The Trial of Derek Chauvin - Judgement(?) Day(?) has arrived!

[Top Skink]

The difference is she deserves the charge.

View attachment 2087259

Sam Hyde - Female Cops

from PGL_05. sub to sam for only 5 bucks and get the full 2 hour episode + all hydewars and other content https://mde.tvhttps://gumroad.com/samhyde

youtu.be

>vid less than a month old

 

[Meat Target]

I just started listening... could someone please fill me in on what happened so far today?

Saffer doctor on the stand is going over other factors, including Floyd's arteries and proximity to carbon monoxide from the squad car.

 

[Ari Gold]

The judge should work at a mechanic. He has breaks for days.

Nelson is reading this thread....

Edit: "Are you a mechanic?"
Edit 2: This carbon monoxide poisoning defense is a bold move cotton, let's see how it plays out.

 

[7he47r0n]

It could be an interesting one to decide if it rises to the level of culpable negligence. It was clearly the height of incompetence and an utter fuck up that lead to a death but there will be something for the defence to go for.

- "Your Honour, she's a woman. And somebody gave her a gun."
- "The defence is correct. Arrest her superiors."

 

[DumbDude42]

Sneedbar on the thread, but the officer who shot Daunte Wight is charged with second degree manslaughter.
eta fuckin ninjas

she literally pulled her gun and shot the guy dead, and is trying to argue that she mistook the gun for a tazer lmao
now there's a case where a murder charge might actually be warranted cause that tazer excuse seems kinda sketchy to me

 

[aussiejinjo]

the carbon monoxide thing seems like a great curve ball tbh

 

[Blobby's Murder Knife]

They've latched on to the lizard guy saying that the body created new blood vessels to redirect blood around a blockage and are taking it to it's retarded extreme, which is precisely what the prosecution wanted the jury to do, ignoring that new blood vessels != a fucking artery and that it's objectively not "fine". You may be able to live your normal sedentary life, but at some point something will tip you over the edge into sneedsville

The state of education in the US.

 

[Carbonation Grimace]

Sam Hyde - Female Cops

from PGL_05. sub to sam for only 5 bucks and get the full 2 hour episode + all hydewars and other content https://mde.tvhttps://gumroad.com/samhyde

youtu.be

>vid less than a month old

the carbon monoxide thing seems like a great curve ball tbh

Not really. This is extremely short sighted, because the prosecution can come back swinging with "Oh ok, yeah the carbon monoxide did it. So Chauvin is guilty of manslaughter because he was negligent when arresting floyd."

 

[7he47r0n]

The defence's strategy is very cunning, I must admit. Mr. Nelson is positing that Mr. Floyd's death is simply the result of a large number of unfortunate, intermingling factors. Thus the prosecutor must waste time and effort trying to take down, or bring into doubt, every single one of them.

 

[Probably An Autist]

she literally pulled her gun and shot the guy dead, and is trying to argue that she mistook the gun for a tazer lmao
now there's a case where a murder charge might actually be warranted cause that tazer excuse seems kinda sketchy to me

Her reaction makes it look unintentional, so I'm willing to buy her shitty excuse.
She should absolutely get a manslaughter charge IMO.

also your pfp looks identical to a troon i know its really unsettling

 

[KiwiFuzz]

What happened to the last officer who shot someone instead of tasing?

Johannes Mesehrle (who killed Oscar Grant on the BART platform at Fruitvale Station) got two years including time served. And I don't think he's been able to work since.

 

[Probably An Autist]

Not really. This is extremely short sighted, because the prosecution can come back swinging with "Oh ok, yeah the carbon monoxide did it. So Chauvin is guilty of manslaughter because he was negligent when arresting floyd."

The way I'm interpreting it is that its a factor only because of all the other mitigating circumstances around his heart condition. As with everything else, a normal person wouldn't die from it.
Thats my take

 

[Top Skink]

Not really. This is extremely short sighted, because the prosecution can come back swinging with "Oh ok, yeah the carbon monoxide did it. So Chauvin is guilty of manslaughter because he was negligent when arresting floyd."

not really this either, they never criticized the actual act of putting him on the ground (obviously, since he's the one who did it) and have never themselves mentioned this. If they just suddenly go "oh yeah, we were wrong it's what the defense said!" they've obviously already lost. At this point in the trial, pros has made their case, the job is to minimize and discredit the defense trying to poke holes in their story. If they actively change the story based on what the defense says, no jury would convict, and for obvious reasons.

 

[Coccxys]

He got two years including time served. And I don't think he's been able to work since.

Yeah just looked it up. It was involuntary manslaughter rather than any of the more serious charges so I wonder how the two state's wordings differ here. Either way she'll probably get some nice please deal that involves never seeing a cell.

 

[7he47r0n]

"Even whilst dying, Mr. Floyd was actively getting high on carbon monoxide", says the expert. A fighter, until his last breath.

 

[aussiejinjo]

The defence's strategy is very cunning, I must admit. Mr. Nelson is positing that Mr. Floyd's death is simply the result of a large number of unfortunate, intermingling factors. Thus the prosecutor must waste time and effort trying to take down, or bring into doubt, every single one of them.

this

they are introducing as many sources of doubt as they possibly can, as well they should

in most legal cases reasonable doubt is about stacking up pebbles to make a mountain, not throwing down one gigantic boulder

they call it the compounding of probabilities, the carbon monoxide angle, while weak by itself, is another pebble on the pile, and the defense absolutely knows what it's doing by introducing it into the evidence

 

[Extreme Aneurysm]

Here’s my depiction of Eric Nelson sacrificing a break to the Break God...

 

[Carbonation Grimace]

I've been trying to figure out the resemblance for days and now I cannot unsee it.

 

[Fields Of Rye]

Not really. This is extremely short sighted, because the prosecution can come back swinging with "Oh ok, yeah the carbon monoxide did it. So Chauvin is guilty of manslaughter because he was negligent when arresting floyd."

So, I think this is a bit of a red herring, and is meant to make the prosecution take a weak argument

There's absolutely no way that short a time could fuck up a normal person. And there's no way Chauvin could know how fucked Floyd was.

What the Jury would be faced with is "does a man deserve to go to jail because he did his job next to a car"

 

[murdered meat bag]

the carbon monoxide thing seems like a great curve ball tbh

wait til cross. i wouldbt be surprised if it boils down to pure speculation, since they wete at the front of the car. i guess the manifold could leak but without a mechanic report its just hypothetical