#Comicsgate - The Culture Wars Hit The Funny Books!

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
So many of these smaller-name CG projects really just look so fucking bad, goddamn.

I get that you can’t exactly splurge on the internal art if you’re trying to make a 144-page graphic novel, but... well, at that point, maybe don’t go for that many pages to begin with.
Take a look at the talentless mental and emotional midgets currently working in the comicbook industry.
Now, imagine how much worse it is for the people who failed to get in in it...
 
@Mister Dongs Now the question would be which CG, are we talking about the Arthurian myth of the OGCG of Ernst and Yah Boi? Where characters are treated with respect and writers and artist don't put SJW lecturing in comics? Or are we talking about Frog's CG, the one soaked in gay ops, IBS and grift thrones? Because the first would be happy to have their Spider-Man or batman as how they remembered them and not rock the industry boat.
Does Jon Del Arroz not count as a fabled "OGCG" alumni? Because he's saying that making videos detailing the problems/fixing Batman or Spider-Man is a lost cause at this point and amounts to the deluded cope of untalented gammas. SWC have also been very critical about the real point of continuuing to pay people who hate you for the privilege of criticize "capeshit", even going so far as to say Ya Boi Zack paying for Mark Waid's comics at this point amounts to financial cuckoldry. To quote Frog: "Marvel and DC listened to what you had to say. Loud and clear. And then they changed nothing."

So I stopped following a lot of the CG drama, especially as it relates to the Ethan Derangement Syndrome crowd, but I happened to catch the video that JDA made about Douglas Ernst and found that JDA had alienated more people, with Cummings and Preston no longer siding with him. I was trying to find out what happened, without having to go through a bunch of videos and avoiding the cancer that is Twitter, and found this page. I didn't find what I was looking for but I did find some amusing shit-flinging, and thought maybe someone here could shed light on what happened.

I made this helpful graph to explain what went down.
In this case, JDA caught wind that Douglas Ernst was spreading dirt around about JDA in DMs and discouraging them from streaming with him.
He took this information to Preston Poulter, who did not feel inclined to take up arms against Ernst. Rinse and repeat with Cummings.

jda.png
 
I have some dms to share between @FROG and @Fathead.
EVSanddonal1.jpg


EVSanddonal2.jpg

EVSanddonal3.jpg

EVSanddonal4.jpg

EVSanddonal5.jpg

EVSanddonal6.jpg


Two takeaways from this.
1. donal admits "I just like making him sweat" which mean she could have paid me at any time, but would rather incriminate himself.
2. donal talks about needing to "transfer money", but I've worked at a bank, and if he's transferring between accounts at the same bank, the money transfers instantly. If it's between two different banks, it could take two days, but it's been more than 2 days by now. He also insists I'll only be happy with 10k, but I've repeatedly asked him just for 5k. He only wants to do a "50-50 split" at this point because he isn't gonna show me the accounting, and is going to manipulate this into giving himself most of the money/giving me nothing.
 
Does Jon Del Arroz not count as a fabled "OGCG" alumni? Because he's saying that making videos detailing the problems/fixing Batman or Spider-Man is a lost cause at this point and amounts to the deluded cope of untalented gammas. SWC have also been very critical about the real point of continuuing to pay people who hate you for the privilege of criticize "capeshit", even going so far as to say Ya Boi Zack paying for Mark Waid's comics at this point amounts to financial cuckoldry. To quote Frog: "Marvel and DC listened to what you had to say. Loud and clear. And then they changed nothing."



I made this helpful graph to explain what went down.
In this case, JDA caught wind that Douglas Ernst was spreading dirt around about JDA in DMs and discouraging them from streaming with him.
He took this information to Preston Poulter, who did not feel inclined to take up arms against Ernst. Rinse and repeat with Cummings.

View attachment 1693549

That is indeed a helpful and accurate graph.

But JDA is just fucking with people. He doesn't care about any pre-existing conflict, and he doesn't care about having allies. He's just another trust fund brat internet troll.

I've tried on two different occasions to take his phony demands for respect seriously. I had what I thought was a sincere and productive phone conversation with him declaring a truce, trying to find a way for him to actually help and be helped by ComicsGate, only to have him comically sabotage it 24 hours later.

I did this because I'd never read his comics before. I saw FLYING SPARKS with a really nice Jon Malin cover, and assumed it was a blandly titled but decent indie book. A genuine effort.

After the most recent time our Peace Accord fell through for no reason, I read a few of his comics. They are objectively terrible. Like a ten year old wrote them. No one who reads his comics can deny this. They exist because JDA needs them to exist so that he can point at them to people who will NEVER bother reading them, call himself a prolific writer and use Trumpian verbiage to describe himself as The Greatest, in order to fuck with people who are actually trying. JDA has the means by which to afford producing this trash, and he does so to bully people and draw attention to himself on the internet, while humorously painting himself as a victim.

I guess he does this on behalf of Vox Day. Just a guess. But it's fun to watch the anti-CGers receive his trolling. Particularly Capn Cummings.

JDA's comics are ALL laughably terrible. I think he's just mocking comics thru them. I wonder if his novels are as bad? You might get a sale out of me, Del Arroz.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, "traditional" comics model refuses to die:

The traditional market had the problem of offering way too many books for way too long. No "lack of diversity" or this kind of shit. Too many crossovers, mini series and reboots that outpriced everyone but the hard core collectors out of the market.
Spider-Man, BatMan and X-men will sell to Kingdom come, Spawn, Saga or Hellboy will also sell to their audience (and Spawn is holding up quite well so props to Todd for ressurecting the title)

Hell, if @FROG was willing to do the work necessary, a Cyberfrog ongoing would be in the top 50 each and every month.

It is the 15th Captain Marvel reboot that failed, partly because the "new diverse audience" wants to buy Captain Marvel Vol. 1, then Captain Marvel vol 2 and never have to switch to an Avengers, X-Men or Champions run, like, you know, in Manga.
 
The traditional market had the problem of offering way too many books for way too long. No "lack of diversity" or this kind of shit. Too many crossovers, mini series and reboots that outpriced everyone but the hard core collectors out of the market.
Spider-Man, BatMan and X-men will sell to Kingdom come, Spawn, Saga or Hellboy will also sell to their audience (and Spawn is holding up quite well so props to Todd for ressurecting the title)

Hell, if @FROG was willing to do the work necessary, a Cyberfrog ongoing would be in the top 50 each and every month.

It is the 15th Captain Marvel reboot that failed, partly because the "new diverse audience" wants to buy Captain Marvel Vol. 1, then Captain Marvel vol 2 and never have to switch to an Avengers, X-Men or Champions run, like, you know, in Manga.

The profit margin of mainstream comics pamphlets is so slim that Marvel and DC tried to make it up in volume. More titles, with more advertising space, more variant covers, with higher cover prices and a poor quality presentation. They're simply treading water.

I don't know why you're bringing me into this. I don't want to make cheap monthly CYBERFROG pamphlets, fight the SJWs who will torture any small business that supports me, for little to no profit, all for the honor of perhaps hitting the Top 50 on Comichron? It's such a desolate industry.

I'm willing to do the work necessary to function outside of it and make more money. People who want Frog comics can find them on IndieGoGo or eBay.
 
How come Peggy Poulter doesn't make vids slagging off Ethan anymore?

Did they agree to a truce?
As far as I can tell Preston doesn't really talk about Comicsgate anymore, his channel seems to be focusing on writer's streams and DnD Roleplaying games. The villain of season 4 of Comicsgate was vanquished mid season and now an empty power vacuum has emerged. I'm unsure whether the reveal of Preston's past was the sole factor, rather internal drama of Anti-Comicsgate/CG™ or whatever you want to call them. I believe he and the Comic Book Hut had a falling out over something, then there was a power struggle for his CG shared universe wiki that saw Zombinomicon and Mecha McCheese depart. Vikki, DA Talks and the SWC Brothers haven't collaborated with him in some time so there's probably more behind the scenes stuff that occurred we don't know about.
So I stopped following a lot of the CG drama, especially as it relates to the Ethan Derangement Syndrome crowd, but I happened to catch the video that JDA made about Douglas Ernst and found that JDA had alienated more people, with Cummings and Preston no longer siding with him. I was trying to find out what happened, without having to go through a bunch of videos and avoiding the cancer that is Twitter, and found this page. I didn't find what I was looking for but I did find some amusing shit-flinging, and thought maybe someone here could shed light on what happened.
As far as I can tell from chatter on twitter, Jon previously tried to hire an artist with ties to ANTIFA? When the artist refused to work with him Jon claimed he was being blacklisted and did his typical cry baby routine. I think Preston called him out on his victim mentality and that was the beginning of their relationship souring publicly from what I could see. Then more recently Jon claimed that Doug Ernst was blacklisting him for refusing to promote Sixth Scale Combat's sequel book Napalm Brother's 2, which Jon was publishing for him. The rift between Preston and Jon widened and from @Mister Dongs previous post it appears Capn Cummings is done with his bullshit too. It doesn't surprise me since Cummings and Ernst are OGCG and have been friends for years and Doug is a really great guy who somehow manages to completely avoid drama.

Of course JDA himself @TheCosmicWarrior could probably answer your question better than I could.
I have some dms to share between @FROG and @Fathead.
View attachment 1693663

View attachment 1693664
View attachment 1693671
View attachment 1693673
View attachment 1693675
View attachment 1693676

Two takeaways from this.
1. donal admits "I just like making him sweat" which mean she could have paid me at any time, but would rather incriminate himself.
2. donal talks about needing to "transfer money", but I've worked at a bank, and if he's transferring between accounts at the same bank, the money transfers instantly. If it's between two different banks, it could take two days, but it's been more than 2 days by now. He also insists I'll only be happy with 10k, but I've repeatedly asked him just for 5k. He only wants to do a "50-50 split" at this point because he isn't gonna show me the accounting, and is going to manipulate this into giving himself most of the money/giving me nothing.
Props to @FROG for trying to get this ongoing issue resolved. Though I don't know whether posting those DMs was a good move Nasser, not that I don't enjoy juicy DMs, but showing Ethan giving Donal a dressing down in a private conversation between the two of them might only antagonize the situation further.
 
As far as I can tell Preston doesn't really talk about Comicsgate anymore, his channel seems to be focusing on writer's streams and DnD Roleplaying games. The villain of season 4 of Comicsgate was vanquished mid season and now an empty power vacuum has emerged. I'm unsure whether the reveal of Preston's past was the sole factor, rather internal drama of Anti-Comicsgate/CG™ or whatever you want to call them. I believe he and the Comic Book Hut had a falling out over something, then there was a power struggle for his CG shared universe wiki that saw Zombinomicon and Mecha McCheese depart. Vikki, DA Talks and the SWC Brothers haven't collaborated with him in some time so there's probably more behind the scenes stuff that occurred we don't know about.

As far as I can tell from chatter on twitter, Jon previously tried to hire an artist with ties to ANTIFA? When the artist refused to work with him Jon claimed he was being blacklisted and did his typical cry baby routine. I think Preston called him out on his victim mentality and that was the beginning of their relationship souring publicly from what I could see. Then more recently Jon claimed that Doug Ernst was blacklisting him for refusing to promote Sixth Scale Combat's sequel book Napalm Brother's 2, which Jon was publishing for him. The rift between Preston and Jon widened and from @Mister Dongs previous post it appears Capn Cummings is done with his bullshit too. It doesn't surprise me since Cummings and Ernst are OGCG and have been friends for years and Doug is a really great guy who somehow manages to completely avoid drama.

Of course JDA himself @TheCosmicWarrior could probably answer your question better than I could.

Props to @FROG for trying to get this ongoing issue resolved. Though I don't know whether posting those DMs was a good move Nasser, not that I don't enjoy juicy DMs, but showing Ethan giving Donal a dressing down in a private conversation between the two of them might only antagonize the situation further.
I don't know. I asked Ethan first if it was fine if I posted, and he said sure. I don't know if it antagonizes it further, but it's more proof that he can pay me but just chooses not to. It's not going to look good in court, which I'm looking into, and which I'll take him to if he doesn't pay me.
 
Props to @FROG for trying to get this ongoing issue resolved. Though I don't know whether posting those DMs was a good move Nasser, not that I don't enjoy juicy DMs, but showing Ethan giving Donal a dressing down in a private conversation between the two of them might only antagonize the situation further.

The inner circle is changing a lot recently. I don't want to answer for objectively terrible comics and I don't want to answer for inexcusable business practices from creators I promote.

Pay the people you're supposed to pay, whether you like them or not, or be honest about why you can't. People will work with you if you're upfront about cashflow issues.

Prolonged jackass behavior about this isn't going to be tolerated by other creators or customers, especially not while more and more mainstream creators are joining us, and will happily take your seat at the table. It reflects poorly on everyone.

It's cold out there. Do the right thing.
 
The traditional market had the problem of offering way too many books for way too long. No "lack of diversity" or this kind of shit. Too many crossovers, mini series and reboots that outpriced everyone but the hard core collectors out of the market.
Spider-Man, BatMan and X-men will sell to Kingdom come, Spawn, Saga or Hellboy will also sell to their audience (and Spawn is holding up quite well so props to Todd for ressurecting the title)

Hell, if @FROG was willing to do the work necessary, a Cyberfrog ongoing would be in the top 50 each and every month.

It is the 15th Captain Marvel reboot that failed, partly because the "new diverse audience" wants to buy Captain Marvel Vol. 1, then Captain Marvel vol 2 and never have to switch to an Avengers, X-Men or Champions run, like, you know, in Manga.
Based on @FROG current campaign he's making nearly 23k dollars per page. That puts him among the top artists in the world. A monthly comic wouldn't work logistically based on the quality of product and service he provides. Most comic creators that go fully independent produce quarterly or bi-annual books. Sometimes only one book a year or even more infrequently depending on the size of the book. EVS is beholden to his customers because he crowdfunds, so he does have to put out a product on a schedule otherwise his customers will lose faith.

The artists that create infrequently don't typically crowdfund. Theres no excuse for what retards like Mitch Breitweiser have pulled. If you're taking peoples money up front to make something that should be your primary focus. Using crowdfunding as proof of concept to secure more investors to launch the product in stores first is dishonest at best, possibly criminal.

Not for lack of trying...
View attachment 1693589
...unless the comic buying public has suddenly fallen in love with walls of text? Though I do kinda wanna know how they poop in the future if toilets are a novelty. Do they somehow J.K. Rowling magic it away?
My fucking God Bendis is an autistic faggot. Who the fuck wants to read all that shit? The walls of text remind me of Sonichu. Why DC pays this idiot top dollar to sperg and tard out onto comics pages is unfathomable to me. This is why I have become very discerning about what books I purchase.

As far as I can tell Preston doesn't really talk about Comicsgate anymore, his channel seems to be focusing on writer's streams and DnD Roleplaying games. The villain of season 4 of Comicsgate was vanquished mid season and now an empty power vacuum has emerged. I'm unsure whether the reveal of Preston's past was the sole factor, rather internal drama of Anti-Comicsgate/CG™ or whatever you want to call them. I believe he and the Comic Book Hut had a falling out over something, then there was a power struggle for his CG shared universe wiki that saw Zombinomicon and Mecha McCheese depart. Vikki, DA Talks and the SWC Brothers haven't collaborated with him in some time so there's probably more behind the scenes stuff that occurred we don't know about.

As far as I can tell from chatter on twitter, Jon previously tried to hire an artist with ties to ANTIFA? When the artist refused to work with him Jon claimed he was being blacklisted and did his typical cry baby routine. I think Preston called him out on his victim mentality and that was the beginning of their relationship souring publicly from what I could see. Then more recently Jon claimed that Doug Ernst was blacklisting him for refusing to promote Sixth Scale Combat's sequel book Napalm Brother's 2, which Jon was publishing for him. The rift between Preston and Jon widened and from @Mister Dongs previous post it appears Capn Cummings is done with his bullshit too. It doesn't surprise me since Cummings and Ernst are OGCG and have been friends for years and Doug is a really great guy who somehow manages to completely avoid drama.

Of course JDA himself @TheCosmicWarrior could probably answer your question better than I could.

Props to @FROG for trying to get this ongoing issue resolved. Though I don't know whether posting those DMs was a good move Nasser, not that I don't enjoy juicy DMs, but showing Ethan giving Donal a dressing down in a private conversation between the two of them might only antagonize the situation further.
To be fair to JDA for an artist to chimp out and bail because of who he supports for President, an inconsequential position that barely affects anyone's life, in solid blue California of all places is pretty gay.
Anti-CG was never going to last. A-logging EVS on youtube is just as boring as people who a-log Chris-Chan on youtube. Getting mad at a tard and making an anti-fan club focused on being mad at said tard is utterly pointless.

The inner circle is changing a lot recently. I don't want to answer for objectively terrible comics and I don't want to answer for inexcusable business practices from creators I promote.

Pay the people you're supposed to pay, whether you like them or not, or be honest about why you can't. People will work with you if you're upfront about cashflow issues.

Prolonged jackass behavior about this isn't going to be tolerated by other creators or customers, especially not while more and more mainstream creators are joining us, and will happily take your seat at the table. It reflects poorly on everyone.

It's cold out there. Do the right thing.
Just admit Wenger is a complete idiot and his art looks like shit.
Donal is clearly a vindictive prick. I dislike Cecil but I honestly feel bad for him. Cash Grab depends on Donal and the pizza cuck has gone rogue as a full fledged retard. If Donal hadn't decided to hold Nasser's money hostage and be a complete fag about paying him things would be a lot different.
 
I have some dms to share between @FROG and @Fathead.
View attachment 1693663

View attachment 1693664
View attachment 1693671
View attachment 1693673
View attachment 1693675
View attachment 1693676

Two takeaways from this.
1. donal admits "I just like making him sweat" which mean she could have paid me at any time, but would rather incriminate himself.
2. donal talks about needing to "transfer money", but I've worked at a bank, and if he's transferring between accounts at the same bank, the money transfers instantly. If it's between two different banks, it could take two days, but it's been more than 2 days by now. He also insists I'll only be happy with 10k, but I've repeatedly asked him just for 5k. He only wants to do a "50-50 split" at this point because he isn't gonna show me the accounting, and is going to manipulate this into giving himself most of the money/giving me nothing.
I will never support another project Donal is a part of. I'm even considering refunding Cash Grab because of Donal's involvement and I've got quite a bit in it.

You shouldn't accept a random amount without seeing the accounting.
 
I will never support another project Donal is a part of. I'm even considering refunding Cash Grab because of Donal's involvement and I've got quite a bit in it.

You shouldn't accept a random amount without seeing the accounting.
I don't want to hurt Cecil financially in all this, but do whatever you're comfortable with.

I could probably find dms too where we talked about seeing accounting, which would just make donal's offer of "you can only see the accounting if I get to own your half of brutas" look even worse (which it's already illegal).
 
I don't want to hurt Cecil financially in all this, but do whatever you're comfortable with.

I could probably find dms too where we talked about seeing accounting, which would just make donal's offer of "you can only see the accounting if I get to own your half of brutas" look even worse (which it's already illegal).

That’s not what I said. Stop lying.

I said I would send you a condensed version of accounting if you agreed to forfeit your rights to the IP if you made the information public.

If you don’t post that info publicly, you have nothing to worry about. You saying no shows me you can’t be trusted with private information and makes me glad you don’t have access to customer dox.
 
That’s not what I said. Stop lying.

I said I would send you a condensed version of accounting if you agreed to forfeit your rights to the IP if you made the information public.

If you don’t post that info publicly, you have nothing to worry about. You saying no shows me you can’t be trusted with private information and makes me glad you don’t have access to customer dox.
Because if you screw me over in the accounting, you dont want me to expose you. So it's either get screwed and stay silent, or talk about it and get screwed.

Also how the hell would anyone get doxed if I knew the expenses?

All the customers who backed my other campaigns got 2 comics. Nobody got brutas.

My PayPal is NasserRabadi13@yahoo.com you can pay me now.
 
Because if you screw me over in the accounting, you dont want me to expose you. So it's either get screwed and stay silent, or talk about it and get screwed.

Also how the hell would anyone get doxed if I knew the expenses?

All the customers who backed my other campaigns got 2 comics. Nobody got brutas.

My PayPal is NasserRabadi13@yahoo.com you can pay me now.
So basically, unless you get an amount that makes you happy, you actually won’t “go away” and move on.

So you lied again when you tried extortion.
 
Back
Top Bottom