No, I agree with you. Every time he brings up a good point, he immediately turns around and shits all over anyone else who tries to go along with it. As I said, his playing a non-Jedi in an all Jedi game is a prime example. Spoony has always struck me as the "alpha nerd," the guy who was slightly better looking and cooler than the other people he hung out with, but it's a matter of degree, like being the smartest kid with Downs syndrome. As soon as he was exposed to the internet at large, he became a small fish in a big pond, and he couldn't handle that.
“Alpha nerd” is such a good term for Noah, because that’s exactly who he is.
Compared to the fat nerd with the acne sitting next to him, Noah is a fucking Chad who might have amazing tales to tell of going to a bar and a getting (a 6 or a 7) girl’s phone number.
Now outside of your typical group of 90ies era nerds, Noah ain’t nothing special. But I’ll bet you he knew he was the Alpha Nerd and enjoyed the fuck out of it.
He was (and is) also the incarnate contrarian, which was probably tied to his Alpha Nerd status.
Just taking the Jedi video as example:
Everyone liked West Ends D6 Star Wars? Pfft! Noah thought it sucked! Fucking lame dude!
Noah is so clearly used to other nerds just nodding and “oh yeah totally! I mean I kinda like it, but yeah you have a point!”
Because nobody wants to start shit with the Alpha nerd, and unlike Noah, the other players are there for a good time, not to mark their territory.
(And btw: How can it be a problem that all the players attack the Sith? Wasn’t there a bunch of Stormtroopers? What were they doing? Scratching their balls and watching the fight? None of this would be a problem for a smart DM to deal with. Except for maybe players going after Darth Vader, which is exactly what you’d expect in a cinematic RPG like SW, lol!
Like most of his RPG stories it boils down to Noah either being a dick or not understanding the game. Or just making most of it up.)
Noah was an alpha nerd, but the reason he became popular was pure dumb DSP-luck. He was doing the right thing at the right time, RIGHT when the internet started booming with what evolved into streamers and content producers.
Noah, true to his contrarian nature, of course chose to piss it all away, and became the internet equivalent of a mentally ill homeless man.
Standing on the street corner with a hat and “need $ for food” sign while yelling and shaking his fist at cars passing by.