Dreadnought: The Quest for Cringe - White-Kettle-Shufflepunk reads a trans YA superhero novel

I feel like it isn't surprising that people who think a twelve year old can consent to having their breast-buds removed also think they should be treated like adult combatants.

The more I think about it, the more it feels like Daniels ignored some major story potential. Danny pretty much blames all his problems in life on his dad, right? Now you have this young kid, who's been indoctrinated and turned into a living weapon of war by her own dad. Isn't there... something there?
 
Now I'm wondering if, off-screen, Garrison/Sovereign gave his daughter the supervillain equivalent of "The Talk" that Helen gave Dash and Violet in The Incredibles. The one about how the real-life baddies will kill you if they get the chance, so don't give them that chance.

"Look, most superheroes are kind of pussies, but this Dreadnought is a fucking lunatic."
 
This has been one of my favorite reads on KF, thanks for that. The experience is surreal - the disconnect between what Daniels sees and what a non-brainwashed reader sees is huge. A bit more self-awareness and honesty on the author's side and these books would have been super-villain origin stories.

He's a sociopath, isn't he? He only pretends to care about others as long as they exist to validate him. The moment they cease their usefulness they turn to air. One of Doc's bodies is splattered over the cockpit and Danny just... barely acknowledges it. No human reaction, no shock or anything to seeing his android waifu/mommy/caretaker violently die. It doesn't matter in his mind. She has more bodies, who cares if some of them die? Supervillain mentality.

Danny is bloodthirsty, he is violent, and he suffers from bouts of insecurity followed by incel rage at the whole world for hurting his feelings. And he has absolutely no qualms about crippling anyone, oh no. Just in the latest part of the review, tranny Superman kicks a 12 yo in the head as hard as he can. No holding back, no hesitation. Panzer's dead, shield or not.

Speaking of which...

Why isn't the Big Bad Dad more concerned about his daughter? The Dread Squad must have gotten through her to make it to Garrison. Imo the most logical conclusion would be that Panzer is dead given Danny's history of murderous bloodlust. Garrison should be more worried, question Danny about the encounter, and finally unleash hell upon the '''whitecape''', believing the monster before him killed his girl in cold blood.

The fight itself irks me as it follows the usual formula - throughout both books I kept noticing Danny acts like a smug, insufferable prick, especially when fighting someone he perceives weaker than him. He mocks the villains, insults them, displays his utter lack of respect for them - and then they land a few hits on him, after which he instantly shits himself. It is clear he perceives himself as the strongest super in the world and the moment someone threatens to shake that belief, Danny loses much of his bravado, leading to him going into rage mode.

What a read.
 
This has been one of my favorite reads on KF, thanks for that.

You're all too kind.

He's a sociopath, isn't he? He only pretends to care about others as long as they exist to validate him. The moment they cease their usefulness they turn to air. One of Doc's bodies is splattered over the cockpit and Danny just... barely acknowledges it. No human reaction, no shock or anything to seeing his android waifu/mommy/caretaker violently die. It doesn't matter in his mind. She has more bodies, who cares if some of them die?

See, I would be more forgiving of this if Doc and Danny had fought together a lot and he'd simply internalised the fact that Doc doesn't "live" in any given body, but rather a server somewhere. A bit like how the other X-Men don't usually freak out when Wolverine gets stabbed or shot.

However, here I'm inclined to agree with you, because this is pretty much the first time Danny has seen Doc "die." Plus, it doesn't help Daniels chose to homage Alien in his description of Doc's innards. When they did the effects for Ash being revealed as an android, Ridley Scott and his crew chose to have him be more of a synthetic emulation of human biology than a clanking, metal affair like say, the Terminator. The result is, despite Ash not having a drop of blood in his body, it's a shockingly gory scene.

So, naturally, Dan has no particular reaction to such a similar sight right before his eyes. If anything, he seems more disturbed by Kinetiq's loose can of spray-paint.
 
The fight itself irks me as it follows the usual formula - throughout both books I kept noticing Danny acts like a smug, insufferable prick, especially when fighting someone he perceives weaker than him. He mocks the villains, insults them, displays his utter lack of respect for them - and then they land a few hits on him, after which he instantly shits himself. It is clear he perceives himself as the strongest super in the world and the moment someone threatens to shake that belief, Danny loses much of his bravado, leading to him going into rage mode.

I brought it up earlier, but Danny is in actuality everything he proclaimed his father to be. And unlike with Papa Tozer, people other than Danny recognize it.

That says a lot about Danny, but it says even more about Daniels, because Danny is a super-villain just waiting to snap.
 
Last edited:
At least me and Daniels can agree that Alien was a fantastic film.
Doc should have spilled her spaghetti.

No disrespect to Calamity, but maybe bringing someone whose only powers are "parkour" and "guns that aren't as good at killing people" against a group with their own private army and the ability to manufacture as many real supers as they want.
It seemed odd to me too that they'd bring her along as "mission leader", but I guess she is the one Dread Squad member with her head screwed on more-or-less straight. I mean, you don't really want "BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD" Danny or "BOOZE FOR THE MACHINE GOD" Doc in charge of the whole op, right?

“What does that do to our ROE?” asks Kinetiq. ROE stands for Rules of Engagement
... What?! The ROE has been "kill or be killed" for ages. Were Garrison's goons all shooting paintball guns? Was Red Steel ordered to "Just rough him up a bit"? Why would you even think you could storm the supervillain hideout after they declared war on the world, without being prepared to kill on your way in and kill on your way out?
Like Danny's "tactile telekinesis", the whole "Killing Question" is just another one of those things lifted from real comics without the context.

“I choose me,” she says a moment before it starts hurling cobalt fire at Cynosure. The top floor of the nearest tower is obliterated in a cascading series of explosions.
Shouldn't this be game over right there? The inner sanctum is suspended from the three towers, one of which Doc just easily wrecked. If the mansion isn't already crashing down, another shot or two should do the trick. Why is anyone bothering with a hand-to-hand slugfest when Graywytch is probably in the sanctum uploading Garrison's next global strike to the satellites right now?

Why the fuck did Garrison need to steal Thunderbolt's powers? Now, let's be charitable and suggest that maybe you can only give someone who already has powers new ones by draining them from another super.
And does that mean they had to drain some other poor schmuck to give Red Steel his eyebeams? Wouldn't it have been more useful to have that guy around and helping rather than giving Red Steel one or two surprise hits on Danny?

Another segment of drywall I was using to haul myself to my feet cracks and crumbles under my grip as that rage I need so much finally arrives.
Yeah, Danny the rage-goblin continues to be a rage-goblin, what more can be said at this point?
It would have been so easy to dash off something like "This time I'm filled with a righteous determination to fight for justice and it makes me even stronger than rage ever did", but our author can't be bothered with even the most perfunctory laundering of Danny's black, black cape.

Calamity cuts in over a background of gunfire and Doc Impossible’s screaming profanity
Doc chooses the weirdest things to LARP. Wasn't she supposed to be embracing her true machine nature at least a bit more? Can't she turn off the "Panic and scream incoherently" subroutines until the world is saved? A stone-cold machine intellect would probably be more helpful right now at keeping the hyperjet running.

God, the Killing Question bit was slimy. It needed someone to answer Calamity's statement with "So, we're killing them, then." And then we could have had a cool follow-up like "Only if we have to-" "As many as we have to. We're killing them. We don't have a way to stop Garrison's power other than killing him, and people are dying right now because of it. We're killing them."
Calamity's mom is trapped in a wall right now, let us not forget. (And Doc's mom is probably having the mother of all BSODs, but who's counting?) Why is anyone so detached about this? They know the stakes are not only life-and-death, but personal. And we're talking about a ragtag band of teen superheroes here, not hardened Nick Fury-type operators. Put a little emotion into it, for Pete's sake! Or as it was well put already:
It's not helped that the tone bounces between whatever emotional state is needed for the quirky punchlines.

Daniels seems to have deep contempt for any super-suit that isn't basic as fuck.
Paints his nails, gets catty about fashion... can we at least get some stable characterization when it comes to AGP vs HSTS?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
So, here's a fun thought experiment: @White-Kettle Shufflepunk suggested that Garrison ought to have gone full Quiverfull and produced a whole superhero team of precocious kids. In a better book, who are they, and what aspects of the vague amorphous blob of chuds on Twitter do they represent? My submission:

Archimandrite
Theme: Ortho-LARP
Costume: sort of a superheroey take on the schema robes
download (2).jpeg
Powers: Defensive+healing magic (although he wouldn't call it that)
Origin: he went to visit a Russian monastery one time (Garrison indulges his children, naturally) and accidentally wandered into the ossuary, where he found the lost femur of Saint Plotinus Incitus and had a vision from Heaven
 
and produced a whole superhero team of precocious kids
Doesn't even have to be kids - the Magic Space Rock apparently governs all superhero origin stories, like getting bitten by a radioactive spider or pulling a magic sword from a stone.

It's a good question though, what "Twitter villain" archetypes haven't we hit? We've got the TERF book witch, the tech bro libertarian/NRx, the insufficiently supportive family, and the MRA incel (Danny's ex-best-friend from school).

As you point out, we don't get a religious fundamentalist. But maybe the biggest omission is actual Nazis. I guess you don't need stock villains it's OK to kill when Danny just kills 'em all.

There's no Trump lookalike either, you'd think the temptation to have a literal Bad Orange Man would've been irresistible.
 
There's no Trump lookalike either, you'd think the temptation to have a literal Bad Orange Man would've been irresistible.

I think Danny mentioned the president saying stuff about trans soldiers in the military, so I'm guessing that was literally Trump in-universe. Because I guess despite Mistress Malice killing millions of Americans in the 50s, their political history is exactly the same as ours.

It's a good question though, what "Twitter villain" archetypes haven't we hit?

Do "centrists" (aka normie Dems) count? It'd be insanely hypocritical, but when has that stopped Daniels?

So, here's a fun thought experiment: @White-Kettle Shufflepunk suggested that Garrison ought to have gone full Quiverfull and produced a whole superhero team of precocious kids. In a better book, who are they, and what aspects of the vague amorphous blob of chuds on Twitter do they represent? My submission:

Wonderful.

One of the kids is definitely a Spartan themed boy, so Kinetiq can go "Ashally, Sparta's military record wasn't that impressive, and they were all pederasts." Still, looks adorable in his little hoplite armour.
 
So, here's a fun thought experiment: @White-Kettle Shufflepunk suggested that Garrison ought to have gone full Quiverfull and produced a whole superhero team of precocious kids. In a better book, who are they, and what aspects of the vague amorphous blob of chuds on Twitter do they represent?
Kid Superman. Superboy? The real hero, trying to stop the tranny copycat from completing his supervillain origin story. Unfortunately, it ends with Superboy missing all his limbs after Danny unleashes his murderous rage. Then we get a scene of Danny looking down at his handiwork.

"I have just crippled a kid for life. Perhaps GrayWytch was right. I really was a terrible person. Doc and Sarah deserved better than a monster like me in their lives. But then I remembered Superboy wanted to seal my powers away. He wanted to return me into the wrong, male body, to my abusive parents, to eternal inceldom shared with David. Oh. All my regret was gone in an instant and I eyed the broken child with grim satisfaction."

It's a good question though, what "Twitter villain" archetypes haven't we hit?
Trolls, I guess? Them darn Kiwi Farmer Nazi Trolls! And maybe Christians?

"You pray to your God but it's me who keeps saving the world!" - Danny, probably
 
I say bring back the de-limbed guy from Book 1 that Danny ended up beating up twice, who's been now built into a WH40K-esque Actual Fucking Dreadnought with specific anti-Danny weaponry, by the guy's kid brother (who is the actual kid superhero). Hell, give the kid a watered-down version of Garrison's power that counters magic and also amplifies hypertech, and make him represent the Internet Atheist / Rationalist / Programmer and Tech group, and specifically have the kid have been on Team Dreadnought before he saw who Danny really was, and Danny's actions affected him personally.

I mean, fuck it, there's a hacker or hackers out there who can challenge Doc, and clearly there is Some Bullshit in engineering the ocean habitat; let's make the unseen hypertech-jockeys into an actual character, and it would give some vague credence to the accusations of Garrison seducing people to the dark side with the power of NRX.
 
All right, screw it. Round two, shithead, let’s go.

Round two? Bitch, we're barely into round one!

You can have your kung fu and your Krav Maga or whatever else you got, I don’t care. Utopia had an antireality cannon and look what happened to her.

Yes, I remember you closing the gaping hole in your chest by wanting to hard enough, because you happened to be the first Dreadnought to actually realise you could do that. Daniels, please don't use your shit storytelling as the basis of a brag.

The slap of fists to meat that comes off like gunshots.


And hey, did I mention he’s got lightning powers? Because he’s got freaking lightning powers, and it’s really pissing me off. My suit is a powerful insulator, which is the only reason I’m not dead yet, but even so, his lightning burns and stings and makes every punch land harder.

Here's a thought, why aren't all of Garrison's troops armed with electric weapons?

And they fight and they fight and they fight...

—tumbling through a wall together, jewels of shattered glass spinning from our bodies, and for a still moment noticing that beneath us Calamity is taking apart a tactical team with her bare hands.

You know, when Batman does shit like that, at least when he's being written with some connection to reality, he does it by using stealth or disorientating his enemies. Think the predator mode stuff from the Arkham games. He doesn't usually just... run at a bunch of armed, armoured dudes with just the power of gymkata. If Daniels is going to write Calamity like a full-fledged superhuman, why not just... make her one?

Doc has dropped her guns, is firing energy blasts from her palms—

Wait, so Doc had inbuilt energy-weapons, and she was relying on regular guns? Why does "not pretending to be human anymore" only appear to amount to "now I'm a much more expensive Jamie Maddox"?

—and then through the mansion and tumbling across the sod, great ribbons of grassy turf thrown into the sky as Sovereign and I savage each other again and again.


Kinetiq and Panzer streak past us, a flying lightshow of lasers and muzzle flash. Kinetiq gives Sovereign a burst of crimson energy right to his face as they pass, but Panzer’s got the same idea, and I catch a rocket with my gut.


“Kinetiq, that psych-out would come in handy any time,” I call over the radio.


“Working on it!” they reply, voice labored, breathing heavy. “The brat got a second wind!”


Great strategy, Danny. Really, you should go pro.

A reminder that the strategy they're talking about is beating the shit out of a child in order to shake her father.

“If one of you’d finish your side of the dance and come give us some air support, I wouldn’t tell you not to,” says Calamity. The sound of gunfire is evermore hectic over her comms. “Codex, how we doin’, partner?”


Gunfire is a bit muffled, but still an obvious baseline under his reply. “It’s one of those good news, bad news things.”


“Bad news,” says Calamity.


“Graywytch set up some more magical booby traps. I need to untangle them.”


“And the good news?”


“They’re not very good booby traps. I think I can do this without getting my head blown off.”

Didn't some Italian guy have something to say about people whose enemies were simultaneously incredibly dangerous and laughably impotent?

“Wait, that doesn’t make sense,” says Doc. “Are you sure?”

“Pretty sure,” says Codex.

“Gift horses, Doctor,” grumbles Calamity. “Keep going, Codex. Tell us when—SHIT! DOC, THE LEFT! WATCH THE LEFT!”

In a smart book, it would turn out Charlie--a teenage hobbyist--was unable to recognize the subtleties of Graywytch's spellwork, and he would then be painfully transformed into a literal bag of dicks.

What the hell are you—oh shit. There he is again, with two men who look like they were cooks hiding in a walk-in cooler. Holding them by the back of their jackets, Sovereign floats out over the promenade and beckons me to the fight with his head.


It’s too risky to throw more bricks at him; I’ve got to close and engage. But when I drive a hard punch at his face, suddenly an innocent cook is in the way to block me. I manage to pull the attack just in time to catch the back of Sovereign’s boot with the side of my head. The cooks are screaming, pleading, and he doesn’t care. Another kick erupts from between the two of them, and I barely turn the blow with my shoulder—the wounded one where Panzer shot me. Crimson spikes of agony stab up and down my arm and I cry out.

I'm almost shocked Danny doesn't just write the cooks off like tankies do the Romanov servants. Also, is it me, or do civilians feel really absent from these books? I think that's another reason Danny feels less like a battle-loving superhero and more like a blood psychopath. Almost all his interactions with non-supers--remember, Cecilia has super-stamina or something--are either indifferent, or downright hateful, like with his parents or David. This is actually a wider problem in a lot of modern cape-comics: the heroes only really interact with other superheroes.

Back up, back up fast to get distance and reconsider.


“So that’s it? Stalemate?” I call to him across the chasm between the towers. “That’s your big play?”


Princess Panzer tears between us on jets of pink flame, Kinetiq right behind her, cobalt beams lashing from their eyes.


“I don’t see a stalemate, little girl,” Sovereign says, an instant before he charges. My heart clenches—baseline humans can’t take acceleration like that!

Okay, embarrassing failure of reading comprehension on my part, first time I read this passage, I thought Danny was horrified that Garrison could handle such acceleration, completely forgetting the cooks he was holding hostage. But yeah, Danny has to save both of them by sapping their momentum with the lattice, yadayada, which Sovereign uses as an opening to fuck him up. Danny spends a few paragraphs getting the shit kicked out of him, which might've been satisfying if it wasn't so dull, but then he remembers something:

There was a group photo taken after the Northern Union superteam stopped that asteroid from hitting us three years ago. I remember I bought a glossy copy because I was hoping to get it signed someday. In that photo, Thunderbolt was wearing a pressure suit, unlike the old Dreadnought. That’s because Dreadnought could hold his breath for hours on end. So can I. Thunderbolt couldn’t. And Sovereign is using Thunderbolt’s powers.

Worth a try, though, admittedly, for all Danny knows, Sovereign stole a bunch of powers. Hell, who says he hasn't drained Red Steel?

We hit the water at nearly the speed of sound. Half-delirious with pain, struggling to keep my hold on the lattice, I didn’t fly well. It feels like I hit every wall and piece of furniture I could on the way off the island. But it doesn’t matter, because my legs are still locked around his waist, and my hand is still locked into his head, and we are headed as far down as I can drag us.


The water is cold. It’s heavy. The salt stings my wounds. In a matter of moments we’re in darkness, and the pressure is a vice grip. The water slows his punches—they hurt, but not so much. My thumb comes out of his eye with a blooming black cloud, and I make a steel band of my arm around the back of his head, lock him in tight to my chest and throat.


Down, down, deeper we go. The anchor cables for Cynosure slide past, a dark bamboo forest reaching down to infinity. High above us, daylight winks dimly through the rippling scales of the surface.


I can tell the moment he figures out what’s going to happen. There is a horrified stillness, and then he begins to thrash. Electricity floods out from him, as much as he can make, but in his panic he can’t focus it to make it behave unnaturally like he normally can. It flows over my suit’s insulation and heads to the sea floor, harmlessly. My broken arm is as far out of the way as I can get it, and I clench tight to him with every other muscle I have. You’re down here with me, Sovereign. You’re down here until I decide to let you go. You don’t get to hurt anybody else.

"That's my job!"


I watch his heart slam in his chest. I watch his legs thrash and twist. Not much longer now. He’s still hurting me. His attacks still land. But I’m tougher than he imagined I was, and more deliberately cruel. They never see it coming. They never expect that someone who looks like me could have so much calm, considered malice at her disposal. By the time they figure it out, it tends to be too late.


The last handfuls of breath escape his chest. He spasms, seawater rushing into his lungs, plumping them out tight. He thrashes again, harder than ever, and then goes still. Cautiously, I loosen my legs. He stays limp in the water and begins to sink.


I am not undefeated.


I am undefeatable.

I know those two quotes were very long, but, man, you needed to see it all.

Up, up into the air, water streaming off my shoulders, pouring off my cape, Sovereign’s ankle clenched in my good hand. His face is pale, his eyes half-lidded. It takes some effort to shake the water out of his lungs, and when I drop him onto the promenade he lands with a wet smack. First things first, I pull one of Codex’s trinkets out of the low-profile cargo blister on my thigh and use it to tie his wrists. It’s tricky with only one hand, but I’ve still got most of my teeth, and I manage. The magic makes the necklace chain as strong as titanium wire, and it should dampen all his powers—including his power-dampening field. Magic is weird. When I roll him onto his back he’s still not breathing. A roll of nausea twists up my throat, and I move straight into CPR.


The chorus of “Staying Alive” by the Bee Gees happens to be the perfect rhythm for the chest-pumping part of CPR.

Threat Level Midnight was a better book than this, and that was a film!

With a cold, urgent fear driving me, I push his ribs in to the beat of the song I’m whispering under my breath. (I’ve heard that paramedics hate this song. Now I know why.) Please. Wake up. Doc was right. Please, wake up. I blow into his mouth. With my ear down at his lips to listen for breath and watch his chest, a little voice in my head screams, the lattice, you idiot!

The Plot-Inciting Orb may have solved all of Danny's problems, but it's caused all of ours.

Princess Panzer comes screaming out of the sky. She lands in a flurry of vernier thrusters and unfolding weapons platforms that gleam in the sun. In a half-second I’m staring down a tank platoon’s worth of firepower.


“GET AWAY FROM MY DADDY!” she shouts, rigid with terror. At least three railguns are pointed at my head, their capacitors crackling with stored charge.


“He’s inhaled a lot of water. I’m trying to save him—”


“MURDERER!” Two of the laser pods floating behind her paint me with targeting beams.

Technically inaccurate, but not for lack of trying.

As calmly as I can, I raise a placating hand. “The CPR isn’t working. He needs a defibrillator. Is there one of those on the island? Do you know where to find it?”


Tears are rolling down her cheeks. Panzer looks from me to her father and begins to shake. “I don’t—I don’t know,” her voice is tiny. “Please, Dreadnought, you can’t let him die.”


“Can you make one?” I ask.


She nods, more a spasmodic jerk than anything else. The railguns fold up and disappear into the nowhere they came out of.


“You need to have the right amps and volts or else—”


“The magic does all that,” she says distractedly. Panzer’s eyes are unfocused as a pair of silver paddles edged in gold appear from folds of light.

Okay, is Panzer saying magic literally or figuratively? Well, I suppose all magic is figurative here, now. The defibulator works.

Panzer takes a step forward, murder on her face.


“Princess,” rasps Garrison. She stops dead, and looks down at him, her face stricken. “No. I can’t lose you. Not after everything else.”

Surely he'd use her real name here?

Panzer collapses into sobbing. Garrison sits up as best he can, leans against the lip of a long, low planter box. She crawls to her father and curls up in his lap. Garrison whispers to her, says that it’s going to be okay.

For a moment, I don’t understand why I am stabbed with envy.

Yeah, yeah, your dad yelled at you entirely off page, we get it.
 
As always, thanks for chewing through this.

Calamity is taking apart a tactical team with her bare hands.
First the book states they're all sort of special forces, then they get beaten by an unarmed girl? Garrison gave them no powers? None at all? They don't even have guns? And when was it established unarmed combat was Calamity's specialty?

Wait, so Doc had inbuilt energy-weapons, and she was relying on regular guns? Why does "not pretending to be human anymore" only appear to amount to "now I'm a much more expensive Jamie Maddox"?
She sobered up and remembered she had these. Alcohol is a bitch.

“They’re not very good booby traps. I think I can do this without getting my head blown off.”

“Wait, that doesn’t make sense,” says Doc. “Are you sure?”
Lemme guess, lemme guess! Graywytch purposely made them weak because she knew the Dread Squad would arrive and beat Garrison's ass. All part of her incredibly cunning plan!

I'm almost shocked Danny doesn't just write the cooks off like tankies do the Romanov servants.
Didn't the Dread Squad blow up half the building...? Why does Garrison think Danny of all people cares about hostages? If anything, it's been established Danny only cares if there's witnesses who can report on him and make him look bad.

long drowning scene
You can't tell me Danny's not enjoying it. He absolutely revels in slowly drowning a man. I thought Danny's story arc was about overcoming his inner sadist but apparently not.

And then Danny pulls Garrison out. Eh? Why? 'Morality' aside, he is drowning the man, watching him struggle, and once he stops moving Danny rescues him?

Does Danny have something even worse in store for Garrison, "Death would be too merciful for you"?

“GET AWAY FROM MY DADDY!” she shouts, rigid with terror. At least three railguns are pointed at my head, their capacitors crackling with stored charge.
This was the plan? To take Garrison hostage and make Panzer stand down? Awfully risky. Kid sees Danny over her father's body and blasts him to pieces in a fit of grief and rage.

And wasn't she engaged in a fight with Kinetiq?

“Can you make one?” I ask.
She can make one?! Just like that?! What else can she make? Why didn't she construct an orbital cannon to shoot the entire Dread Squad down?

Panzer takes a step forward, murder on her face.

“Do it,” rasps Garrison.
Fixed it for Daniels.

She crawls to her father and curls up in his lap. Garrison whispers to her, says that it’s going to be okay.

For a moment, I don’t understand why I am stabbed with envy.
Yeah, yeah, your dad yelled at you entirely off page, we get it.
I know Daniels implies Danny is salty about Panzer/Garrison having a normal parent/child relationship, but imo it makes more sense he envies Panzer for being a girl born to a rich dad. That was Danny's whole problem, wasn't it? Not being a girl and having a poor guy for a father.
 
Last edited:
“They’re not very good booby traps. I think I can do this without getting my head blown off.”
How many times can they go to this well? Danny can Kool-Aid-Man his way into Myra's apartment (multiple times!) without turning into a frog, the amulets are not only reverse-engineerable but hackable, the satellites are unguarded, the books and mystical artifacts in the library have no wards of protection or curses on them, a novice magician's charm is enough to stop Danny from being assassinated, and now the one time there are actually booby traps, they're incompetent. By process of elimination, Graywytch is shaping up to be the final boss of this book, and yet she's depicted as absolutely worthless.

There he is again, with two men who look like they were cooks hiding in a walk-in cooler.
I picture them sort of like the Italian cooks from "Lady and the Tramp". Music, Luigi!

My thumb comes out of his eye with a blooming black cloud
His face is pale, his eyes half-lidded.
Eye, Danny. Singular, you rabid dog.

But I’m tougher than he imagined I was, and more deliberately cruel. They never see it coming. They never expect that someone who looks like me could have so much calm, considered malice at her disposal. By the time they figure it out, it tends to be too late.
I'm genuinely shocked that they went beyond "Rage is my strength" to "Cruelty is my strength". I really wonder if this isn't a case of the editor trying to patch-up a sort of redemption arc to overlay on the original draft, but throwing their hands up in disgust before finishing the job.
And how do we go from this to Danny panicking over the idea that he might have killed another man? Where was his shoulder angel when he was gouging Garrison's eye out?
Please. Wake up. Doc was right. Please, wake up.
Doc was right about what? Is this another vestigial remnant of the "Doc chews Danny out" scene that seems to have been lost in the wash?

and when I drop him onto the promenade he lands with a wet smack
Jackass.

EDIT: by the way, looking back through this thread, I noticed mention of an audiobook of Dreadnought Book 1.
There's a sample on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFgLHKGUEKI
Of all things, it's the "Danny searches his pants after getting his plot-inciting orbs installed" scene.
 
Last edited:
You can have your kung fu and your Krav Maga or whatever else you got, I don’t care. Utopia had an antireality cannon and look what happened to her.
So, we've gone from 'Holy shit, he knows kung fu!' at the end of the last chapter to 'Bah, what's the worst that can happen?' with no change in the situation?

The slap of fists to meat that comes off like gunshots.

I swear this author has used 'like gunshots' way too many times.

Kinetiq and Panzer streak past us, a flying lightshow of lasers and muzzle flash. Kinetiq gives Sovereign a burst of crimson energy right to his face as they pass, but Panzer’s got the same idea, and I catch a rocket with my gut.

I don't get how Kinetiq works, she flies by propelling herself with laser blasts, right? How the fuck is she flying and fighting Panzer (who I'm assuming has a jetpack or something) without plummeting?

In that photo, Thunderbolt was wearing a pressure suit, unlike the old Dreadnought. That’s because Dreadnought could hold his breath for hours on end. So can I. Thunderbolt couldn’t. And Sovereign is using Thunderbolt’s powers.

He says this like not being able to breathe for long is apart of the superpower.

Electricity floods out from him, as much as he can make, but in his panic he can’t focus it to make it behave unnaturally like he normally can. It flows over my suit’s insulation and heads to the sea floor, harmlessly.

Uh, no, not what happens. I don't care how fancy your suit is, if it couldn't stop his punches from getting the electrcity advantage, it ain't stopping the reality that your ass is getting fried when you use electricity underwater. This should be early Ash ketchum getting jumped by Pikachu. Hell, didn't Danny confirm that the suit isn't all encompassing? A lot of his head is exposed.

You’re down here with me, Sovereign. You’re down here until I decide to let you go. You don’t get to hurt anybody else.

I know he's a murderous super villain and I assume he probably has hurt and killed a lot of people off screen, but like... This line loses a lot of weight when the only person Garrison has hurt so far is Danny. Like, the actual take over part of his plan hasn't happened yet, has it? GreyWytch is the one fucking people up. Which just makes the fact that this spite and rage is fueled by Garrison DARING to be able to land a hit on Danny and hurt his pride all the more hilarious and pathetic.

I watch his heart slam in his chest. I watch his legs thrash and twist. Not much longer now. He’s still hurting me. His attacks still land. But I’m tougher than he imagined I was, and more deliberately cruel. They never see it coming. They never expect that someone who looks like me could have so much calm, considered malice at her disposal. By the time they figure it out, it tends to be too late.


The last handfuls of breath escape his chest. He spasms, seawater rushing into his lungs, plumping them out tight. He thrashes again, harder than ever, and then goes still. Cautiously, I loosen my legs. He stays limp in the water and begins to sink.


I am not undefeated.


I am undefeatable.

So, please explain to me how this self-assured description oozing with smugness and sadistic pleasure somehow leads right into 'Oh noes, he might die!'

Please. Wake up. Doc was right.

Superman refuses to kill because he believes in a better way and thinks that someone as powerful as him have to be held to a higher standard because of just how destructive their mistakes could be. Danny refuses to kill, when it's convient, because he's afraid it'll hurt his rep and he values validation just a little more than his power trips.

“Princess,” rasps Garrison. She stops dead, and looks down at him, her face stricken. “No. I can’t lose you. Not after everything else.”

My god, is that huamnity? In a villain in THIS story? It's scare scraps, but that is an achievement for this author.

Round two? Bitch, we're barely into round one!
Maybe that punch from Garrison gave Danny some brain damage.
Here's a thought, why aren't all of Garrison's troops armed with electric weapons?
Dude was too much of a cheap fuck to give them the super powers upgrade, you think he'll shell out the cash for specialized weapons? Preparing for a fight is for the poor, Kettle!

You know, when Batman does shit like that, at least when he's being written with some connection to reality, he does it by using stealth or disorientating his enemies. Think the predator mode stuff from the Arkham games. He doesn't usually just... run at a bunch of armed, armoured dudes with just the power of gymkata. If Daniels is going to write Calamity like a full-fledged superhuman, why not just... make her one?
Calamity is the closest thing to a likable character in this series, so much so that even the goons don't want to kill her off too soon.
Wait, so Doc had inbuilt energy-weapons, and she was relying on regular guns?
Damn, the old hero league must feel like fucking chumps. She used toxic gas and a pistol when taking them down, didn't even feel threatened enough to pull out the iron man pulse beams.
A reminder that the strategy they're talking about is beating the shit out of a child in order to shake her father.
They don't even end up doing the strategy at all, really. Like with the 'I'm totally luring Garrison into a trap, except that trap is never revealed or sprung and I just deck him in the face' in the last chapter, we have build up to the idea of executing a plan, build it up and then Danny just forgets the plan and does something else. Like, not that Danny decides not to go through with it, I mean that the story doesn't acknowledge the plan at all, it isn't mentioned after the end of the last chapter.
In a smart book, it would turn out Charlie--a teenage hobbyist--was unable to recognize the subtleties of Graywytch's spellwork, and he would then be painfully transformed into a literal bag of dicks.
The bitch put more effort into securing some old books than she did defending the shit that's crucial to her plan for world domination/retribution against the patriarchy.
I'm almost shocked Danny doesn't just write the cooks off like tankies do the Romanov servants.
Didn't they literally say going into this whole operation that they'd treat all of Garrison's staff as combatants?
 
They don't even end up doing the strategy at all, really. Like with the 'I'm totally luring Garrison into a trap, except that trap is never revealed or sprung and I just deck him in the face' in the last chapter, we have build up to the idea of executing a plan, build it up and then Danny just forgets the plan and does something else. Like, not that Danny decides not to go through with it, I mean that the story doesn't acknowledge the plan at all, it isn't mentioned after the end of the last chapter.

To be fair, it seems like this plan failed because Panzer kicked the shit out Kinetiq, which I find very funny. Maybe there's a reason she doesn't have a steady hero gig.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Aloof Pessimism
Jesus, that fight scene ending ending was bullshit.

You know what the worst kind of dramatic final showdown is to show the character of a hero? The match-up of a hero against an enemy who is Them, But Less So. It doesn't challenge the hero, or make them struggle, or even put them in an interestingly asymmetric situation. It just leads to another "And then Axe Cop cuts the criminal's heads off!" It's one of the reason why mid-to-late-phase Marvel villains were such shit, and it's why this fight ends with a sad clown honk. But what's even worse than that is when the villain is supposed to have powers and abilities that should force the hero to need to grow and struggle and instead they just...don't.

Garrison has electric powers! How to counter them? Dive into a giant conductive bath, that should route his electricity right into your uninsulated face! And then hold them there, despite the fact that they've got three black belts and breaking out of grapples is one of the few things I'd expect to cleanly port over from martial arts to murderous street-fighting! And then count on the familial bond between father and daughter, despite the fact that this father send his daughter out alone to get punted in the head and didn't support her for 20 fucking minutes afterwards, or even care remotely that you were the one who punted her! And despite being able to strike at vital areas and keeping his head in the fight, Garrison never tries to go for Dreadnought's cross, which is all that's stopping him from falling out of the sky like a big useless lump!

Then there's the fact that "I'm so much more brutal than you gave me credit for." is treated as a strength. Garrison never treated Dreadnought with kid gloves, except when the plot demanded he be stupid, and it's not like Dreadnought is actually saying "I bet you wish you'd sawed off my arms and legs and lobotomized me when you had the chance!" here, is he? This is purely the author reveling in his masturbatory fantasies of brutality and violence, and being rewarded for them, and are the perfect counterpoint to the question "Did Dreadnought learn anything, anything at all from spending time in a prison sell contemplating his hospitalization of GreyWytch?"

Man, now I'm wondering if the logical reading here is that Codex is actually some ancient sorcerous rival of GreyWytch who has been manipulating events with progressively less patience and subtlety as time has gone on, and is about to drop the magic on everyone's amulets but his own and take over the satellite network for himself.
 
You know, the whole "cold-cock Garrison while he rushes to save his daughter" plan might not have worked anyway, because Danny would be overcome with sympathy (jealousy).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aloof Pessimism
Man, now I'm wondering if the logical reading here is that Codex is actually some ancient sorcerous rival of GreyWytch who has been manipulating events with progressively less patience and subtlety as time has gone on, and is about to drop the magic on everyone's amulets but his own and take over the satellite network for himself.

That's a stupid plot point, but still one reserved for a better book than this.
 
Back