Going back to my Mark of Cain autism, you could argue that Phil is already being punished. Let's look at the Biblical story that I'm drawing from here, rather than killing Cain right away as punishment for killing his brother and lying about it to God, God made it so that the Mark protected Cain from premature death from any source, as God wanted to make him live in suffering, as the Mark makes it that anything he does and anyone he interacts with would suffer a great disaster, kind of like how the DSP Autism Vortex (aka The Mark of Dave) D'VOURS, chews up and spits out anything and anyone who dares directly interact with him.
I mean look at his life - his only "legacy" and accomplishment is the fact that he somehow still exists on the internet despite completely losing his popularity early in his career. He's a complete laughingstock to almost everyone that even knows about him and that just eats away at him. He's got no drive, no real ambition in life except existing. He's got no friends, he coops himself up in his house almost all week, the only interaction he has outside of his wheelchairs on-stream are his dopey wife and Punished "Venom" Jasper - A Cat Denied His Claws. I can go on but there's this big archive of his failings, almost 7000 pages long you might say.
Finally, one part of the Mark of Cain is that any soil that Cain would try working would bear no yield. No matter how much money Phil gets it all goes to his collection of worthless jpegs that are stored somewhere on the internet that have no further monetary value. He can't trade those jpegs, he can't sell his account, and one day the game will be shut off permanently, cementing that he threw money into a bottomless pit. There is no "yield" from his investment, that's why begging resumes every stream, no matter if he got 10 dollars or 10k dollars on the previous stream. You could also compare his gacha financial black hole and the immediate retconning of any funds he got on the previous stream to the punishment of Sisyphus, since all the "work" Phil puts into streaming is futile if you think about it because even after his credit card debt got cleared he's still back here begging like it never got granted in the first place, but my 'tismpost is already getting longer than it should. Maybe next time.