic, every single person on earth was abused because they were asked to not watch Tv for 5 minutes to go buy some bread.
 
Asexual does not equal a lack of a sex drive. Its hard to describe but asexual people can enjoy sexual activities/get turned on but they dont actually like participating in the act of having sex. Also Mikaila thirtsts after Sylvanas, Jaina, and Eda from the owl house a lot. She makes sexually explicit comments and remarks outside of the comic all the time, it's really not that farfetched.
This is backwards. Being asexual means you don't have a sex drive (and have no psychological need for sex-- there's a difference between being asexual and having a sexual dysfunction, too). Ace people can fully have and enjoy sex (although there are many that are repulsed by it), but the defining factor is that it isn't something they have a desire for. Sexually active asexuals (yeah, I know) are generally ambivalent toward sex but engage because it fulfills a need for their partner.

They can still experience physical attraction but divorced of the sexual aspect. And none of it means they can't make sexual innuendos and jokes; those are just part of the popular consciousness and even if you're sex repulsed, at this juncture you'll still understand what '69 lol' means.

All that said this actually makes that Machoke comic even weirder? By the look Lily is giving Mikaila, Mikaila has either made a similar joke before or knows that Lily doesn't like joking in this manner. Why would she say something like this with no prompt? If the two of them had some kind of goofy sexual puns (like they kept walking down the street and saw more Pokemon they could pun off of) it might be a silly and almost cute (if... uncomfortable) gag. Instead Mikaila says something that Lily obvious disapproves of and then says 'Don't leave me'.

I guess this might be trying to catch on to that thing where somebody makes a supremely bad joke and then excuses themselves from the room, but the expressions between these two characters -- Lily's silent fury and disapproval, Mikaila's wide-eyed terror in the last panel -- speak to a very different relationship and it's simply baffling instead of being... I assume she was going for cute.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Typical Anime Trap
Can we actually believe Lily when she claims that her parents and her siblings are abusive?
unless you were in a literal cult where everyone is out to brainwahsing you, if you think everyone, as in every single person in your family is abusive, your either one of three things

1) Deluded and no better than those conspiracy nutjobs who think everybody from the government is after you cus your spwecial or something
2) You're the black sheep of your family (i doubt this because the only thing black about lily is her dirty laundry)
3) youre the problem.
If someone calls you a horse, how dare they. If someone else calls you a horse theyre an asshole. third time someone dose it, hey, time to go saddle shopping- something like that.

I'mma guesses option 1 and 2 are the most plausible because as far as people on this thread have said, her immediate family arent too bad/actively want nothing to do with her. If people are abusive/narcs, they'd actively seek out the black sheep of the family just to use as their personal punching bag just to make themselves feel better but... they don't. they actively try to avoid lily.

People only tend to avoid others if; the person theyre avoiding has wronged them in the past/is just a general gloom to be around/has been abusive to them in the past.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ColdArmadillo288
I'mma guesses option 1 and 2 are the most plausible because as far as people on this thread have said, her immediate family arent too bad/actively want nothing to do with her. If people are abusive/narcs, they'd actively seek out the black sheep of the family just to use as their personal punching bag just to make themselves feel better but... they don't. they actively try to avoid lily.
In addition to Lily's dubious definition of abuse (remember also that one of Lily's 'red flags' about Lizzy being an 'abuser' was that Lizzy refused to upend her life for 'one measly year' and live with Lily), Lily also insists that it is impossible for children to abuse their parents because power dynamics. See, adults have all the power, and children don't have any (legal) power, therefore children cannot abuse their parents.

Always seemed like suspiciously specific denial to me, especially given how Lily has treated her mother on social media.
 
Funnily enough Jerry himself was the one who added this bit, as well as the one who created the page lmfao

TLDR Alchorative is Jerry.


Alchorative has a few different stories going for them. Most notably, the infamous Tara Callie claims this was them when someone talked about a fic they supposedly wrote;

which links to a riff some people did to said fic

Now, strangely enough, I could have sworn this google doc mentioned that the fiction was written by "Alchorative", not "Passion Fruit", so I guess Alchorative once again has plausible deniability...

...is what I would say, if I didn't realize that the link on the doc was a fimfiction link, when the story also existed on fanfiction. I'm pretty sure that doc originally mentioned Alchorative as well.

The riff was done by two people who aren't Jerry given that they have profiles that have more content and presence than Jerry's alts tend to have, so I have no reason to think they changed it, but... anyway

Archive of Alchorative's fanfiction.net page, containing A Mother's Love, A Daughter's Passion:

And of course, archive of A Mother's Love, A Daughter's Passion by Alchorative:

Feel free to compare this archive to the version on fimfetch and the version on the doc linked above

Jerry is Tara:

Bonus posts:
One of the lies Jerry's told to obfuscate the connection between him and Tara:

Jerry did to a fake ex-girlfriend what he's doing to Lizzy lmfao

Alchorative's comment on TVT claiming they're not Jerry
Despite the fact that they've not only made pretty personal edits about Jerry including attempting numerous attempts to give RVI and Valkyr Studios their own pages separate from Jerry's, but even created the TVT pages for Jerry and Stockholm in the first place lmfao

There was also an OKCupid profile for Alchorative whose birthday was a day off from Jerry's, but I can't find it. Not like I need it anyway, heh

It's almost as if he knew the fic was fucked up so he preemptively wanted to give himself some plausible deniability by making sure Nintendogal was a scapegoat
Let's put on the old tinfoil hat for a sec--do we even know if Nintendogal is real? From what I remember their internet trail kinda goes cold and seems to only really have Stockholm attached to her, something Lily went out of her way to explicitly state she was the one who was most experienced with all the smut, almost as if to put all the uncomfortable pedo-shit on her. Those were all her ideas, and not those of the heroic Lily Orchard.

Are we certain Nintendogal isn't another sock-puppet of Lily's she created as a dead-end scapegoat to take the pressure off of her? Because, as we all know, Lily has a habit of creating sockpuppets to either praise herself (Tara) or vent her frustrations openly (Ebara--funny she removed the 'T' from Tara and added an 'EB') so it totally wouldn't be out of character for her to create a 'second author' for this story should she ever need to shift blame to avoid criticism.

The only problem with that is, of course, Lily has never done such a thing. In all the times people have tried to bring up the story or criticize her for writing it, she's never thrown Nintendogal under the bus for it, as far as I can remember. She's instead relied on her self-created and maintained TVTropes page to dispel criticism, rather than blame her writing partner.
 
Last edited:
Let's put on the old tinfoil hat for a sec--do we even know if Nintendogal is real? From what I remember their internet trail kinda goes cold and seems to only really have Stockholm attached to her, something Lily went out of her way to explicitly state she was the one who was most experienced with all the smut, almost as if to put all the uncomfortable pedo-shit on her. Those were all her ideas, and not those of the heroic Lily Orchard.

Are we certain Nintendogal isn't another sock-puppet of Lily's she created as a dead-end scapegoat to take the pressure off of her? Because, as we all know, Lily has a habit of creating sockpuppets to either praise herself (Tara) or vent her frustrations openly (Ebara--funny he removed the 'T' from Tara and added an 'EB') so it totally wouldn't be out of character for her to create a 'second author' for this story should she ever need to shift blame to avoid criticism.

The only problem with that is, of course, Lily has never done such a thing. In all the times people have tried to bring up the story or criticize her for writing it, she's never thrown Nintendogal under the bus for it, as far as I can remember. She's instead relied on her self-created and maintained TVTropes page to dispel criticism, rather than blame her writing partner.
Is this not her? This was her last YouTube video from August 2014.


Screen Shot 2020-12-07 at 9.36.53 AM.png

She is apparently still active on most social media.

Not so much in others.
 
Last edited:
So I had a teeny bit of a revelation while thinking about that Jerry/Alchorative post I made.

Remember when Jerry said that "people have been labeling me as a pedophile for 8 years and it hasn't stuck"?

"They've been doing that for eight years now and it hasn't stuck."
If people have consistently been labeling you a pedophile for writing underage smut for eight years now with proof, I think it's safe to say it's more or less "stuck". Lmfao

Even in those threads and QRTs I've seen people be presented the evidence and go "well shit, didn't know that!"

Sorry Jerry!

I thought that was odd, seeing as how Stockholm was published in 2014. This is something I've seen rather often, actually, when Jerry talks about pedophilia accusations, he always overshoots the time frame of when people were first accusing him of being a pedophile (and I can't be assed to find the other posts where he does this, so for the time being, Source(s): Dude trust me, but if you want to find it yourself, I think the post I'm thinking of was made during the Toonkriticy2k pedo stuff).

I know already that Jerry has problems remembering dates and times, whether on purpose or not, but this 8 year thing would mean that either Jerry genuinely misremembered when Stockholm was published, or that he purposefully misremembered when Stockholm was published to throw people off the trail, or maaaaaaaybe...

1607365890399.png


He correctly remembered when he wrote his first MLP underage smutfic.
By the way, the reviews are archived too, and they're exactly how you would expect lol

I don't think this is definitive, silver-bullet type proof of anything (in fact it's very circumstantial, in spite of the fact that he always overshoots the time frame, like I said before), but it was an interesting thing I noticed. I don't think there's anything else storywise from Jerry at that time, so it's possible he slipped up and indirectly referred to this.
 
Last edited:
So I had a teeny bit of a revelation while thinking about that Jerry/Alchorative post I made.

Remember when Jerry said that "people have been labeling me as a pedophile for 8 years and it hasn't stuck"?



I thought that was odd, seeing as how Stockholm was published in 2014. This is something I've seen rather often, actually, when Jerry talks about pedophilia accusations, he always overshoots the time frame of when people were first accusing him of being a pedophile (and I can't be assed to find the other posts where he does this, so for the time being, Source(s): Dude trust me, but if you want to find it yourself, I think the post I'm thinking of was made during the Toonkriticy2k pedo stuff).

I know already that Jerry has problems remembering dates and times, whether on purpose or not, but this 8 year thing would mean that either Jerry genuinely misremembered when Stockholm was published, or that he purposefully misremembered when Stockholm was published to throw people off the trail, or maaaaaaaybe...

View attachment 1772749

He correctly remembered when he wrote his first MLP underage smutfic.
By the way, the reviews are archived too, and they're exactly how you would expect lol

I don't think this is definitive, silver-bullet type proof of anything, but it was an interesting thing I noticed. I don't think there's anything else storywise from Jerry at that time, so it's possible he slipped up and indirectly referred to this.
Oh boy, Nyx...
For those who don't know, Nyx is an original character from a rather popular MLP fanfic called "Past Sins".
So not only did Lily write porn about Twilight fucking her adoptive daughter, she used someone else's OC for it.
 
So I had a teeny bit of a revelation while thinking about that Jerry/Alchorative post I made.

Remember when Jerry said that "people have been labeling me as a pedophile for 8 years and it hasn't stuck"?



I thought that was odd, seeing as how Stockholm was published in 2014. This is something I've seen rather often, actually, when Jerry talks about pedophilia accusations, he always overshoots the time frame of when people were first accusing him of being a pedophile (and I can't be assed to find the other posts where he does this, so for the time being, Source(s): Dude trust me, but if you want to find it yourself, I think the post I'm thinking of was made during the Toonkriticy2k pedo stuff).

I know already that Jerry has problems remembering dates and times, whether on purpose or not, but this 8 year thing would mean that either Jerry genuinely misremembered when Stockholm was published, or that he purposefully misremembered when Stockholm was published to throw people off the trail, or maaaaaaaybe...

View attachment 1772749

He correctly remembered when he wrote his first MLP underage smutfic.
By the way, the reviews are archived too, and they're exactly how you would expect lol

I don't think this is definitive, silver-bullet type proof of anything (in fact it's very circumstantial, in spite of the fact that he always overshoots the time frame, like I said before), but it was an interesting thing I noticed. I don't think there's anything else storywise from Jerry at that time, so it's possible he slipped up and indirectly referred to this.
Lily's only luck is that she doesn't have a recording or conversation in a arquive with a minor, as in the case of pedophiles who are exposed, she only has these fanfics and posts that show a clear tendency and desire but it seems that it is not enough to convince her audience or they just say ""it's just fiction and it's been so long she doesn't think like that anymore"

or maybe they are just lazy and prefer to believe in Lily instead of the evidence

and also, Lily must hate Twilight, she is only portrayed as a horrible person and Lily even transferred the story and context of Ascentia's abuse to Tale of the Valkyrie universe too
 
Lily's only luck is that she doesn't have a recording or conversation in a arquive with a minor, as in the case of pedophiles who are exposed, she only has these fanfics and posts that show a clear tendency and desire but it seems that it is not enough to convince her audience or they just say ""it's just fiction and it's been so long she doesn't think like that anymore"

or maybe they are just lazy and prefer to believe in Lily instead of the evidence

and also, Lily must hate Twilight, she is only portrayed as a horrible person and Lily even transferred the story and context of Ascentia's abuse to Tale of the Valkyrie universe too
Lily definitely hates Twilight
She starts a fullblown rant about her at about 10:10 of this video
Going on about how Twilight comes off as an abusive manipulator because she makes friends with new people she meets without becoming permanently glued to their sides, and that she collects them purely to satisfy her ego and then abandones them. Because clearly she couldn't just be keeping up with her non-plot relevant relationships off-screen.

To me it all sounds like Lily projecting her own incredible neediness and narcissism onto those characters
We know that she expects the people in her life to be available to her 24/7 and to never ever deny her something
She bitched about Mikaila getting a job because it meant that she wouldn't have 24/7 access to her anymore
And she threw a fit about Lizzy being unwilling to upend her entire life, so she could move in with her for a year
 
This is backwards. Being asexual means you don't have a sex drive (and have no psychological need for sex-- there's a difference between being asexual and having a sexual dysfunction, too). Ace people can fully have and enjoy sex (although there are many that are repulsed by it), but the defining factor is that it isn't something they have a desire for. Sexually active asexuals (yeah, I know) are generally ambivalent toward sex but engage because it fulfills a need for their partner.

They can still experience physical attraction but divorced of the sexual aspect. And none of it means they can't make sexual innuendos and jokes; those are just part of the popular consciousness and even if you're sex repulsed, at this juncture you'll still understand what '69 lol' means.

All that said this actually makes that Machoke comic even weirder? By the look Lily is giving Mikaila, Mikaila has either made a similar joke before or knows that Lily doesn't like joking in this manner. Why would she say something like this with no prompt? If the two of them had some kind of goofy sexual puns (like they kept walking down the street and saw more Pokemon they could pun off of) it might be a silly and almost cute (if... uncomfortable) gag. Instead Mikaila says something that Lily obvious disapproves of and then says 'Don't leave me'.

I guess this might be trying to catch on to that thing where somebody makes a supremely bad joke and then excuses themselves from the room, but the expressions between these two characters -- Lily's silent fury and disapproval, Mikaila's wide-eyed terror in the last panel -- speak to a very different relationship and it's simply baffling instead of being... I assume she was going for cute.
You're right my apologies, I'll be honest asexuality is rather confusing but my original point still stands. Mikala is definitely sexually active. She's the one whos drawn a majority of Lilys porn, she actively thirsts after characters, and I believe Lily has said a couple times that her and Mik have had sex/done sexual things together.

We have no real reason to believe Mik isnt asexual but we also have no real reason to believe lily is a lesbian, after all Lily has said that she might be sexually interested in men a couple times. So we can be correct about the definition of asexuality all day but i dont think its an accurate descriptor of Mik based off of her actions.

Can we actually believe Lily when she claims that her parents and her siblings are abusive?
As everyone else has said, no. But im not saying her parents are actually abusive, Im saying that's what lily thinks. She's convinced herself that everyone (not just her family) is out to get her and that even the slightest bit of criticism is raging abuse. So it's not that Lilys parents are abusive but rather thats what she thinks they are. Once you think something for long enough it starts to become true in your brain, and since Lily has pretty much cut off communication with her family theres no doubt in my mind its cemented in hers that she thinks her parents were abusive.
 
Last edited:
Her thread talks about a slight deep in subs. But a 1k drop all at once? Does that lean into a mass culling of ghost/dead/bot accounts?
lily count.jpg

sub count.png


Her subs are at 120k dead and that exact number reek of manipulation to me, not to get all tinfoil hat about it. Anyone else?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ColdArmadillo288
Her thread talks about a slight deep in subs. But a 1k drop all at once? Does that lean into a mass culling of ghost/dead/bot accounts?
View attachment 1773421
View attachment 1773423

Her subs are at 120k dead and that exact number reek of manipulation to me, not to get all tinfoil hat about it. Anyone else?

It's a new YouTube thing. Every channel's subscriber count rounds down to three visible digits. In reality, Lily has over 120K subscribers. For all we know, that 1K drop could've been a single user and now she has 120,999. YouTube's just dumb like that.
 
This is a interesting chapter, not only because we’re finally first seeing Rainbow’s true face but also because we will see how this fic and the Sith one connect.

Chapter 6: Count of Monte Christo Style Vengance

+Fluttershy is watching Applejack and Rainbow having a snowball match. Apple Bloom is there to ask Fluttershy why Rainbow “walks like Big Macintosh and Princess Twilight’s brother does”. Apple Bloom even comments that it seems like if she kicked Rainbow on the crotch she would react like a guy does and Fluttershy tells her is not funny.

+She doesn’t really respond the question beyond “Well, Rainbow is how she is… I suppose some would think of it like that”. Next Apple Bloom question if Rainbow is gay because she wants to ask someone more experienced about her relationship with Sweetie Bell. Eventually Apple Bloom tells her about Sweetie Bell trying to lick her tongue while kissing and Fluttershy explains to her what french kissing is, how it’s not really how the French kiss (really), how it’s a “spicy kiss” and how her body can take the germs from another’s tongue and she shouldn’t worry about that. Apple Bloom keeps asking her about french kissing and Fluttershy keeps telling her about “you do have to keep in mind that your breath and your partern’s breath will be a part of the equation, especially the flavours in your mouths. But if you can get past all of that, it’s lovely”, which Apple Bloom finds pleasant at least.

+Next Apple Bloom ask if it’s normal that sometimes she wants to see Sweetie Bell naked. Fluttershy say that is just her hormones kicking in and she find Sweetie Bell sexually attractive, but because Apple Bloom still doesn’t get it, even though it’s nothing that complicated, Fluttershy rephrase it as “You’re growing up into more of a woman and becoming more aware of sex”. Apple Bloom doen’t know about sex between two women so Fluttershy starts to explain to her about sex toys used to simulate a penis and how you can use your fingers and mouth to stimulate your partners. She does add that whatever sexual thing they decide to do has to be done consensually. Apple Bloom wants to talk to Twilight and Ascentia too, but Fluttershy advice her not to because their methods are not for everybody.

+The snowball match finishes and Apple Bloom goes to talk to Rainbow in private. She asks her if she is gay and shen Rainbow say yes, Apple Bloom asks her how did she knew. Rainbow just say that she looked in the mirror one day and that is how she knew she was gay… so I guess the implication is that she felt sexually attracted to her reflection. Apple Bloom wants to know because she thinks she might be gay and not only wants Sweetie Bell to take off her clothes, but she has also been watching the porn magazines that Big Mac saved under his bed. Apple Bloom is scared because of his granny. She mentions how she got very upset very fast when there were rumours of Applejack hooking up with Rainbow, and for some reason this is the momento the narration decides to do a little PSA about the older generation being bad.

“Rainbow was partially reminded of some older ponies slipping out racist comments around ponies like Zecora. Not so much mean, but holding attitudes that they were probably raised with that were inappropriate all the same.”

+Why does she even say ponies there? This is a human AU. Maybe in this universe humans are called ponies, I don’t know.

+Rainbow give this piece of advice that wouldn’t really help a preteen on this situation at all:

“Kid, your granny’s a bit of an old soul. Old school, traditional raising kinda thing,” Rainbow waved it off, “I understand you guys want to respect her wishes and all… but that’s a two way street. And not to say any real disrespect to dead people or oldies who are at death’s door, but think about it. She’s gonna be gone sometime, then it won’t even matter. Life’s too short, kid. Don’t turn it around to please someone else when you’re unhappy.”

+The phrase "old soul" usually refers to someone that is wiser than their actual years, especially if they are youngr. It doesn’t apply to a 90 year old granny.

“Hey, come on, no need to be scared! You make it sound like she’s that grandmother from that book Fluttershy had me read once, where she locked kids in the attic…” Rainbow chuckled, hugging her back, “If you’re gay and you feel this way about Sweetie Belle, just go for it. If you have to, just be honest with her about how you feel. It’s scary, believe me, I know. Took me well over a decade to even come clean to Fluttershy, and she’s my best friend, I tell her everything. Still, it made me realize that it feels a lot better to be honest about how you feel. If your ol’ grandma’s gonna take it badly, that’s her problem. Just take it and keep your chin up. We can’t help who we want to be with, sleep with, and all that jazz, anyway.”



“I know, but… I’m afraid Granny won’t love me anymore…” she said, her eyes watering a little.



“You’re her Granddaughter, she’s always loved you. If she won’t love you because you’re gay, then she never loved you at all. Kid, it’s gonna be okay,” Rainbow assured her, “Besides, you’ve still got AJ, Big Mac, Scootaloo, Sweetie Belle, Fluttershy, me, and the rest of us. You’re not gonna be alone, kid. Promise.”

+That book Rainbow is talking is a reference to Flowers In The Attic, the first on a series of novels that became infamous for treating dark subjects and especially because of the incestuous relationship between the older brother and older sister. I don’t know if Liliana actually read the book or just heard what is about, but if she did I wouldn’t be surprised if she didn’t wanted that to become well known.

+This happens:

“I… I wanna… sleep with Sweetie Belle,” she blushed.



“Everyone wants to sleep with Sweetie Belle. Sweetie Belle’s adorable,” Rainbow chuckled.

+I’m becoming increasingly uncomfortable with the use that “adorable” is given in this fic. Ignoring the red flag, Apple Bloom then asks Rainbow if she can fuck Sweetie Bell at her house because they won’t have privacy at hers. Rainbow accepts, like a creep. Apple Bloom is ever so grateful.

+Getting back with Fluttershy, Rainbow tells her about what they talked about and the plan of Apple Bloom, adding “Don’t want my house being a haven for teenage lesbians to roll around naked in… actually on reflection I’d be very okay with that.” Taking advantage of the fact Fluttershy still thinks this is all a joke, she adds:

“I wouldn’t try anything, I’m not a complete perv,” Rainbow chuckled, “I’d just enjoy the view… and maybe take pictures. No wait, that’s illegal, forget that. I’d just enjoy the view.”

+Fluttershy comments that Rainbow surely wished she could do something like that when she was about Apple Bloom’s age, and Rainbow goes on a little rant about how all girls dressed too slutty and were throwing their tits and asses to her face all the time when they were younger. She mentions how she would openly defend the boys who were creeps having erections on the middle of the class because she understood what was that like, what a problem was to be surrounded by females and not get aroused. Maybe those guys were lesbians too! That would have explained it better why they couldn’t contain themselves!

+Anyway, Rainbow keeps talking about how hot it’s for her the idea of having two preteens that now they are saying are 14 because I guess Liliana forgot what she said before fucking at her house. Fluttershy say that it’s fine, they are just fantasies and as long she doesn’t break the law, which she is sure Rainbow will never do, it’s okay. Spoiler alert: she does break the law.

+“So you’re saying you have no problem with me oogling AJ’s little sister?” Rainbow asked.



Fluttershy smiled, “I said I didn’t want to share you. I didn’t say you couldn’t look. Just don’t make her uncomfortable about it and it’ll be fine.”



Rainbow’s eyes widened, “Damn Shy, you’re darker than I am,” she chuckled, “Next thing I hear, you’re gonna be asking me to describe my twisted fantasies.”



“We can save that for next time,” Fluttershy kissed her nose.



“I don’t know whether to kiss you, call the cops, or both,” Rainbow snickered, “Oh… we’re awful.”

+Everyone talks a lot about Rainbow’s pedophilia and such, but I don’t think people appreciate enough the way it’s treated on fic. Fluttershy is basically a MAP supporter here and a enabler too at that.

+Later they are at Rainbow’s house. Fluttershy is horny and kissing Rainbow.

“This must be what my dolls felt like when I was little and smacking their faces together,” Rainbow panted, biting at Fluttershy’s neck, “Just screaming ‘NOW KISS!’

+This is the second time this analogy happens on this fic. The first times was used by Ascentia refering to Rainbow and Fluttershy. Now Rainbow uses it about herself and Fluttershy because she is a narcissistic plagiarist creep.

+They have a dirty talk in which Rainbow suggest that Fluttershy fucks the critters so they listen to her and Fluttershy say that no, she prefers tentacles and Rainbow say this is cliche. Fluttershy now says that because she shared one fantasy, Rainbow has to do it. This is the moment in which Rainbow confesses that she has masturbated fantasizing about the Crusaders before and Fluttershy, to add more insult to injury, says she already suspected that.

“You don’t have to worry. I mean, it’s not something you should ever say at the dinner table or even to the ones in question, but it’s all right. Just be glad you’re doing that and not molesting them.”



Rainbow covered her eyes with her hands, “It’s embarrassing, though. Alright, your turn again.”

+Having sexual fantasies about kids you have known since they were toddlers is “embarassing”. Not sick. Not disgustig. Not wrong. Embarassing. Let that sink in.

+The next fantasy of Fluttershy is to have wings and being able to fly, as a reference to the wings her pony-pony version has unlike this pony-human version. Next is the turn of Rainbow and you won’t ever believe what it is.

“...Incest.”



“Really?” Fluttershy asked, “I thought you hated your parents.”



“Not my actual family,” Rainbow scoffed, “Just… what if scenarios. Like what if you and I were sisters? What if I was Cheerilee’s daughter? What if…” her words were covered by a very unconvincing cough, “...was actually my sister instead of just… you get the idea.”



Fluttershy giggled, “I see what you mean. I’m an only child, but… it certainly is something interesting to think about. Oh, but if we were sisters… I think we might’ve done this a long time ago.”



Rainbow blushed, “Oh really? How do you figure?”



“If we were close since we were kids as friends, I can only imagine we’d be closer if we lived under the same roof together,” Fluttershy nuzzled her neck, “Playing doctor… taking baths together, growing up together… learning about our bodies…”

+Sounds familiar?

+Fluttershy gets on the fantasy and she makes this whole scenario about how their parents would find out and they would get punished, but they still couldn’t stop seeing each other at their backs until they got caught a second time. Then they would get separated as Rainbow is send to a relative’s home and Fluttershy is so sad, missing my only and wonderful sister, and everything we’ve shared”, until they are all grown up and their parents understand that they made a mistake by keeping them appart so now, in order to compensate them, they are going to pay for a incestuous wedding. The final fantasy, that is from Fluttershy, is to take classy nudes and the scene ends.

+We move now to Sweetie Bell and Apple Bloom having a date. Apple Bloom tells her that she wants to have sex, something Sweetie Bell is all up for because she read some porn books of Rarity and thinks she knows what to do, but she reacts less enthusiastically when Apple Bloom tell her that they were going to have sex on Rainbow’s house.

“Oh… Okay,” Sweetie Belle squirmed a bit, “I don’t know, what if she watches us? ...Sometimes I see her looking at me, or any of us….with that weird look in her eyes… The same looks I see her giving Fluttershy… Are you sure it’s safe?”



“What?!” Apple Bloom was genuinely surprised, “Are you sure? I’ve never noticed that before…”



“I know it sounds weird, but trust me… she does that!” Sweetie Belle nodded, “It’s a little creepy… I mean, she looks at Fluttershy like she wants to eat her alive...okay, wait, bad comparison! Kinda like she wants her bad and like she’s on top of the world. When she looks at us, it’s like… I don’t know, like we’re candy or something. She doesn’t do anything and she doesn’t say anything, but I feel kinda weird… Still, I guess it’s nice she’s letting us use her place!”



“Well… if you don’t feel safe going there, we don’t have to,” Apple Bloom said dejectedly, “But I don’t think it’d be safe doing it at my house… or yours…”



Sweetie Belle shook her head, “No, we can! I’m sorry, I just kinda felt a little weird. I know she’s not a pedophile, anyway. So… when do you want to do this?”

+They’re both very excited about losing their virginities. Apple Bloom tells Sweetie Bell that she loves her and Sweetie reciprocates, so they kiss and are find out by Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon.

+What comes next is a long and boring scene in which I think Liliana had one big “this is how the show should have handled it” moment, so I’m going to summarize it the best I can:


+Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon took a picture of them kissing and threaten to tell the granny. Apple Bloom is terrified, but Sweetie Bell keeps mocking them and angering more to the point that she just yells for Rainbow and Fluttershy, who are conveniently nearby, to intervene. They come and tell the girls that is not a good thing to do. Then Twilight and Ascentia appear. Ascentia is a creep.

“You’re not going anywhere,” Twilight growled, “You young ladies have a lot to answer for.”



“Oooh! Are we gonna ‘Interrogate’ them?” Ascentia asked delightedly.



“They’re 14, Ascentia,” Twilight said with a scowl.



“...Killjoy.”

+Instead of doing what I imagine Tara would have done, Ascentia talks to Diamond Tiara in a way that convinces her that if she doesn’t stop bullying Apple Bloom her family will go bankrup and Rainbow name drops the title of the chapter while praising her. There is a lot more dialogue that I don’t care about in which all these four adults verbally gang up on these two little girls, psychoanalyzing Silver Spoon to the point she is too ashamed to want to bully again.

“Does this count as bullying kids?” Ascentia asked.



“Who the fuck cares,” Rainbow snarled.

+They discover that Silver Spoon has daddy issues and that is why she hangs with Diamond Tiara, and Diamond Tiara doesn’t know how to be affectionate because nobody is affectionate on her house and they are saying all of this in the middle of the street. This all ends with Sweetie Bell telling them to be friends and they accept.

“If ya want mah opinion,” Apple Bloom chimed in, “I’m perfectly fine with that. We’ll be yer friends. Everyone deserves a second chance.”



“Or in your case a ninety-sixth,” Ascentia commented,

+Twilight smacks her on the head. Ascentia complains that she had a concussion, pressumably from the last chapter where she had her head hit a wooden table and then somehow still had an orgy. I don’t think Liliana knows what a concussion is.

+The bullies apoligizes. Sweetie Bell tell them that they have a lot of issues and they should go to a doctor, although I don’t know why if they already spilled everything right there and then. She also gives them an assigment to each write a list of all the things they like about the other and read to each other on Monday. Then Fluttershy tells Diamond Tiara to go talk with her father. Then they go and everyone goes back to what they were doing. Apple Bloom and Sweetie Bell have this conversation to end the chapter.

“Still worried Rainbow might be watchin’ us?” she asked.



“Nah, I’m not scared!” Sweetie Belle waved it off, “She’s known us since we were a lot younger and she’s always been awesome to us. I don’t think we have anything to worry about! First thing tomorrow, it’s going to be just you and me, for our big day!”

+To be young again and not know what grooming is.

Next Chapter: Dateless When We Turn 16

Estimated time remaining: 9 Hours, 8 Minutes
 
  • Feels
Reactions: SubarashiiRage
So I had a teeny bit of a revelation while thinking about that Jerry/Alchorative post I made.

Remember when Jerry said that "people have been labeling me as a pedophile for 8 years and it hasn't stuck"?



I thought that was odd, seeing as how Stockholm was published in 2014. This is something I've seen rather often, actually, when Jerry talks about pedophilia accusations, he always overshoots the time frame of when people were first accusing him of being a pedophile (and I can't be assed to find the other posts where he does this, so for the time being, Source(s): Dude trust me, but if you want to find it yourself, I think the post I'm thinking of was made during the Toonkriticy2k pedo stuff).

I know already that Jerry has problems remembering dates and times, whether on purpose or not, but this 8 year thing would mean that either Jerry genuinely misremembered when Stockholm was published, or that he purposefully misremembered when Stockholm was published to throw people off the trail, or maaaaaaaybe...

View attachment 1772749

He correctly remembered when he wrote his first MLP underage smutfic.
By the way, the reviews are archived too, and they're exactly how you would expect lol

I don't think this is definitive, silver-bullet type proof of anything (in fact it's very circumstantial, in spite of the fact that he always overshoots the time frame, like I said before), but it was an interesting thing I noticed. I don't think there's anything else storywise from Jerry at that time, so it's possible he slipped up and indirectly referred to this.

Nice find. But are we sure it's her? The account details kinda don't match up unless she was identifying as trans way longer before i realized. Pluse the only people who commented calling her by her dead name seem recent as if you look at the dates. Unless im dumb these are from this year as no year is listed like comments below. So...?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20201208_053222.jpg
    IMG_20201208_053222.jpg
    58 KB · Views: 97
  • IMG_20201208_053147.jpg
    IMG_20201208_053147.jpg
    95.9 KB · Views: 84
Back