Dat Kang spergs, supporters freak out.

[Dat Sped]

You're the one who came in claiming everyone only likes it because everybody here is thirsty, how exactly would you improve it if a fanfic of a fanfic offends you so?

Fine, let's go piece by piece since everyone is sperging out over this. Remember, this will give you all the material you need to whiteknight and win this girl's heart.

Let's start with the first 20 pages.

Page 1: Oh look, Liquid is the truly good Chris. Never seen this done before. NEXT!
Page 2: "Solid Chris, eager to have his ego validated..." Yes, Chris has an ego and is unoriginal. Nothing new to see here.
Page 3: Okay, we're setting up Rosechu. This is somewhat interesting.
Page 4: Rosechu whining about stuff. Is this going to become a reoccuring theme?
Page 5: Okay, this is Chris's tagline for Sonichu. I'll give her credit, at least when Trickie says this is someone's story and nothing less, she means it.
Page 6: Okay, this kind of explains why Rosechu is kinda useless in the actual comics.
Page 7: Remember what I said at page 4?
Page 8: And back to page 4 again...wait, I'm sorry. This shows that the comic "has heart".
Page 9-12: Better animation for a scene that already happened in the original, so not much to say here. At least it looks like Rosechu quickly moving her head, unlike the CWC version where she looks like she has two heads.
Page 13-14: OH MY GOD QUIT BEING SO DAMN WHINY, ROSECHU!!!! Is this what Rosechu's story is; re-readng Sonichu with her mopey internal monologues?
Page 15: I will give Goddess Trickie some credit here, this is exposition done right. If this were Chris, the textwalling would be in full effect.
Page 16: I should be rooting for Rosechu to convince Kel not to prostitute her to the extreme, but all that whining before...
Page 17: Okay, remember how people used that whole pointed-tail bit to troll Chris...and how funny that was. Yeah, this took all the funny away from that with just more whining.
Page 18: Kel apologizing.
Page 19: Sonichu is gone. Please don't tell me Rosechu is gonna mope some more.
Page 20: She didn't! Thank GodJesus and the Bear!

Shall I go on?

Wouldn't be surprised if his ideas were either "I wouldn't bother" or just incredibly stupid that even Chris would have to ask "Why?".

So, because I'm not writing fanfics, I don't have the right to criticize other people's? By that same right, I have to like every movie I see, since I would only have the right to criticize a film I don't like if I were a filmmaker.

 

[Silvally]

Fine, let's go piece by piece since everyone is sperging out over this. Remember, this will give you all the material you need to whiteknight and win this girl's heart.

Let's start with the first 20 pages.

Page 1: Oh look, Liquid is the truly good Chris. Never seen this done before. NEXT!
Page 2: "Solid Chris, eager to have his ego validated..." Yes, Chris has an ego and is unoriginal. Nothing new to see here.
Page 3: Okay, we're setting up Rosechu. This is somewhat interesting.
Page 4: Rosechu whining about stuff. Is this going to become a reoccuring theme?
Page 5: Okay, this is Chris's tagline for Sonichu. I'll give her credit, at least when Trickie says this is someone's story and nothing less, she means it.
Page 6: Okay, this kind of explains why Rosechu is kinda useless in the actual comics.
Page 7: Remember what I said at page 4?
Page 8: And back to page 4 again...wait, I'm sorry. This shows that the comic "has heart".
Page 9-12: Better animation for a scene that already happened in the original, so not much to say here. At least it looks like Rosechu quickly moving her head, unlike the CWC version where she looks like she has two heads.
Page 13-14: OH MY GOD QUIT BEING SO DAMN WHINY, ROSECHU!!!! Is this what Rosechu's story is; re-readng Sonichu with her mopey internal monologues?
Page 15: I will give Goddess Trickie some credit here, this is exposition done right. If this were Chris, the textwalling would be in full effect.
Page 16: I should be rooting for Rosechu to convince Kel not to prostitute her to the extreme, but all that whining before...
Page 17: Okay, remember how people used that whole pointed-tail bit to troll Chris...and how funny that was. Yeah, this took all the funny away from that with just more whining.
Page 18: Kel apologizing.
Page 19: Sonichu is gone. Please don't tell me Rosechu is gonna mope some more.
Page 20: She didn't! Thank GodJesus and the Bear!

Shall I go on?

oh so you come from the Chris school of thought where every one should be happy even when they drastically change form are de powered and scared of being abandoned by there best friend. you do realize emotional Drama is a legit theme right?

 

[Dat Sped]

oh so you come from the Chris school of thought where every one should be happy even when they drastically change form are de powered and scared of being abandoned by there best friend. you do realize emotional Drama is a legit theme right?

1) "There", "their", and "they're" are not interchangeable.
2) I realize it now, since I read a web comic where it was beaten over my head.
3) If we had a build to that sorrow, I could probably appreciate it more. But right out of the chute, it's all 'i mope, therefore I am".

 

[Lalala]

Fine, let's go piece by piece since everyone is sperging out over this. Remember, this will give you all the material you need to whiteknight and win this girl's heart.

Let's start with the first 20 pages.

Page 1: Oh look, Liquid is the truly good Chris. Never seen this done before. NEXT!
Page 2: "Solid Chris, eager to have his ego validated..." Yes, Chris has an ego and is unoriginal. Nothing new to see here.
Page 3: Okay, we're setting up Rosechu. This is somewhat interesting.
Page 4: Rosechu whining about stuff. Is this going to become a reoccuring theme?
Page 5: Okay, this is Chris's tagline for Sonichu. I'll give her credit, at least when Trickie says this is someone's story and nothing less, she means it.
Page 6: Okay, this kind of explains why Rosechu is kinda useless in the actual comics.
Page 7: Remember what I said at page 4?
Page 8: And back to page 4 again...wait, I'm sorry. This shows that the comic "has heart".
Page 9-12: Better animation for a scene that already happened in the original, so not much to say here. At least it looks like Rosechu quickly moving her head, unlike the CWC version where she looks like she has two heads.
Page 13-14: OH MY GOD QUIT BEING SO DAMN WHINY, ROSECHU!!!! Is this what Rosechu's story is; re-readng Sonichu with her mopey internal monologues?
Page 15: I will give Goddess Trickie some credit here, this is exposition done right. If this were Chris, the textwalling would be in full effect.
Page 16: I should be rooting for Rosechu to convince Kel not to prostitute her to the extreme, but all that whining before...
Page 17: Okay, remember how people used that whole pointed-tail bit to troll Chris...and how funny that was. Yeah, this took all the funny away from that with just more whining.
Page 18: Kel apologizing.
Page 19: Sonichu is gone. Please don't tell me Rosechu is gonna mope some more.
Page 20: She didn't! Thank GodJesus and the Bear!

Shall I go on?

So er yeah I'm a straight chick, just gonna throw out there my motivations have nothing to do with winning over some other woman.
And I'm gonna give ya credit here, you've acknowledged the things you don't like about the comic while still keeping an open enough mind to point out things you think were done well which I can respect. It's not your cup of tea, whatever, the worlds gonna keep on spinning.
But I do think, as some commented before, some things have been oversimplified in your critique which is frustrating as they see Trickie taking a character who's sole purpose was to be a pretty set of tits'n'ass for the male lead and actually tried to give her some personality and reasonable reactions to whats happened to her. Shes suddenly a new species, lost her main source of power, and in that what she considers her usefulness, and is trying to avoid being considered useless and shoved into a dark forgotten space for the rest of her existence. Come on man, even the strongest willed uber optimist would be mopey if everything they knew changed for the worst because they got smacked by a rainbow, Trickie's taking the absurd situation and trying to convey a semi-realistic reaction to it in universe.
But like I said like or don't like doesn't matter to me personally, just interested in what caused the dislike really.

 

[Ido]

Why is this even a discussion right now? An autistic argument is not what I want to see when this thread gets bumped,

 

[Jewelsmakerguy]

Why is this even a discussion right now? An autistic argument is not what I want to see when this thread gets bumped,

Blame @Dat Kang for starting it. He's the one who claimed this was a rip off of The Real Sonichu.

And speaking of, Mr. Kang, do you think that's a terrible fancomic too? Also...

So, because I'm not writing fanfics, I don't have the right to criticize other people's? By that same right, I have to like every movie I see, since I would only have the right to criticize a film I don't like if I were a filmmaker.

And which ass did you pull this assumption from?

I didn't even say anywhere that you weren't writing fanfic. I was assuming what you'd do if you did this differently.