- Joined
- Jan 29, 2021
I'd say there are fair arguments for keeping DVDs around, largely because they're full of supplemental material that that just can't be found elsewhere. Like, to this day it's still a toss-up as to whether or not a pirated movie will even have subtitles, and they almost never come with commentary tracks. Making-of featurettes and the like tend to get taken down on YouTube, and even a lot of rereleases, including Blu-Ray releases, tend to shun those. Streaming services never have them for anything older, either. It's not unheard of to have to buy multiple special editions of a movie to get every single extra, either. There was just a short, golden point in time where it'd be disappointing to look at the back of a DVD case and see that the only extras were trailers and Interactive Menus as if that's a selling point, and the adoration for all that shit just kinda fell by the wayside over time and I never hear anyone talking about it anymore.
It's also nice that physical copies of movies now just straight up come with every single version you could possibly need, with some movies coming with I think like five versions of the film for whatever situation you're in: a 4K version, a 3D version, a standard 1080p Blu-ray version, a DVD version, and a streaming code. It's kind of like the opposite of video game collecting now: it's getting increasingly harder to justify buying games on discs, considering they'll be tied to one console, with no guarantee they'll work on a future system that'll inevitably be out within a decade, no support for mods, and even the game's cases tend to be depressingly empty.
Film and TV piracy usually comes with a quality compromise as well. Most scene releases are compressed down several GB from the discs they were ripped from for easy online distribution, and this compression is noticeable especially if you have a larger (> 40") television.
The exception is if you are able to obtain a cracked ISO or a remux of the film; raw DVDs aren't very cumbersome to store on a hard drive at 4-8GB per disc, but Blu-rays require much more storage ranging from 20-50GB per disc. 4K discs can reach around 100GB in some cases, and HDR/Dolby Vision is a pain in the ass to stream locally in my experience.
and you still more than likely have to update the game because so many have day one patches now, and if you only play online, the only benefit is resale value anyway. Of course, video games are much more popular to buy and resell physical copies of than movies, so I guess games are getting the bare minimum because they'll sell anyway, while movies have to bend over backwards to compete with streaming.
I have to disagree with you on this. I don't see Blu-ray or UHD as competing with streaming at all, because the target audiences are different. Even a few of the "boutique" labels like Criterion and Arrow Video have their own streaming services which supplement their disc libraries. Home video, and especially UHD, is being held up almost entirely by enthusiasts, whereas streaming is a much more convenient option for the regular folk who simply want to watch the new Hollywood releases or whatever Netflix has curated for them.