Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

I was bored and watched all of Jujustu Kaisen. Then I read the manga from the Shibuya Incident arc until the ending. This is by far the worst manga I have ever read. I think even the author couldn't figure out if he was trying to rip-off Bleach or Naruto. The shear number of plot holes, asspulls, and mishandling of characters is staggering. The ending of Shingeki no Kyojin is somehow better than this terrible story. The Shinjuku Showdown and the Culling Game arcs are so bad and it's not even so bad that it's good either. Yet the manga is an 8.22/10 on MAL. Has anybody actually read this shit? It's worse than every other popular shonen series before, during, or since.
Do you mind going into detail while it's still fresh on your mind? I still get youtube algorithm spam and random comments on various sites still recommending JJK so it's nice to hear new reader opinions that aren't overhyping it for no valid reason.q
 
Subs just inherently have better voice acting because Japan has a much larger and robust pool of voice actors due to their industry being much larger by necessity. Remember, Japan doesnt just have to voice all of their anime but also dub every show from outside of Japan. American voice acting is a sparse industry as it is, nevermind dubbing for tv anime. There is a reason why a lot of the time localized anime films from Ghibli will have big actors do the roles and it isnt just for name recognition, the reality is that the quality of talent for the average dub is borderline amateur for a lot of the cast. That doesnt mean there arnt great voice actors floating around but from what I can tell thats the main issue with most dubs.
The problem with subs vs dubs is that a lot of comedy anime rely on things like wordplay and timing that you're completely going to miss if you only read words on a screen while not understanding what you're listening to.
It's why so many western anime watchers think anime can't be funny, no shit nigger, you're reading translated jokes.
 
I think even the author couldn't figure out if he was trying to rip-off Bleach or Naruto.
Yes. And the magic system is just Nen (powered by inconvenience from self imposed rules) and the ultimate move is shoving people in your Reality Marble.
 
The problem with subs vs dubs is that a lot of comedy anime rely on things like wordplay and timing that you're completely going to miss if you only read words on a screen while not understanding what you're listening to.
Which is why the loudest and most cogent argument in response to untranslatable puns is "Learn Japanese".
I don't disagree that it's the real solution to these arguments, but Jesus Christ if it isn't a steep price of entry into this medium.
 
I was bored and watched all of Jujustu Kaisen. Then I read the manga from the Shibuya Incident arc until the ending. This is by far the worst manga I have ever read. I think even the author couldn't figure out if he was trying to rip-off Bleach or Naruto. The shear number of plot holes, asspulls, and mishandling of characters is staggering. The ending of Shingeki no Kyojin is somehow better than this terrible story. The Shinjuku Showdown and the Culling Game arcs are so bad and it's not even so bad that it's good either. Yet the manga is an 8.22/10 on MAL. Has anybody actually read this shit? It's worse than every other popular shonen series before, during, or since.
Give us a breakdown, c'mon. I've heard everyone suck this manga's dick so many god damn times i'm actually pretty interested to hear what you think
 
Do you mind going into detail while it's still fresh on your mind? I still get youtube algorithm spam and random comments on various sites still recommending JJK so it's nice to hear new reader opinions that aren't overhyping it for no valid reason.q
Give us a breakdown, c'mon. I've heard everyone suck this manga's dick so many god damn times i'm actually pretty interested to hear what you think
I will limit myself to after the Shibuya Incident arc to save time and because I think the second half of the series has more problems. The first half is mediocre, but the second half is an unfinished rushed mess. I wrote a big long synopsis but halfway through I realized it was getting too long. Instead I think I'll just hit over some of the things I hated with the story/characters and world building.

Yuji is revealed to be the son of Kenjaku who took the body of his mother Kaori so that he could create a vessel for Sukuna. This is why he is called brother by Choso and is able to use blood manipulation techniques. Nothing he does improves or develops his character. He feels guilt over Sukuna killing people during the Shibuya Incident and wants to kill himself, but his grandfather and the character motivations that are half baked but present in the first half of the story are nowhere to be found. He's a generic good guy who feels really bad but does nothing wrong and is super special with no understandable character motivations. The author tries to resist formulaic shonen bullshit but exemplifies it and has no other way to resolve the relationship between Yuji and Sukuna other than for Yuji to pull out a surprise domain expansion that is literally Talk no Justu.

Nobara is hinted to be alive after being fatally injured by Mahito, but doesn't return until the Shinjuku Showdown arc. And when she does return it is only for one small part of the fight with no explanation given or any further character development. That one moment is her Sakura moment where she is a girl boss and uses her resonance to do barely anything about Sukuna. She doesn't have a character arc at all. Her arc ends at the end of the Shibuya Incident arc.

Megumi doesn't have any character development either and becomes a one dimensional character fixated on protecting his sister until Sukuna tricks Yuji and transfers himself to Megumi. After this Megumi is literally not a character at all and has no impact on the story because he becomes depressed and can't take control back from Sukuna. Even when Yuji breaks through to him later in the Shinjuku Showdown arc he just lays on the ground and cries inside of his own body, not even slightly inconveniencing Sukuna. The author intentionally wrote him out of the story by doing a special ritual to suppress Megumi and having Sukuna kill the incarnated body of his sister with his own body to break him.

Gojo is not developed any further either and the author hates his character. He isn't unsealed until the Shinjuku Showdown arc. Gojo loses to Sukuna because Sukuna pulls out a bullshit attack at the end of the fight to cut Gojo in half. For some reason none of the main cast is bothered by this and there is no appropriate fear or reaction. Everyone just moves on until the author teases that he was actually alive. They introduce this black box about how Tengen secretely knew that if Gojo left the prison realm there was a condition and binding pact that would kill him, and Kenjaku is worried over this. Don't worry, nothing comes of it. The tease was actually because Okkotsu made this secret plan to copy Kenjaku's technique so he can transfer his brain into Gojo's body to use the Six Eyes and Limitless techniques against Sukuna. He manages to do nothing against Sukuna and quickly leaves the fight.

Kenjaku's motivations are that he wanted to enact this stupid plan to merge everyone into Tengen so he could control it and see what happens. He gets killed because of a throwaway gag character with an overpower cursed technique that allows him to bend reality into whatever he believes is funny. Okkotsu is there to finish him off since the gag character doesn't kill anybody. After getting jobbed. he says that someone will inherit his will, and nothing comes of that statement at all. Because he got jobbed everyone blames Okkotsu for having to be the one to finish him off since he was delayed in returning and taking Gojo's body.

Sukuna's backstory references a massive plot during the Heian era (mostly to give him a retarded form change midway through the fight with the sorcerers during the Shinjuku Showdown arc) that is not explored in-depth at all. They name drop a bunch of shit that the author doesn't explain in the story and just moves on from. It's not explaineed very well why the Heian era was super powerful, it just is. It's a time period to pull powerful incarnated sorcerers from that have a one-dimensional relationship to Sukuna to generate fake mystery. Gege pulled all of this out of his ass to rush out this hackjob.

Yuki Tsukomo is built up as a major supporting character, but gets killed before even releasing her domain expansion against Kenjaku. She has no character development other than mentioning that she was a former platinum star vessel for Tengen as a jab at her. THIS IS NEVER EXPLAINED. Her connection to Toudou is never explained. In the flashback she is connected to Geto, but Geto's character has nothing to do with Kenjaku. They have different motivations and interests.

Instead of focusing on the important side character (and main characters) the story during the Culling Game arc focuses on introducing random characters like Hikari and Higurama that have no wider impact on the story. There is an entire story about a French guy who is a manga artist that get's jobbed by Hikari's bullshit cursed technique which gives him infinite cursed energy and makes him immortal. Kenjaku convinces America to send troops to capture sorcerers so he could kill them and use the soldiers as fuel to generate cursed energy, so there is this drawn out sequence of him talking the president and it's like playing a knock-off Kojima game without any of the charm. As an American I was on the floor about how embarassing and retarded that scene is, and it was based off a throw away line by Yuki at the end of Shibuya Incident arc.

The entire last arc is one long drawn out fight against Sukuna where every character no matter how powerful gets jobbed and has these built up final attacks before Sukuna pulls out another hidden technique or gimmick. Even after fighting Gojo he is revealed to have not been at full power at all and manages to have infinite asspull cursed energy while the tension throughout the fight quickly wears down. This is over the course of dozens of chapters of him having the most plot armor out of any character in the series. Few of the characters die and so it became a revolving door of a character being introduced before jobbing and then being replaced by another character because Sukuna is a retarded character. I laughed out loud when they brought out the magical black man and the gay guy who were followers of Geto to fight Sukuna before leaving shortly after midlly inconveniencing him. The Shinjuku Showdown arc is the down-syndrome short bus version of the last arc of Naruto.

The ending resolves none of these character conflicts, answers none of the remaining questions about the world or the story, and ends with a slice of life about Megumi, Yuji, and Nobara continuing to do missions as normal.

The power system is awful and full of asspulls. Domain expansion is carrying the weight for most of the major fights in the series as it has gamified mechanics like the "sure hit" bullshit. If the base power system was left alone it would still be passable, but the introduction of binding pacts ruins the way that these mechanics interact with each other by making them convoluted and able to be manipulated easily as the story demands it. But even those binding pacts are not internally consistent. The manga says that Sukuna is able to maintain an open domain that is so powerful because it gives every individual a pact where they have a line of escape. This is not capitalized on or used by anyone fighting him in the story. There was a binding pact that would eliminate Gojo if he escaped the prison realm, but he just ignores it. Binding pacts are ignored when the author needs them to be. Some binding pacts require a lot of sacrifice, while some more powerful binding pacts don't seem to require much sacrifice at all. There are also parts of the power system that are added on but not explored. They are only introduced in order to give a justification for why something is stronger without being represented or impacting the wider power system, like how doing rituals and incantations increase the power of techniques.

The worlbuilding in this show never lives up to the expectations of the reader. The author constantly introduces concept or new information about the lore behind the universe that is not explained and which contradicts rules set about the world. If cursed energy is generated by having more people, why was the Heian era more powerful than the modern era? Gege sets a distinction between earlier incarnated sorcerers and modern sorcerers, but immediately contradicts this himself and makes it a point in the story that this way of introducing the differences is wrong. We're told that there are these three clans that are so important and powerful, but we only know anything about the Zenin clan and all of them are taken over off-screen by Kenjaku with no difficulty. For some reason Japan is super special and is the only place that has cursed energy. This is not explained. There are so many examples of this that if I listed them all we would be here all day. The entire series feels like a filler arc from Naruto Shippuden. Put your shonen gruel in the bag, Gege. This is garbage work.
 
Last edited:
Finished the original Panty & Stocking. I feel like this is a show made to please to the creators without really caring how the audience would take it - understandable given how it was made in the aftermath of a studio-reshaping compromise. While I'm glad at how they got to inflict their id on people seemingly without compromise this time, I'm not really someone who likes seeing constant sex jokes and sex fluids in things that aren't explicit porn.
Ending's decent, but dumb as hell. Having Brief turn out to be a secret pretty boy rich kid who has to re-de-virginate Panty with his magic cock to restore her powers is bad fanfic as fuck and I'm glad it wasn't made in the era of inceldom, but the post-ending is indeed one of the most hilarious cliffhangers ever.
 
I've been slowly building an anime backlog and I found a nyaa torrent (300+ seeders) containing the entirety of evangelion, but there seem to be multiple mkv files with the same name (but different sizes) and 2 of the folders are similarly titled so I'm a little confused.
 
I've been slowly building an anime backlog and I found a nyaa torrent (300+ seeders) containing the entirety of evangelion, but there seem to be multiple mkv files with the same name (but different sizes) and 2 of the folders are similarly titled so I'm a little confused.
uncut and cut?
different subtitles?
 
uncut and cut?
different subtitles?

here is the directory listing copied from a terminal
Code:
 '[Anime Time] Rebuild Of Evangelion'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 01.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 02.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 03.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 04.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 05.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 06.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 07.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 08.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 09.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 10.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 11.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 12.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 13.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 14.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 15.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 16.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 17.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 18.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 19.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 20.mkv'
"[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 21'.mkv"
"[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 22'.mkv"
"[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 23'.mkv"
"[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 24'.mkv"
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 25.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 26.mkv'

'./[Anime Time] Rebuild Of Evangelion':
'[Anime Time] Evangelion 1.11 - You Are (Not) Alone.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Evangelion 2.22 - You Can (Not) Advance.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Evangelion 3.0+1.11 Thrice Upon A Time.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Evangelion 3.33 You Can (Not) Redo.mkv'

'./[Anime Time] Revival Of Evangelion':
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - Death & Rebirth.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - Death (True)².mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - The End of Evangelion.mkv'

'./[Anime Time] Revival Of Evangelion (Sephirotic)':
"[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 25'.mkv"
"[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - 26'.mkv"
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - Death.mkv'
'[Anime Time] Neon Genesis Evangelion - Rebirth.mkv'
 
Aren't these multiple versions of episodes 21 to 24?
I've been slowly building an anime backlog and I found a nyaa torrent (300+ seeders) containing the entirety of evangelion, but there seem to be multiple mkv files with the same name (but different sizes) and 2 of the folders are similarly titled so I'm a little confused.
There are Directors' Cut versions of those episodes.

Taken from a torrent with those episodes included:
Just what are these Directors cut episodes?

They are extended versions of episodes 21-24.
Each episode has between 2-6 minutes of new scenes added, some quite noticeable, some not.
All in all, they improve the storytelling and flesh out some of the characters more then the original TV episodes.
They also set the stage for End of Evangelion to a greater extent then the originals.

"Which ones should I watch?" Watch these ones. The original 21-24 are quite pointless after these became available

Also for those who like to pirate anime, if you want a good source for the best rips of most shows, Sneeddex, A Certain Fansubber's Index, and SeaDex are both extremely solid sources. I'd recommend cross referencing these three to find the best result but 90% of the time they usually all come up to the same answer. If I remember correctly, SneedDex is the most recent one of these.
 
Found this.
file_0000000077f861fb85e17da07a85f510.webp
 
"Which ones should I watch?" Watch these ones. The original 21-24 are quite pointless after these became available
That's a stupid thing to say. You're not getting an authentic Evangelion experience watching the recuts, and it sells a false narrative that Eva was this fully-planned-out masterpiece rather than a pileup of on-the-fly improvisation plagued with production troubles and timeslot schenanigans that through sheer dumb luck and copious art-from-adversity managed to be one of the greatest shows ever made.
Watch the original versions, and THEN watch the recuts. Find both versions of the episodes and put them on your torrent list. Otherwise you're gonna make it impossible to find one or the other version on torrenting sites. And if you think redundancy is unnecessary, why is any of the Death & Rebirth stuff in your list when the only necessity is End of Eva?
 
Last edited:
That's a stupid thing to say. You're not getting an authentic Evangelion experience watching the recuts, and it sells a false narrative that Eva was this fully-planned-out masterpiece rather than a pileup of on-the-fly improvisation plagued with production troubles and timeslot schenanigans that through sheer dumb luck and copious art-from-adversity managed to be one of the greatest shows ever made.
Watch the original versions, and THEN watch the recuts. Find both versions of the episodes and put them on your torrent list. Otherwise you're gonna make it impossible to find one or the other version on torrenting sites. And if you think redundancy is unnecessary, why is any of the Death & Rebirth stuff in your list when the only necessity is End of Eva?
The description I got describing the directors cut episodes didn't come from the rip that Lone Wandering Courier got. I just took the description of what the director's cut episodes were from another torrent. The Anime Time one doesn't have a description on the episodes.
 
Back
Top Bottom