You are genuinely fucking retarded if you think Phil could convincingly insult or say anything that would “cook” anyone.
Sure, some detractors are massive faggots and unfunny retards. But, Phil is completely devoid of an original thought or opinion. He has never once in his life been clever or charismatic enough to even approach being “funny”.
At best you’d get two unfunny retards flailing at each other.
As we've seen with most DSP interviews, it's not about an exchange of disses, but quite literally who ends up looking like the bigger loser. If you turn into a weird sperg over his cat blood tests and start yelling at him - you instantly hand him the win.
He knows how these situations work - feign ignorance, remain calm, accuse your opponent of being emotional (regardless if they are or not, you need this to build a narrative) and just let them seem like an unhinged retard.
Then, leave it to the rest of the detractors to crucify one of their own, because "they gave Phil ammo" or "they made Phil right".
Phil will never admit defeat. Especially at the moment when it happens. So, you defeat him by "being more normal than him", targeting his insecurities and pointing out his inconsistencies until he is seething for years. And you don't do that by convincing yourself that you know his character - you do that by studying his behavior.
Many detractors are convinced they know exactly what happens every second of Phil's life - what his relationship is like, what his free time is like, etc. And that's what makes them deluded and over-confident, and it makes you look like a retard.
Stick to the facts, publicly recorded and widely available - the things he's trying to cut off his streams, the things he's ashamed of the public seeing and
the pattern of behavior that can be observed on a daily basis - guilt tripping, logical fallacies, emotional manipulation, hypocrisy, and so on.
If you haven't noticed, the most "successful" and well-liked detractors use Phil's own behavior against him by simply remembering it. And the detractors who fall off make it about themselves vs DSP - a guy who most likely doesn't even know they exist.
DSP is his own biggest detractor - publicly, privately, unknowingly and unwillingly.
Just use that against him and you will win.