I don't reallt think you could call the Southern and Eastern European waves that arrived on the Shores of America from 1850 to 1920 as that culturally similar to the Northern European Protestant majority. An association of these people with low intelligence, corruption, criminality, and poverty led to the first closing of American immigration with the institution of quotas in 1924 (ironically the people of that period suffered from many of the same problems of globalization that we suffer from today), and led to the formation of the Ku Klux Klan at its most powerful, with millions of members sworn to fight Catholics, Blacks, and Jews. The fact that Catholicism is no longer a seriously contentious issue in modern American politics is in fact a testament to the power of the Melting Pot.
A bit off from the main discussion, but having been raised Catholic, all of this Protestant v. Catholic nonsense is actually still more prevalent than most people think it is (though don't get me wrong, it's nowhere near the same level as other issues). Thing is, having learned theology from Catholic schooling as well as arguing with Protestants before I became an atheist about midway through high school, I really don't think that the inherent religious differences between Catholics and Protestants matter that much from a cultural perspective. Protestants main gripes are:
- They believe that statues of Saints are a form of idolatry, and that Catholics come too close to deifying Mary.
- They don't think that transubstantiation (host actually becoming the body&blood of Christ) exists.
- The papal system.
- They think that they have too many dumb rules, lol what nerdz rite?
None of this directly contradicts the "liberal" values of the U.S. constitution, and more importantly there was never any motivation for Catholics to try and subvert the way that the government works in order to accommodate them. Admittedly I'm not overly informed on the history of immigrant groups in the U.S. outside of the basics, so if things were different back then and I'm missing crucial points in any of this feel free to correct me.
Anyway, association with crime appears to be the one thing that's consistent with every "wave" of immigration, possibly because of poverty or a lack of sufficient law and order in the places people flee from. Thing is, this aspect of things is relatively easy to address, and tends to balance out rather quickly. Latin American immigrants, for the most part, have very little trouble integrating. Problems only arise when gangs/cartels take advantage of lax border laws in order to infiltrate the U.S., and when corporations taking advantage of the cheap labor that illegal immigrants can provide puts people out of work. I highly doubt that this is unconnected to the fact that Latin America is a predominantly Christian (specifically Catholic) region. The same can't really be said for the current wave of Muslim migrants in Europe. To be honest, I think that Sargon is right when he says that the desire to not only self-segregate but to also try and subvert the new country's legal system to defend and cater to their own religion appears to be culturally unique to Islam. It very much appears to be severely influenced by their religious text as well, meaning that this problem isn't going away until there is a major secular reform (which can be done, since several Muslim nations have come close before).
Education is inherently more left wing yes, but the greatest problem with the modern conservative movement is this surrender of the intellectual spaces and a return to anti-intellectualism. Like it or not, but the oftentime idiotic ideas that come out of Humanities departments have a way of diffusing into the modern consciousness, since the people who become teachers come out of these indoctrination facilities. An example of this is the proliferation of social justice in modern day education, which I thankfully only narrowly avoided the full extent of this phenomenon.
I was in STEM for undergrad so I likely avoided the full blunt of this, but one of my freshmen year required humanities electives was borderline communist propaganda, and multiple professors I had for history classes were blatantly SJW (one was even full blown anti-white). Having a social circle largely composed of music oriented people I was also exposed to SJWs 24/7 and very rarely talked to people who fundamentally agree with me irl. And oh yes, I personally witnessed a few of those infamous college protests. Thing is, very little about my core beliefs and principals changed as a result of this, and I turned out... fine, I guess? I'm not sure that this "brainwashing" is as effective as you think it is, as luckily it only seems to really work on people who are already at least sort of on board? Maybe too optimistic, but I think there's hope on this one.
The UK and Europe are pretty much fucked if they don't immediately halt the wave of Muslim immigration coming in, and even if they do they'll still have serious problems with the current Muslim populations. I don't believe that the countries will be destroyed within five years, but the social problems the European elites are trying to sweep under the carpet won't go away. Did you know that in this recent row in Germany one of those nameless Brussels oligarch said that Horst Seehofer, Merkel's coalition partner who's currently pushing for a harder line on immigration, needs the EU's help to "climb out of the tree" that they think he put himself in? I swear, the arrogance of these bureaucrats is astounding.
Split on this. I do think, for the reasons listed above, that there should be massive reduction. Thing is, once they've eschewed all the fake refugees taking advantage of the system, I do think that making room for legitimate asylum seekers is the proper path. Especially since atheists, other religious dissidents, LGBT people, and women need some means of escape (I would take the first chance I got if I were unfortunate enough to be born in one of these countries). A more liberalized Western faction of Islam is probably the only real chance for reform as well.