I'll chime in a bit more:
A-Logging is strongly discouraged, and especially egregious examples get locked and whatnot. But sometimes there's grey areas and if I was a hardass who had to crack down on every instance of A-Logging, I would have to lock or delete probably about half the posts on here. For example, I'm not really crazy about the "What if you could punch Chris anywhere?" thread. It's not strictly A-Logging, but I don't want to appear to be a hardass about it. That's the thing about being a mod or an admin, on the one hand you have to enforce the rules but you can't be a hardass about enforcing every single rule to the point you can't have any discussions because some part of it infringes on the rules. I know recently there was a thread that was something along the lines of "For people on disability, what do you think of Chris?" and I thought Compy handled it well when he warned people on the thread to tread carefully. The thread topic was just ripe to provoke A-Logging but it's not entirely impossible to have the thread without A-Logging if it was properly done.
The whole A-Logging rule is mostly a safety measure for all parties involved. One, unfortunately there are people who lurk the forums who have the intention of finding a new lolcow to replace Chris. I know what these kind of people are like, because I hang out with them on PVCC and I've frequented /cow/ for ages and to them, saying something like "I hate Chris! He gives autistics like me a bad name!" or "I wish Chris would die!" says to them "Yes, please troll me, I hate a harmless autistic manchild because I am desperately overcompensating for my own miserable life." Second, I don't want to give Chris fodder. I have a strong suspicion feel that Chris thinks we all hate him and want him dead, when I think most of us are just have a morbid fascination with Chris, albeit on the unhealthy side at times. I think the average person here doesn't want Chris dead, they just think Chris is bizarrely interesting and they probably wish Chris would listen to people and change for the better. Third, it's to keep Null's and by association my ass safe. If Chris ever wisens up, I don't want him to show this forum to an attorney or someone and show them posts that say things like "If I had the chance, I'd slit Chris's fat throat" or shit like that. I don't want to give an impression we're some sort of hate site and jeopardize us. Likewise, if some psychotic person decides to physically harm Chris, I don't want law enforcement to find this forum and argue that we encouraged this person. This is similar to the reason why I don't allow trolling plans.
If you see A-Logging in a thread, report it. There should be a little button in the post to do so and that makes the mods' and admins' jobs easier because it'll pop up for us and we can investigate it immediately. People have been posting out threads but nobody has reporting them, don't be afraid to report bad posts.