God I can just imagine, Penny staring off into the void, his sleep deprived mind drifting from his lack of dilations, and Bonnie's fucking awful cooking, causing him to get visions of this Earl in the dark, dancing around like a shadow. Then he starts getting delusions, he finds a wrapper on the tranch, of, OH GOD, EARL GREY TEA. EARL!!
Next thing you know, he finds some dude who doesn't like the tranch, also named Earl, and now hes dead set that this is the person who is shadow dancing at night. And if you dare ask for prove, your a nazi.