LMAO I forgot about that one
View attachment 6257421
Can't believe I missed this at the time, I guess because the "my favorite consumerist crap is more important than the complete works of Shakespeare" take was so glaringly obviously stupid that it covered up anything else. But he's definitely been harboring these thoughts for years now, it's basically his thesis statement for what the MCU is.
"Nominally" American? What the fuck does that mean, Bob? They're not "nominally" American, they
are American because they're from the USA, a country that still exists in the MCU. I get what he's trying to say, that because they hop around the globe and fight supervillains instead of foreign nations, they're effectively the superheroic example of the rootless cosmopolitan, a "child of the world" as he'd probably say. But just because Captain America isn't chanting "USA! USA! USA!" as he pummels Thanos in the face, doesn't mean he doesn't consider himself American.
Seriously, that's the lynchpin of his argument: if the characters don't explicitly state their country of origin and how much they're proud of it, then they must be a supporter of the Superior Future! Never mind that there's more important things in that moment like, oh, I dunno,
the continued survival of the human race, nope, because Cap didn't say America, he supports globalism!
And it's hilariously easy to poke one gigantic hole in his argument: Wa-fucking-kanda. Clearly they're more than happy to continue having their super high-tech walled-off society (where the right to the throne is decided through bloodsport, very advanced). They showed no inclination towards giving up their sovereignty, nor do they ever stop being proud of their country and their ability to do whatever they want without anyone else telling them otherwise. Yeah, he'd probably point to the end of BP1 where BP was going to start a bunch of inner city programs 'n sheeit, but a country can do foreign aid without giving up their sovereignty.
The reason why all the heroes are American is, quite simply, because these are based on comics written by Americans, for Americans. Of course they were going to set everything of importance in America, especially New York City, it's where their readers would expect things to happen! I don't think Stan Lee or Jack Kirby or anyone else working at Marvel back in the day was explicitly aiming to portray a harmonious world under one government, partly because that removes an area of potential storytelling conflict, but mostly because it's fucking stupid. Humans still care about national pride, despite decades of propaganda telling you that nationalism is bad.
I swear, this gets funnier and more baffling the more I think about it, and it's put my understanding of Bob's Marvel love in a whole new light.