Autoneoteny, self-infantalization and lost futures - Why zoomers look fondly on pasts that they haven't experienced

BussyBusta

kiwifarms.net
Joined
Apr 17, 2025
The point of this thread is not to shit on zoomers really, but more to highlight how we, as a society, have let them down. When I say "we" I mean their retarded parents and boomers.
I'm going to use millenials as a counterpoint for the most part just because it's the only older generation I know this much about personally.

Zoomers, if you've taken notice, are deeply entrenched in an ever-revolving series of nostalgic trends for eras that they were not around to experience.
Most flippantly write this off as typical since generations past have had similar fads come and go (e.g. millennials with the 80s hysteria that eventually culminated in the "Stranger Things" aesthetic).
I disagree. Maybe just because I'm old but hear me out and let me know why you disagree if you do.

My main thesis is that zoomers look "back" to other cultural eras not because they think it would be better to live in that time, but because they're envious of the fact that those eras were hopeful for the future.
It's an attempt to live in a zeitgeist that has a positive forward outlook and, because zoomers are the product of a doomer society, the only way they can do this is by trying to identify with eras wherein that was the norm.

I want to touch on why zoomers are doomers in the larger sociocultural strokes first.
This is the generation that was not only raised on the internet but by the internet. Advice, guidance, goals, knowledge, ideals... a large part of a zoomer's experience of growing up is formed in and by the things they saw and participated in on the internet growing up.
I won't go into this too deeply since I'm not too interested in discussing it here but what is important about this is that zoomers were not always doomers but in large part were made that way due to their experiences with social media and online "news".
Teenage zoomers, like any teenagers really, had a big inclination to be swept up in all sorts of cultural initiatives: BLM, anti-BLM, global warming etc. The difference, compared to prior generations going through this (in the case of hippies, tree huggers, punks and the like) is that zoomers had their confidence, and perspective on the effective change that they could generate, warped by an egotistic social media feedback loop with mass media further boosting that signal.
My friend has a zoomie sister. When she was in highschool, her and her friends would constantly argue with us that they are going to "change the world" in a naive, aggressive and, most importantly, hopeful tone.
So then, if zoomers were hopeful before and constantly identifying with social causes with intent of creating a better future, how did they become doomers?
Because reality hit. Eventually, like most teenagers, they got bored and fatigued with whatever fad they were going through. For zoomers this crushed them way more than any other generation because of the simple fact that almost everyone they knew: from their friends in class, to the people online to the news channels themselves, was telling them that they were going to change the world. So when saying George Floyd's name three times in the mirror didn't end racism and paper straws didn't stop climate change, they were not only fatigued but in a state of shock.
The shock made the zoomer largely give up on the idea that somewhere in the future there can be a good world for them to live in. It wasn't worth trying to craft that future because ultimately, to them, their actions wouldn't matter.
It also happened to many of them at a much earlier age than would typically happen in the past. Instead of being in the usual age range of mid to late teens where teenagers start picking up edgy habits and causes, the range extended itself to the point where 12 year olds are getting pressured to kneel to "stop racism." This ubiquitous culture of pushing for change and identifying with "causes" was so ingrained in the zoomie's childhood.
Note that this doesn't only apply to liberals or lefties. For the zoomies hoping that Trump would bring about a major societal shift, they too were largely disappointed.
Zoomers basically got taught the hardest lesson of nothing ever happening. And now their feed is filled with doomposting news articles and they're left without the cause or drive to think they can change anything about it. The media pushed them to overconfidence and now it kicks them while they're down with negative messaging.

So why would I say that zoomers don't just want to live in another time because it looks fun, for instance?
When millenials were obsessed with 80s culture, it largely manifested in consumption of 80s media and occasional events such as "80s night." Outside of minor 80s influenced fashion trends, millenials did not transform their self to try and identify with someone living in the 80s.
If you want to know what I mean by this, take a look around you in a public space or take a look on tiktok (if you really want to hurt yourself I guess). The average zoomer girl at the mall dresses in a costume. It is a pantomime mimicry of the "subculture" they absorbed from tiktok. This often involves whole dress emulating that of periods past. Millenial girls were not walking around like Cyndi Lauper in public - the 80s was a novelty to them. A cute little curiosity with a fun aesthetic.
For zoomers it goes beyond this. If presented the chance, a millenial in their teens would be highly unlikely to want to be transported and transplanted to the 80s to live in that era themselves. Zoomers want so desperately to escape this present reality because they think it has no future. It's like they're trying to forcefully isekai their way to another time. On this note, the popularity of isekai anime and manga can be related to the zoomer's lost future. Being "reborn" into a different world is an appealing notion to someone who doesn't see the point of being in this one.

When I say that zoomers can't envision a future, it might be helpful to draw a comparison. What is the zoomer's version of 80s futurism or 90s Y2K projections for the cyber future? They have none. They can only envision life progressing on towards the same but worse.
This is reflected in the media they consume and create. There is nothing new imagined of things to come but a constant need to draw on futures created in the past, e.g. cyberpunk. The worst part is that when they do this, they only end up cribbing the aesthetic usually but that's off-topic.

This effect extends to music as well. Have you been to a nightclub within the last 3 years? Unfortunately I have. Go to a "normie" (not some trendy underground techno drugden in a fucking basement or warehouse) nightclub that's a zoomer hangout spot. Pay attention to the music. 90% of what the DJ's playing is hits from the 90s and early 2000s. And the zoomers love it.
Millenials similarly had 80s hits occasionally played in clubs but, outside of 80s themed parties, these were usually at the end of the night to close the club.
To be 18 (21 for burgers) and singing along to Avicii with your friends in the club represented a jovial spirit of optimism going into young adulthood. Zoomers play the hits of their parents in the hopes that they can recapture the feeling of their parents being in the club and feeling that same spirit of optimism. They do this because they can't imagine having that same optimism themselves. They want to bottle that optimism so that they can hit it like a drug.

I'm going to coin a term here, autoneoteny, to try and make my last point.
You can observe an interesting trend in zoomer girls applying makeup vs prior generations like millenials. Both generations, for the most part, use makeup to make themselves appear more attractive or simply to style themselves but there's a nuance in certain trends that creates a major distinction.
Millennial girls used makeup to look more "mature." To look like a woman or lady and not a little girl. Zoomer girls do the complete opposite. The trend for the largest time has been for them to do things like make their eyes look bigger, make their face look more flushed in places that aren't meant to mimic sexual arousal (e.g. a red dot on the nose to indicate a spritely nature), or to place fake freckles on their face. They emphasise neotonous features to look youthful.
Whereas the millenial girl looked optimistically towards growing into a woman, the zoomer girl rejects it. She rejects it because ageing and growing up remind her of a march towards an increasingly bleak outlook. It's not that she doesn't want to get old, it's that she doesn't want to walk into this present future. It's much easier to play pretend and briefly copy someone else's.



This turned into a much more scattered, schizophrenic write up than I anticipated. Thanks to anyone who actually reads (and hopefully engages with) it.

Btw I don't think the above holds the same for younger gen Alphas. They're borne out of chaos and don't suffer the same pessimistic outlook imo. But that's a discussion for another day.
 
From the sound of things, being that you go to nightclubs, you might just be a Zoomer yourself. So I am going to approach this from that assumption. In that Normie millennials my age don't go to nightclubs anymore.

There is so much to unpack here, but I can broadly explain it in the context that we are going through a clash of ideologies while the Zoomers are reaching maturity.

Since the end of the Cold War, there has been this "Whig Theory of History" epitomized by Fukiyamas infamous work "The End of History and the Last Man". In it, the theory is set forth that Liberal Democracy and international capitalism have prevailed as the bestest forms of human organization ever, and that the only thing left to do was implement it world wide and everything will be happy and peaceful forever. There will be no more wars, there will be only endless betterment and that the natural evolutionary process of selection would create the new man to fit this ideal social organization.

The entire western political and academic establishment fell in love with this theory. Even more, breakthroughs in the sciences of psychology and social engineering brought about by Liberal Democracies need to gather minutia on polling and voting data led to a greater top down ability to enforce the new paradigm. Not by coercion but by persuasion. Through media, education, and professional certification. The old institutions of the State bypassed and replaced by new institutions.

Needless to say it failed. The new institutions were as corrupt as the old. In the end, man is a fallen creature and despite the fact that an international Charity is called "Save the Children", saving children was never the primary goal. The primary goal was laundering tax money through shell accounts and into the bank accounts of the board members. The vanguard of the new liberal order, the non-governmental organizations, became somehow worse and yet more powerful then the institutional states they sprang from.

And then on September 11, 2001, a rogue non-governmental organization, Al Qaeda, decided to start a war with the USA. And you saw such an upheaval. The traditional State suddenly roused to fury and war, while the new international systems followed along behind it in the hope of imposing their vision of the Last Man on the Middle East, which rejected it utterly. But it led to funny things like NGO's trying to teach women's rights in Afghanistan. Or queer theory in Iraq. One guess how that ended up.

The Zoomers are now inheriting the ashes of the failure of the post Cold War era, coming to grips with the calamity even as forces that were forcibly suppressed by the ruling establishment move under their feet. Unrestrained migration of the third world into the first world being the most obvious. Part of the theory of the End of History was that all humans are equal and thus interchangeable. And so it was assumed that just as we could invade the Middle East and show them the light, we could also bring the Middle East into our own countries and show them the light.

Both strategies failures.

So now there is a total rejection, but the entrenched power refuses to give up and there is an increasing awareness that things will inevitably get worse and possibly violent. Especially given how so many people were made susceptible to the brainwashing techniques of the ruling elites that weaponized the media and the psychological sciences against their own people.

Traditionalists such as myself reject the Liberal whig view of history. All men are not created equal. All men are created by God to serve the purpose for which God made them. The world does not progress towards Utopia. It is ever progressing towards damnation and only by the grace of God and the intervention of the righteous is the fall arrested.

For more watching...

Love your Servitude

The Philosophy of Tolkien

And of course, the most based Anime speech ever, presented as the villain speech, but true in the sense but not the delivery. Even when trying to present the traditionalist argument as the villain the proponents of Liberal theory can't help but put their own philosophy of progress into it. I find this illustrative of the fact that they simultaneously hate people who think like me, but also have no conception of how people like me think.


The answer to why the Zoomers feel like things are getting worse, well, things are ALWAYS getting worse. Always have been. But for the last 30 years society has been fed a comforting lie that things would always get better. Prior generations were prepared for struggle by their parents. Sadly not the Zoomers. The Zoomers were promised safety and fun and are discovering the world offers neither. The great lie, and it has to burn.

As for the Alphas, well, I genuinely think the Alphas will inherit the earth.
 
Last edited:
Zoomers have the same issues that younger Gen X and Millennials had. Bud Bundy was the original basement dweller and that was during the 90's. It was just back in those times people like that were a small number and they could easily be written off as losers. The population of these people is growing larger and larger and has for 20+ years now. They can't all be written off as losers as much as the Boomers try.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Ser Prize
Since you mentioned music, you can see the end of optimism by looking at the charts. I think there was a distinct shift around 2016. Compare 2016 to 2014, it wasn't that long ago but there is a very distinct somber feeling creeping into pop music in 2016. Around that time I also believe that soundcloud rappers were becoming popular, which is the "grunge" of rap in a sense. Clubs play old songs because music now is sad, dreary, and slow. I guarantee there will be a 2010 revival, I already see it. People are sick of being sad. Example:

Its so wild.
 
The answer to why the Zoomers feel like things are getting worse, well, things are ALWAYS getting worse. Always have been. But for the last 30 years society has been fed a comforting lie that things would always get better. Prior generations were prepared for struggle by their parents. Sadly not the Zoomers. The Zoomers were promised safety and fun and are discovering the world offers neither. The great lie, and it has to burn.
I agree with you but the point was more to try and tie all of this to the concept of their aesthetic obsession with the past. I don't think it's wrong for them to have the worldview that they do. It's more an indictment of everyone before them crafting these circumstances.
As for the Alphas, well, I genuinely think the Alphas will inherit the earth.
Or burn it down, but either way they have too much sincerity (vs zoomie post-post irony and millennial post-irony) to get depressed about the world the way zoomers do.
 
Last edited:
What you say is scattered, but there is so much truth in it. I think a lot of it is jealousy of a time when you weren't being watched 24/7. You could make mistakes and people would forget about them. The internet and the ability to give everyone, including children, a voice has had a terrible effect on human development. One of my favorite cows, Birdie, proves this so well. Same with LTcorbis.
What do you mean a bunch of adults were having political discussions and debates with a 10 year old? I still can't believe I didn't hear about that live while it was happening.

The media was higher quality and younger people envy the community you could have before the smartphone/social media age. Things were cheaper. Fashion was higher quality. You weren't a slave to a black box you carried around with you. School shootings weren't as prominent in the 80s and 70s. Although there was a problem with latchkey kids, I think latchkey kids in the past were somehow better off than the digital latchkey kids of today. If you leave your child alone on the internet, you might as well let them walk around at night. Companies have hired people who know how best to take your psychology and use it against you. So you stay on their platforms longer. The companies want to throw everyone under their boot into a dystopian hellscape. Live in a pod, eat the bugs, own nothing.

The internet age has amplified all the worst aspects of human nature and American culture in general. I think about the song Virtual Insanity a lot now. Although it was written in such an optimistic time for technology, it made points that have only rung truer as the decades have passed. I
have such a deep appreciation for that song to the point it's ridiculous.
 
What you say is scattered, but there is so much truth in it. I think a lot of it is jealousy of a time when you weren't being watched 24/7. You could make mistakes and people would forget about them. The internet and the ability to give everyone, including children, a voice has had a terrible effect on human development. One of my favorite cows, Birdie, proves this so well. Same with LTcorbis.
What do you mean a bunch of adults were having political discussions and debates with a 10 year old? I still can't believe I didn't hear about that live while it was happening.

The media was higher quality and younger people envy the community you could have before the smartphone/social media age. Things were cheaper. Fashion was higher quality. You weren't a slave to a black box you carried around with you. School shootings weren't as prominent in the 80s and 70s. Although there was a problem with latchkey kids, I think latchkey kids in the past were somehow better off than the digital latchkey kids of today. If you leave your child alone on the internet, you might as well let them walk around at night. Companies have hired people who know how best to take your psychology and use it against you. So you stay on their platforms longer. The companies want to throw everyone under their boot into a dystopian hellscape. Live in a pod, eat the bugs, own nothing.

The internet age has amplified all the worst aspects of human nature and American culture in general. I think about the song Virtual Insanity a lot now. Although it was written in such an optimistic time for technology, it made points that have only rung truer as the decades have passed. I
have such a deep appreciation for that song to the point it's ridiculous.
You make a very good point. Deleuze talks about how societies of control make the school to corporate wagie pipeline an almost seamless process. So that there isn't a clear delineation between school and work but just one constant treadmill of never-ending training. Kids nowadays are in a persistent digital panopticon where they're monitored, observed and judged for all their actions.
As an adult, I've worked a job in my past where every action on your work laptop was monitored and micro-managed and it genuinely made me miserable to the point of quitting. Zoomers have had that experience applied to their whole existence.
 
I don't want to be all "there's a lot to unpack here" but the visions of the future from the 80s and 90s have been made manifest. Even the most optimistic ones were basically just "comms get better" and "stuff gets cheap" at the end of the day, with the truly hard sci-fi being trying to reconcile FTL nonsense with layman understanding of physics. Fashion is cyclical so of course there's 80s nights now where there were 70s nights before, and now places have 00s nights instead of 90s nights. People have been nostalgic since there have been people. There are antiquated words for "nostalgia for a place that never was" in a ton of languages. None of this is new. If anything, the only new thing is people mixing up recent eras by slapping 00s cheap/easy skate video tape style subtitles (as in, text on a rectangular bar) on actual VHS tape filtered images that would have used normal drop-shadow subs. Like vapor wave shit that's just a mish-mash of the few period things trivially achievable with modern techniques.
 
  • Optimistic
Reactions: Anonitolia
I guess I'm not aware of the young zoomer lifestyle enough to really comment, but I'm sure what you're saying is correct

You could make the argument that they're looking back to the last time culture even truly existed; it obviously still exists in some way, but it's a really decrepit version of culture that tends to feel really flimsy and disengaging, and the bulk of it is made up of tons of tiny independent threads that burn up as quickly as they appear.
Thus culture hasn't really done much within the last decade, and I'm not sure how it ever can do anything again when people increasingly live an existence where they sit inside, work remotely, spend free time online (in corporate-controlled channels), and effectively know random strangers on a screen better than they know anyone outside their front door.

You know, what even is "Current culture"? The closest thing I can think of to a broad modern cultural touchstone for young people would be the general idea of tiktok.

If we're talking purely about adopting cultural aesthetics, to me it's no mystery: when you're deprived of your own culture, what else can you do except look to one that's already established?
 
The point of this thread is not to shit on zoomers really, but more to highlight how we, as a society, have let them down. When I say "we" I mean their retarded parents and boomers.
I'm going to use millenials as a counterpoint for the most part just because it's the only older generation I know this much about personally...
If you want the average Zoomer experience paraphrased to four bullet points, I think these are comprehensive of it:
  • The feeling of betrayal from the juxtaposition of the freedom and safety (both partial illusions) that previous generations enjoyed compared to the modern hellscape.
  • The paranoia of being constantly watched, recorded, and judged at all times by devices necessary for you to operate in society normally.
  • The dread of "Nothing Ever Happens", because we all (from Zoomer to Boomer on both sides of the isle) know deep down, under however many layers of obfuscation, something is eventually going to happen and it won't be good.
  • The desolation of either, 1) Being BTFO in the job market after selling 4-6 years of life and purpose for a degree by people that have experience you can't get without the jobs you can't get in the first place, or 2) Slowly dissolving your soul in a minimum wage position either right out of High School or after getting or failing a degree.
Then there's all the peripheral reminders that this era is not as prosperous (Read: delusional) as the one the Zoomers missed by two decades. Media is getting worse in quality of writing and production (more accurately the good stuff is not popular and you have to dig online to find it but that drives people into niche groups that are harder to identify in between.) Clothing, furniture, tools, appliances, electronics; Average household everything is a minefield of Chinesium products quite literally designed to break.

Hence the subset of Zoomers that crave retro everything, from reasonable to unnecessary things, because the escapist media was better and the surviving quality items from "back in the day when the dream wasn't dead" do not break to force a purchase of the next product iteration.

As for the Alphas, well, I genuinely think the Alphas will inherit the earth.
Unironically, why do you believe this to be the case? Are they just more optimistic than Gen Z?
 
Unironically, why do you believe this to be the case? Are they just more optimistic than Gen Z?
They are unironic agents of chaos. They were born with the modern internet in the crib. They were raised by it. The world will fear and love Gen Alpha, because they will be like nothing that has come before.

For good or bad.
 
DJ's playing is hits from the 90s and early 2000s. And the zoomers love it.
Millenials are exactly the same way about 60's and 70's music. A lot of kids tend to subconsciously absorb the music their parents listen to.
generations past have had similar fads come and go (e.g. millennials with the 80s hysteria that eventually culminated in the "Stranger Things" aesthetic).
You've got this shit all wrong. Gen x was the one with the 80's nostalgia shit going on. Millenials aren't the ones financing shit like Stranger Things.

It's the 30 year culture cycle. When millennials were the age zoomers are now a lot of them were into the 60's and 70's aesthetic. They wore bell bottoms and shit like that. Eventually that morphed into hipsters. I'm curious what the zoomer version of hipsters will be when all the baggy pants and flannel wearing zoomer kids grow up.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: Anonitolia
They are unironic agents of chaos. They were born with the modern internet in the crib. They were raised by it. The world will fear and love Gen Alpha, because they will be like nothing that has come before.

For good or bad.

Because of the internet/social media/etc, gen Alpha will probably be polarized between the extremely well-adjusted and the barely-functional spergs, with few in between. That dynamic already sort of exists with younger zoomers and will probably accelerate.
 
I think this speaks a lot. Especially in the context of this thread.

Screenshot 2025-04-17 231011.webp
'

I think it's so bleak that a lot of these kids can't even read or write, and they know it's going to get ten times worse. Another reason why Zoomers idolise older music and culture is that the corporations want everything to be automated. Everything to be artificial. The things that make us most human are the things that are least compatible with the need for profit. I think the push for transgenderism was a testament to that. So many children and adults will be left with a plethora of physical and psychological damage. The companies and corporations behind it? Could care less. Same thing with the internet, education, etc.

The internet should always have been a place to visit, not a place to live. It clashes so much with how the human mind operates. Like I said in another thread, the devil lives in the silicon valley.
 
When millennials were the age zoomers are now a lot of them were into the 60's and 70's aesthetic. They wore bell bottoms and shit like that.
I've never experienced this. Are you referring to bootcut jeans being popular in the 90s and early 2000s? That style of flare was popular through several prior decades and isn't really related to bell bottoms.
Millenials are exactly the same way about 60's and 70's music.
This is true to an extent while not sharing the same veracity of absorption that zoomers have with 90s and early 2000s music. Millennials were not listening to Sgt Pepper in the club.
This also misses the fact that zoomers aren't just interested in the music, but are wholly consumed by the aesthetic. No millenial was trying to dress like their parents by wearing an afro and paisley shirt.
 
My main thesis is that zoomers look "back" to other cultural eras not because they think it would be better to live in that time, but because they're envious of the fact that those eras were hopeful for the future.
Correction: they imagine those eras were hopeful for the future. Like they imagine they'd fare well in a zombie apocalypse.

In reality this is wrong, the notion that life is going to be better is, historically, extremely new. Commies came up with it, and everyone else rolled out their own version. But earlier in history, you had to take extraordinary steps to improve your lot in life, otherwise you and your descendants would be stuck as illiterate peasants or hereditary craftsmen. You could reliably improve your lot in life by becoming a monk, but that was, by design, not hereditary.

Most groups/ideologies have a mythical golden age to uphold, simply because an active ideology must by definition be unsatisfied with the status quo, and ideas are hard.
Adult anglo trads long for the mythical 50s with their rapeable housewives. Normie Russians of course want Stalin to come back and shoot every bougie, while domestic traitors miss tsarism, and traitor "expats" miss the 90s, when young girls wanted to be prostitutes when they grew up. Japs probably want their emperor and national pride back. Turks want Ataturk and/or the Ottoman empire. Hungarians want Greater Hungary.

Whole artistic movements that we now consider trad, based, and ennobling were hilariously lolcowish at their time.
We think it's funny when Trump is portrayed as the god-emperor, and yet we don't think it's particularly unusual when Napoleon is portrayed in Ancient Greek paraphernalia, even though Napoleon is closer to Trump than to Ancient Greece -- because to us the real distance between Alexander and Napoleon is measured in school years, and in school years it's really short. We think one type of fine art painting that takes effort is pretty much the same as another type of fine art painting that takes effort, until the ugly shit shows up. In the 18th century, they were building faux-Greek not-temples with glazed windows, they're now masterpieces of architecture. Fucks sake!
Don Quixote is about a lolcow who romanticizes the past; the character is fictional but the attitudes it makes fun of were real. Waverley started out as a lolcow (he got better).

(Speaking of ancient Greeks, wokism is not new either: the not so ancient Greeks during the decline were wokening and fagging up their own myths. They made Achilles gay over a thousand years before they made Jeanne D'Arc nonbuynary.)

And there was never a time when doomerism wasn't a thing. Christianity had a variety of doomer cults and movements, from the early days when Jesus was expected to show up soonish, to the year 1000, and later, what with plagues and invasions. As religion waned, early science fiction has had plenty of stories where inventions are bad and a return to the status quo is desirable. When Tsiolkovsky's fans wrote about the perspectives and perils of space exploration, Lovecraft wrote about beings from outer space who'd eat us all and won't even notice.

Tolkien may be a conservative doomer and miscegenation fetishist, but he was """inspired""" by, and credited, the Socialist William Morris (nature = romance = socialism = good, industry = materialism = capitalism = bad).

The end of history is also a common occurrence through history. The Roman empire was eternal until it wasn't. World War I wasn't supposed to get a sequel. I remember a Spanish story that goes, "it happened during one of those wars that are always called 'the last one', even though it's always followed by yet another more bloody and destructive" or something like that. Fukuyama is a certified moron: WWI ended with the rape of Germany, the Cold War ended with the rape of Russia (then 5.5% of the world's pop, not counting the other "second world" countries), how cancerous does one have to be to think this amount of surprise human misery would have no consequences? Zero pattern recognition. Even if you think Russians are quqs, all that looted wealth is going somewhere.


---
I haven't been whoring, recently or at all, but a simple explanation for why older music is popular is the culture wasn't as fractured back then. Now, less mass media and more targeted streaming means less shared culture, except for "blockbusters" like Taylor Swift (I've successfully avoided hearing any of her songs; same for the rape ape, but I understand it's almost impossible to keep your ears safe in the US).
And the zoomers love it.
...Why not? Why would zoomers be offended by background music when they're busy going deaf, holding their liquor, and trying to tell female sluts from troons in the dark. Old songs are probably cheap to license in every sense of the word (cheap in dollars and the corporate rightsholders are available at the click of a button).

There is nothing new imagined of things to come but a constant need to draw on futures created in the past, e.g. cyberpunk.
Star Wars and Indiana Jones are just two counterexamples. Another reason for the recycling is there's vastly more supply now, people want to write because they have plenty of free time and no original ideas, they want to tell a fun story in an existing setting they like. I grew up reading historical novels and oldtimey sci-fithat had become reality, I write anachronistic "low fantasy". Why? Partially because I don't have to make shit up. I know how a gas turbine works, I don't have to look into cutting-edge soyence or invent technobabble. Partially because it's more fun to write about real things and real material culture. I don't want to live in ancient Mesopotamia, it's just a fun setting to drive a T-80 around.

Also, zoomies didn't invent the fantasy genre (magic, dragons, the works). Indeed, by now the notion of fantasy is thoroughly destroyed by videogames and muh magic systems, nothing supernatural/romantic/oldtimey/escapist remains of it. You're in a dungeon 9 to 5 except your two weeks of paid vacation per year, and you get pushed around by higher-level adventurers. The Wood Beyond the World is where you go to hunt 10 dickwolves for 100 bonus XP.

Whereas the millenial girl looked optimistically towards growing into a woman
Need I remind you of goths and emus? Craaaaaaaling in my skiiiiiiiiiinnn

On this note, the popularity of isekai anime and manga can be related to the zoomer's lost future. Being "reborn" into a different world is an appealing notion to someone who doesn't see the point of being in this one.
Going to a magical country has always been a trope. The new thing is trying to relitigate an existing story; it's a new development because mass media exists and canon exists. Historically, if you didn't like the ending or details of a story, you'd just tell your own version, everyone's illiterate anyway. But now everyone is literate, there's movies and archives and canon and intellectual property rights; this gives rise to "reincarnated as a villainness" shit in which the IRL reader is invited to dream about putting the fiction-within-a-fiction "right".
 
Reading through this topic and the responses, I have to wonder who has it better: someone who was raised in the 70's and was a teen in the 80's and KNOWS what it was like to live in that era (and has to come to terms with the loss of everything cool from that era); OR a zoomer who never lived through that era to know what it was like and compare it to the present?

It's godawful depressing as an older person to see how society has fractured. People gave me a little razzing when I mentioned that Daddy Government making smoking indoors illegal was a psyop to separate people from their people IRL but hey lookie here! It worked. There are no common third spaces where we find our tribe and commiserate.

Everyone is in "I AM The Main Character" mode. There is no common vision, everyone is so flamboyantly THEMSELVES that the magic is gone. Like, I went to Vegas recently and although my expectations were on the floor, it was still disappointing to see so many people just schlepping around the joint wearing whatever they threw on that morning - I brought a nice little black dress to wear on the floor in the evenings but NO ONE DRESSES NICE ANYMORE.

How can we have shared cultural experiences when we all want to be the star of our own play?
 
How can we have shared cultural experiences when we all want to be the star of our own play?
Isn't this the jewish question? this is not a facetious rhetorical, i'm dead serious. "how do we all stay jews if we all have different beliefs for what it means to be a jew" is the thing that cleaves the jews together

Our society became jewish
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: Anonitolia
@Safir you raise some very interesting points but I want to respond to this specifically:
Need I remind you of goths and emus? Craaaaaaaling in my skiiiiiiiiiinnn
Emos and goths were minor subcultures that don't really represent the larger teen zeitgeist of the time. You do bring up Linkin Park lyrics though (which predate scene emos and are unrelated to goths) which is relevant since they were highly popular.
What Linkin Park's popularity and goth subcultures have in common is that they're all representative of teen angst. I do not think the angst-fueled, edgy aesthetics of teen millennials preclude an optimism towards the future - it's almost necessitated by it.

"I hate my mom, things would be so much better if I could just be on my own to do what I want."
"Adults suck, I'm not going to be like them when I grow up."

The nature of this angst can only exist insofar as there is a hopeful alternative to the present reality. Where there's an outlook of things improving as autonomy is gained. Of course, millennials, like most people, found out this isn't true as they grew up, but they didn't have that illusion shattered until they got to experience reality later in life. For their formative years, that future still existed for the most part. Zoomers had this angst, the same as most generations, but had that dose of reality and pessimism hit a lot sooner for them than anyone else. There's no feeling of "when we're in control, things will improve."

Also, as an aside: what did you mean by this? I'm not quite sure I follow how they're counterexamples to the idea that zoomers don't have a generalized, prominent aesthetic imagining of the future.
Star Wars and Indiana Jones are just two counterexamples.


Everyone is in "I AM The Main Character" mode. There is no common vision, everyone is so flamboyantly THEMSELVES that the magic is gone. Like, I went to Vegas recently and although my expectations were on the floor, it was still disappointing to see so many people just schlepping around the joint wearing whatever they threw on that morning - I brought a nice little black dress to wear on the floor in the evenings but NO ONE DRESSES NICE ANYMORE.
I think the dressing nice thing stopped way before zoomers tbh. Cinemas killed off the idea of people dressing up to go to the theater. In the 80s, people stopped dressing formally when attending rugby matches. I think the decrease in concern for decorum re: dress is something rooted in the 80s and 90s but I don't really have a theory on why.

I think it's so bleak that a lot of these kids can't even read or write, and they know it's going to get ten times worse.
As someone who knows a few teachers: you have no idea how bad this really is. One of my friends believes that it's due to the lack of early development language stimulation that children require. Their parents don't read to them or even talk to them as much - they're just plopped in front of a tablet with headphones. This, and the digital, atomised world they live in, also coincides with how many of these kids are labelled autistic nowadays. They're just very poorly socialized imo.
In a weird way, this works to the benefit of alphas. They truly could not give a fuck about anyone's opinions or expectations of them and it contributes largely to the chaos that @mindlessobserver describes here:
They are unironic agents of chaos. They were born with the modern internet in the crib. They were raised by it. The world will fear and love Gen Alpha, because they will be like nothing that has come before.

For good or bad.
 
I've never experienced this. Are you referring to bootcut jeans being popular in the 90s and early 2000s? That style of flare was popular through several prior decades and isn't really related to bell bottoms.

This is true to an extent while not sharing the same veracity of absorption that zoomers have with 90s and early 2000s music. Millennials were not listening to Sgt Pepper in the club.
I have actually been in a bar full of millenials when Sgt. Peppers was played and the place went nuts for it. I can't even count the amount of millenial bands I've seen over the years that all play boomer rock covers. I've met millenials that'll talk your ear off about about Led Zeppelin or Pink Floyd the same way a zoomer will make an hour long video essay on the depth and complexity of fucking limp bizkit. I think zoomers recently discovered nu-metal because there's been a lot of zoomer video essays about nu-metal bands cropping up on youtube lately. Zoomers are really not special or unique in their appropriation of the culture of a couple generations before.
This also misses the fact that zoomers aren't just interested in the music, but are wholly consumed by the aesthetic.
No millenial was trying to dress like their parents by wearing an afro and paisley shirt.
I literally knew someone that used to wear their parents hippy shit.

You sound like you've gotten all your info from the internet or movies or some shit. Either that or you've forgotten the retarded late 2000's hippy bullshit.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: Space Police
Back