Inactive Andrew Dobson / Tom Preston / CattyN - STOP DOING SEXIST CRAP

At surface value, nothing seems really wrong with his art, and I have said in the past that there is a bit of a charm to it.
I’ll agree some of his earlier art was charming, like his Nintendo-based fanart pieces he would put out in his DA days, but his more recent stuff?
D61CC700-091C-498F-A871-FC9870744A79.png

7FF71279-777A-4404-AF9A-F886E9A808F4.jpeg

8152A07A-8103-4C99-AACE-9FD610EE211A.jpeg

Hard disagree.
It’s not just that the art is flawed; the overuse of detail lines, the stiff, awkward posing and obvious refusal to use a reference are easy to point out. There’s just something uniquely terrible about it in a way you can instantly point out his work among a sea of other artists.

The development of his art style from his faux-Rumiko Takahashi days up to when he disappeared is like what happens when you stick a banana that’s well overripe in a jar, and then allow that banana to sit and fester untouched in the jar for years. At first the banana was kind of brown and a little unsightly but it was still okay to eat, but keeping it in a closed-off, unsuitable environment for so long allowed it to develop increasingly virulent mold variants and rot into something unrecognizable. And also develop an obsession with lesbians. Scientists are still unable to explain this.

Basically my point here is that he closed himself off from learning, practice and critique for so long that his art mutated for the worse in the vacuum he himself created. It’s not just his attitude that sullies his artwork.
 
He's definitely out there but it's still funny that while he believes people are obsessed with him, they are so obsessed nobody cares much about actually trying to find him at all
Well, this thread is active after more than a year of him vanishing, so there's that.

But admittedly, this thread is more about people sitting around a fire and sharing Hat Andy stories and remembering the good times. Like when he was sprayed with water at a con and thought it was piss, cause the water mixed with his sweat and gave off a weird smell. Best part, he was actually dumb enough to share that last bit of info on his social media.
Dobbo, you read these threads so, hey, do anything you need for as long as you need to.
Funny thing about this: Either he doesn't read it and there is nothing lost -or- he does read it and he's freaked out and annoyed.
It's like saying "I know perfectly well that you're listening in on me" in an empty room. Either no one will ever know or you'll freak out whoever is eavesdropping.
obvious refusal to use a reference
Dobson is really weird how he refused to use references on one hand, but will happily trace art and photos. Like the last comic you linked, the image of Rey is so obviously traced from a photo.

picard fade.gifhank hill fade.gif

The thing about that picard image that really slays me though:
He so obviously used a photo to trace his """art""", yet the finished product looks N O T H I N G like Patrick Stewart.
The shadow on the jawline, the position of the ear and right eye, the dome of the head, the left shoulder, all of this is a perfect fit.
There is NO doubt about him tracing or not.

Yet he fucked up so badly in so many other areas: The chin, the neck, the right shoulder, the left eye, the nose... For some odd reason he mirrored the original image, I sincerely hope that wasn't his attempt to hide the fact he traced it... cause that half-assed attempt at subterfuge would just be sad.

Hank Hill is also a weird tale. He traced the head regularly, but he made the body a lot shorter than the original by squashing it shorter than it was.

Have another instance of him tracing:
THIS IS MY HOUSE.png
An Artwortk depicting a house from Skyrim... with an actual screenshot overlayed. Well gee.
It's pretty obvious that he used a similar screenshot to the one I found online. I had to fiddle around with the aspect ratio of the screenshot to make it fit, but once it fit, every shingle, every rock, every tuft of moss, every step, every stone, every beam lined up almost perfectly. The weird thing about that image is that the sightlines are wonky as fuck. It's the easiest part of the whole process and he fucked it up.
 
Sorry if I'm coming across as A-Loggy here, but Dobson is the stereotypical cuck that would fling himself into a puddle and get stepped on if it meant that he got to watch when two lesbians make out.


I have a theory, though, that this path of being a shameless social justice warrior is linked to him losing the only woman who'd give him the time of day leaving his ass.
His crusade of 'RESPECKING WIMMEN' is most likely his weird way of atoning for being an ass to her.
Unfortunately, in true Dobson fashion, he probably came to the conclusion that his being an ass was somehow linked to him being a cisgendered, white male. It's not his fault, his genes are to blame!


I mean, that's only a theory on my end, but would you really put it past Dobson?
 
I have never seen this show, but aren't they mother and daughter?
No. Marinette is half chinese and half frenchwhitebread. Kagami is japanese. The girls are near the same age. Kagami was held out as a love interest for Adrien Agreste, who Marinette has a crush on. Dobson of course thinks that lesbuns are the answer and thus ships "Marigami" instead of "Adrienette".

But dear lord those poses are awkward AF.
 
Fliiiiip yoooour canvas! Flip your canvas,
So the pic won't look like ass!
Furry Robin has eyes akimbo
And the smile of a brain-dead himbo
Your outline is slightly hazy
And the color on his muzzle's just lazy.
Worse, the eyebrows make no sense.
Please work on environments,
For you've got too much empty space.
Instead of trying your own pace,
Why not go back to college
To give that art degree some polish?
At the very least, mate,
Learn to control you line weight.

I await my puzzle pieces.
 
Fliiiiip yoooour canvas! Flip your canvas,
So the pic won't look like ass!
Furry Robin has eyes akimbo
And the smile of a brain-dead himbo
Your outline is slightly hazy
And the color on his muzzle's just lazy.
Worse, the eyebrows make no sense.
Please work on environments,
For you've got too much empty space.
Instead of trying your own pace,
Why not go back to college
To give that art degree some polish?
At the very least, mate,
Learn to control you line weight.

I await my puzzle pieces.
what's that to the tune of?
 
I’ll agree some of his earlier art was charming, like his Nintendo-based fanart pieces he would put out in his DA days, but his more recent stuff?
View attachment 2321527
View attachment 2321533
View attachment 2321535
Hard disagree.
It’s not just that the art is flawed; the overuse of detail lines, the stiff, awkward posing and obvious refusal to use a reference are easy to point out. There’s just something uniquely terrible about it in a way you can instantly point out his work among a sea of other artists.

The development of his art style from his faux-Rumiko Takahashi days up to when he disappeared is like what happens when you stick a banana that’s well overripe in a jar, and then allow that banana to sit and fester untouched in the jar for years. At first the banana was kind of brown and a little unsightly but it was still okay to eat, but keeping it in a closed-off, unsuitable environment for so long allowed it to develop increasingly virulent mold variants and rot into something unrecognizable. And also develop an obsession with lesbians. Scientists are still unable to explain this.

Basically my point here is that he closed himself off from learning, practice and critique for so long that his art mutated for the worse in the vacuum he himself created. It’s not just his attitude that sullies his artwork.
When exactly were these artworks made?
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Koby_Fish
Dobson's flaws could easily be overlooked if he wasn't such an outright ass to people.
At surface value, nothing seems really wrong with his art, and I have said in the past that there is a bit of a charm to it.

But because he decided to play holier-than-thou with his opinions, even at people who weren't at all asking to be spit roasted by him, onlookers are far less kind when it comes to critiquing his art and finding every single flaw in it, if only for the reason of putting him in his damn place.

It's like if you took it easy on somebody in a boxing match by tying pillows to your hands, only for said person to start calling you dogshit in front of everyone, prompting you to not only drop the pillows, but load your boxing gloves with horseshoes while you're at it.


So, in essence, Dobson getting trolled and 'obsessed over' is his own damn fault.

Exactly! There are literally hundreds of thousands of terrible, lazy artists out there that nobody fucking cares about since they're not close to Dobby in terms of personality.

Dobby himself wouldn't be as noticed if he stopped being a self absorbed shithead who spergs around like a raging retard all the time! He would just be another low profile artist or some random asshole nobody fucking cares about in deviantart, probably exchanging fetish artwork with Haley in an ultimate Skinner Piss Inflation Crossover lol!
 
Please keep in mind; Dobson's support for LGBT is not some kind of fetish, oh no. It's political. Totally political. Nothing about lipstick lesbians and porn clichées at all.
"Please ignore all of my previous work involving buxom pirate lesbians. Several books worth. That has no bearing on my politics regarding the L in LGBT issues today. Also, please ignore all of my CattyN inflation work. You know what? Please ignore all of my work, forever."
 
It's actually worse than that. If you watch his old animations, a few things stand out:
  1. He does not use a character reference sheet. For example: in the bullying animation (can't find it on YouTube, but Ken Ashcorp put it in his rant about Dobbles; the timestamp should be right), the victim goes from having a sweater and a backpack to just a t-shirt. Additionally, the Bully magically lets go of the victim so he can flinch.
  2. To build on the point above, it may also be that he doesn't storyboard his animation, so he has no clue how the action is supposed to flow and gets scenes mixed up in his head.
  3. He does not use a timing sheet. In animation, a timing sheet is a special chart that allows animators to break down the flow of dialogue and action into a handy frame-by-frame reference. If Dobson's animations look stiff and jerky, this is why. He has no sense of timing, or how long an action is supposed to take place, and no reference to work from, so he's winging it.
As you said, he could have been great if he'd just knuckled down and worked his way up to Disney, but no, in his arrogance he expected the Mouse to accept him right away. If he had been born ten years later, it might've worked out that way (as it did for Alex Hirsch).

And props to Dobbles for keeping his head down for well over a year. Hopefully, the fact that nobody wants to go to the trouble of finding him hammers home how low a view people have of him (if he's still alive.)
The bully animation might be in here.
 
If this was a high-schooler's work, I'd rate pretty good/10. Probably could get you into a college animation program. It's got some issues, mostly in the scene changes, but nothing that can't be fixed by adding a few animations.

Of course, he never improved past this, did he?


It was one of the smoothest animations that he did. The few he did since then have been rough and choppy, like they're missing frames.
The only 'improvement' I see is that later animations he drew were in colour, and that's it.


On a side note, I find it kinda tragic that when he can be assed to do something animation-wise, it's to feed his fetish for lesbians (the Proposal video) or to kiss the ass of social justice warriors (The Adventure Zone video, note that one of the characters is a black lesbian whose design basically screams SJW.)

Screenshot_2.jpg

By the way, sorry if this is late news, but I believe Dobson is still active on Instagram. Note that the account is up, still has content and followers.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not gonna lie, the framerate feels a bit off. It's still pretty good, but I can't help but get some Ali Baba and the Gold Raiders vibes from it.
To be fair to Dobson, this is a reupload of an old video he made of an animation that was probably early college. So some quality may have been lost along the way.
 
Last edited:
Back