Dreadnought: The Quest for Cringe - White-Kettle-Shufflepunk reads a trans YA superhero novel

That Gerald scene is really something. Danny starts admiring him for being a hard, unbreakable man and then does a 180 after they break him with threats of torture and brainwashing. Only the most stereotypical manly men are worthy! Gerald should have just stared down those vigilante psychos like James Bond in the clutches of the villain!
But on the other hand, when Danny's not a John Wayne stereotype, it means he's a girl and no one should ever fault him for it.
 
It's also a hell of a vindication of Gerald's position. In this world, there are no civil liberties but what the strongest heroes choose to grant; there's no question as to whether confessions said while literally mind-controlled are valid, or that the Legion has the right to snatch up someone and use said mind-control as part of an interrogation. There is only power.

And I think that the OP is right on with the in adequacy complex. The author clearly feels that there are burdens placed upon men that he personally can't live up to, so not only can no one even attempt to live up to them in his fictional world, but he has the super-power of being exempted even having to make the attempt.

I'd really love to see the fortitude of Danny and Calamity tested in a similar situation. How does Calamity respond when a villain shrugs off her three best rounds and drops a sly hint about where she got them, and then drops the coy bit and says outright that if she wants her family's secrets to stay secret her next round needs to go into Danny's head? How does Danny respond if Graywytch gives him an ultimatum; pass on the mantle to a worthier successor and leave the city (and she'll even throw in some shape-stabilizing magic, fake IDs, and fuck-off money for him to start his new life elsewhere), or she'll do a ritual of Trueform-Sight and ensure that everyone sees Danny as the man he is going forward?

I doubt we'll see this, or even see either character put in actual serious physical danger. And the more we see them threaten others, the more jarring that lack feels.
 
By the way, on the topic of breaking men, I'm putting in my bet now that Danny will be sneering down at a broken, weeping Roger before the book ends. He can go to Crybaby Corner with Gerald and Bosco.
 
To be fair, in the MCU it's pretty much been confirmed Stan Lee is an agent of the Watchers, so probably.
Yeah, that would track. For anyone reading along not aware of what we're on about, Captain Marvel's Stan Lee Cameo is him reading the script to Mallrats, a movie in which he plays himself, and talks about Spider-Man and the like to drop an Aesop for the main character. A character who would not even be born yet in the fictional timeline and who Stan would not have 'created.' It's perhaps the most meta and strangest of all his cameos.

It occurs to me--and this is something that the smarter capeshit universes take into account--there have to be like, superpower equivelants Dr Sidhbh Gallagher out there: quacks and butchers who promise powers to desperate people. Might even be worse, because those guys can at least point to actual cases of normal people becoming superhuman. Of course, the fact that no doctor on Earth has ever succesfully changed a patient's sex doesn't stop some from claiming it anyway.
I can't think of any off the top of my head that sell fake superpowers to the masses. Plenty that sell real powers with horrible side effects to mundanes in the super side of business. I can also think of plenty shilling stuff like the mutant cure as well. I'm sure some exist, I just can't think of them off the top of my head.

I'm sure we're meant to think "if only he knew" here, but Gerald's right. A superhero literally fell from the sky and handed Danny the solutions to all his supposed problems, and the only reason he still has any is either because he's a massive wimp, like with his dad, or because his demands are incredibly unreasonable, like expecting a superhero team to chuck out their teammate for not thinking he's a girl.
Gerald feels like the author beginning to feel jealous of his own power/ sexual fantasy. I definitely agree it's about feeling like an inadequate man.

Like father like son, eh, Danny? Gerald admits he drove the truck on a few robberies. He's also an idiot who didn't turn his phone's GPS off, so Calamity--being an actual superhero with brains--is able to use that to figure out where they hit.
Danny's worse than Roger, though. Roger still cares about Danny. Danny no longer has any sympathy for Gerald, what little was there in the first place.

The Power Pack were edgier than Danny, and they were like, eight-to-twelve years old.
Their arc during inferno was brutal. Also their mom and dad are fictionalized versions of two long time Marvel employees, Walt and Louise Simonson. That's totally irrelevant, but it's also very charming.

I mean, technically David was fucking stoked you were transgender. It's kind of hard for Danny to be a stand-in for "trans kids" when his situation is nothing like theirs. No fifteen year old boy who decides they're a girl suddenly has to deal with their heterosexual mates wanting to bone them.
Yeah, David immediately accepted Danny as a girl. David's just a one dimensional degenerate.
Also, unless you skipped over it, the mom says nothing about Roger having banned Danny from the house or even having said anything to her about the previous blow-up, so yes, Roger still considered Danny his child and cares for him, showing Roger > Danny.

I kind of imagine every mother who has only sons ponders that at some point. Most of them treat it as an amusing or slightly wistful thought-experiment.
My mother coped by all but adopting her friends' daughters when I was growing up. She is now super stoked to have a granddaughter.

I think Blanchard talked about TIMs retconning their childhoods to include dysphoria.
I think body dysmorphia is common among basically everybody during puberty, but the dysphoria during childhood definitely sounds made up. Kids have a very bad concept of the physical self and differences from their bodies to other bodies.

Cooties is actually a pretty culturally limited phenomenon from what I've read. You tend to see it in anglophone cultures and not say, France.
Even then it's not universal. Cooties is absolutely a social phenomenon, not a biological one.

Convinent. Personally, I'd speculate it has something to do with your best friend being a total fucking creep and you apparently never noticing or say anything.
Hypothesis: Danny is also a creep, but much less obvious about it.

I think at this point Danny is just angry his mother wasn't a literal mind-reader, which might be a slightly more reasonable expectation in his world, but only so much.
Yeah, this was where I started thinking Danny was a shit. Remember, in his worldview whether it's true or not, his mother is a victim of abuse. And he's mad she didn't pick up on his completely unvoiced desires and act on them.

Isn't this called gaslighting?
It depends on a few factors, such as whether or not you think one needs to know they are lying to gaslight and whether or not Danny is knowingly lying or delusional as well. The other major factor is whether or not it becomes a pattern, so "We can't be sure just yet, but probably"

Now, the compassionate thing for Danny to do here would be to reveal his superpowers to his mother, reassuring her that it's essentially impossible for anyone to hurt him for being trans. Or to remind her they live in East Coast America, and he's not a Brazilian prositute, but either works.
West Coast, I thought. And yes, letting the mother worried for her child's safety "I am basically invincible because of whatever happened to me" would be a good thing. You don't have to say "I'm a super hero!" you can just say "What happened to me also made me ultra-durable, so don't worry" It's not like that's less believable than switching sex after a super hero fight.

Not something you get to ask while literally lying to your mother. And they can't take your word for it because you never told them.
I suspect this is a common thing with Danny, and why he is such a shit.

I will never get over someone who was a teenage boy less than a month ago telling off his mother for not noticing he was always a girl.
"How dare you not notice what I was going to great pains to hide!"
Like a said, a shit. Not even an amusing shit. Just a stain.
 
Sarah calls in sick on Tuesday and doesn’t show up to school. Over the next few hours, several industrial sites in the Pacific Northwest get phone calls from a “reporter” asking about what they lost during their recent burglaries. She dragoons me into the effort as well, sending me a list of phone numbers to call over lunch. I don’t get much to eat, but I send what I find back to her.

The virgin Dreadnought-4: Can only investigate the murder of his predesecor for forty minutes around noon because he shouldn't take the algebra mid-term on an empty stomach.

The chad Calamity: Realises high-school is bullshit, blows it off to be a fucking superhero all the live-long day.

As the day dims toward night, our inventory of stolen goods begins to firm up. Exotic coolants and ceramic heat sinks. Optically flat mirrors and several very expensive motion picture camera lenses. A thousand gallons of low-viscosity hydraulic fluid.

Utopia's either going to build a mega-death-mecha, or a sick gaming rig. Oh, wait, she's going to solve all the Suduko puzzles and render bitcoin useless! The girls pay a capacitor plant Utopia hit a visit:

Back on her feet, she pulls something out of her jacket that looks like a tiny toy gun with a pair of thick wires poking out the front. She jams them into the lock, squeezes the trigger a few times, and we’re in.

“Lock picking with actual lock picks is for eccentrics, hobbyists, and morons,” she says.

“You’re not an eccentric?”

“Hush.”

I feel like there's probably some locks where an actual pick would be the best option, but I know very little about that.

“Wackachicka wackachicka wackachicka wackachicka…”

Calamity pops her head out of the storage room. “What in the hell are you doin’?”

I pause like a deer in headlights between a wacka and a chicka. “A cheesy ’70s investigation montage?”

“Damnit, D—girl!” She stalks down the short hallway and slips into the office. “Caping is a might bit more serious than that.”

“Oh come on, you talk all old timey and you call yourself Calamity.”

I'm torn about this bit. On the other hand, Danny actually enjoying himself doing something besides trying on girl clothes is nice, but I dislike MCU style "Isn't being a superhero wacky" bits.

“That is a persona!” says Sarah. She snatches her hat off and throws it to the floor. “It is a vital element of the form, one that you have ignored for too long. I don’t even know what to call you when we’re out like this!”

I shrug as I take the copy out of the machine and fold it up. “‘Hey you’ is working fine so far.”

Sarah is one of the few characters who acts like a native inhabitant of her own universe.

That’s a very good question. At first, I sort of assumed I would be. But then. Well. But then. But then my parents found out I was a girl. But then I met the Legion. But then David torched our friendship. Running around hunting Utopia is fun and all, and yeah, I promised I’d find a way to honor Dreadnought, and taking down the supervillain that killed him is a good way to do that, but Calamity has a point. I’ve been able to choose permanent colors—not even Dreadnought’s colors, just anything—for more than a week now. And I haven’t. And maybe I never will. So I don’t say anything because I don’t have any answers, and after a moment it gets weird.

I could swear I've read this exact paragraph five times doing this review.

“Hey, look, I didn’t mean anything by that,” says Sarah. It’s a little weird talking to Sarah when she’s got the Calamity outfit on but she’s not doing the voice.

“It’s okay.” Like a bubble rising from the depths, the question forms and is out of my lips before I really think about it. “Is it selfish that I kinda just want to be Danielle right now?”

Yes! You've been "Danielle" for most of the book!

“No. I don’t think so.” Sarah bends down, picks her hat up, and fiddles with the brim. “I think we’ve already gotten everything we’re going to get from here. In fact, I was just being thorough. We probably have enough for my contact to go on already. Do you, um…do you wanna go buy makeup?”

Canny Calamity knows how to keep the AGP demigod wrapped around her gun-barrel.

“I don’t have any money.”

With that bandanna over the lower part of her face, Sarah’s eyebrows become much more expressive. “My bike cost seventy thousand dollars, and my guns are eleven hundred each. You think I can’t afford a tube of lipstick?”

“Where the hell do you get that kind of money?”

Sarah shrugs. “I rob drug dealers.”

“Oh.”

Most drug dealers apparently make sub-minimum wage, so Calamity must be busy.

“What kind of makeup do you like?” asks Sarah.

“I have no idea. I used to just grab the first nail polish that looked pretty and get out.”

“Okay, so let’s get you some foundation and mascara to start. Maybe some lip gloss, too.”

“Not lipstick?”

Sarah shakes her head. “Maybe. Lipstick is a little heavy. Unless you’re going to a formal event, or there’s a particular look you’re going for, it will seem out of place.”

"Also, bitch, wash your damn hair."

I realize I’ve never seen Sarah actually wear makeup, and yet she speaks as an authority on the subject. When I say as much she shrugs. “I am the only daughter in a family of boys, and
if you think my mother didn’t force me to learn about this stuff, then you are out of your goddamn mind.”

A little stab of envy goes through me. That one day shopping with Mom seems cheap and flimsy in comparison.

At least Sarah's not talking about her first period or something.

Picking the correct foundation turns out to be a lot more involved than I thought it would be. There’s a special lamp that’s supposed to give the right kind of light for color matching, and I’ve got to hold different shades up against the inside of my arm to see which ones match my skin tone the best. Of course before I can do that I’ve got to decide between liquid and powder foundation, and really I have no idea which is better. When I reach for a tube of black mascara, Sarah shakes her head, and points me towards some dark brown mascara instead. Because I’m blond, actual black mascara would stand out strongly against my coloration, which is useful for achieving certain looks but not something I want to tie myself to, at least not until I know what I’m doing.

I have never felt more "cis" in my whole life. Also, Danny's blond? Huh. I always pictured him darker-haired. Someone shop tranny-Homelander for my personal collection.

It’s like this all the way down to the smallest detail. There’s nothing simple about makeup, and she assures me that I’ll want to practice putting it on a few times in private before I leave the house with any of it on, because apparently it takes considerable skill to put the stuff on and make it look nice.

You know, I'm a dude with only the one sister, and I'm pretty conventional in my presentation or whatever you want to call it. Do most ladies actually get sat down by their mums or sisters and taught this stuff explicitly? I always got the impression most mothers allow their daughters to learn through trial and error, with the occasional comment about how they look like clown-hookers.

Then she says I might not even need it, and I nod and say its one of my superpowers to be impossibly beautiful, but it still looks like fun to get made up. Sarah sputters for a little while.

Every day, Sarah wishes she could be the Falcon to Cybersix's Captain America and not Danny's. Enough of this bullshit, someone press "T" to wait.


We’re good at leaving my back yard without any noise now, and we wait until we’re most of the way down the alley before we say anything else. I notice for the first time that somehow all the streetlamps in this alley are out. When I examine them in the lattice, I see they have been shattered. Almost as if someone with a silenced pistol came through here and shot them all.

That very night, the Tozers discovered a baby boy left for them by American Dumbledore.

“So tonight’s the night?”

“Tonight is a night. Gonna come calling on a business partner of mine, fella going by the name of the Artificer. He’s a grayish sort of hypertech merchant. We tell him what we know about the robberies and the time frame, then maybe he can tell us what she’s planning. Probably won’t be too exciting. I was thinking we’d do a little patrolling after we talk to him.”

Still knocking it out of the park with the names, Daniels. Also, is it wrong I kind of want to go on patrol with Calamity? Sounds like a hoot and a half if you get into the spirit of things. You know, beating up criminals, having a somewhat loose interpretation of the rule of law, thinking thoughts other than trans nonsense.

Calamity kills the engine and pulls her helmet off. Her motorcycle ticks and clicks in the cold night air. “This here is it. I called ahead so we shouldn’t get shot at, but just in case we are, try not to get hit. He’s got things that could even put a dent in you.”

So, a boombox playing recordings of Danny's dad?

Calamity draws a pistol and begins swapping out jelly rounds for hollow-points. “He’s a mite bit eccentric, but he only tried to kill me the one time. We’re square. Square-ish. It’ll be fine.”

“That’s why you’re loading lethal rounds, because this is fine?”

“Only in one gun. Nice to have options.” She snaps the cylinder closed. “Let’s go.”

I bet that was a more interesting adventure than anything in this book.

We walk towards the shuttered factory. There are no lights on in this area, no sodium orange to keep the night away, and so the Artificer’s factory seems like a hulking black void in the silver moonlight. When we’re within thirty yards, I start to hear a low buzzing noise. My hair begins to prickle and float. A white spotlight clacks on and pins us to the ground.

Okay, so, when I was writing my capeshit novel (avalible now at no major bookstores or digital vendors!) my editor cautioned me about figurative language, because in a book where characters can do whatever, it's easy to confuse metaphor for something literally happening. That being said, is the spotlight actually immobilising the kids? Introductions are made, and we get to see inside the Artisan's lair:

Holo-projectors and flat screens throw pale glows on the cement floors, and bright white banks of LEDs hug the ceiling. Huge dynamos and racks upon racks of computer servers dominate the walls to either side. Deeper into the Artificer’s lair—and this place is so obviously meant to be thought of as a lair—I can see individual experiments in progress. A half-refurbished matter fabber sits in a corner, its guts splayed out on the ground. Its functioning sister is humming quietly, steam leaking from its sealed production cubby.

Oh, look at Dani--been in two mad science lairs and she's already jaded. Also, is a "matter-fabber" something a layman would be likely to recognise on sight?

Calamity, you had better be prepared to pay your bill,” he says as we come down the steps. “I refuse to be strung along any further, young lady. No more ammunition until you settle your debts.”

“Don’t let your horses lead you, Art. Here’s your money.” She reaches into her jacket and pulls out a fat brick of twenty-dollar bills. She holds it up and he snaps it out of her hand, rubs his thumb down the edge to make sure they’re all the same denomination.

“I’ll count this later,” he says.

“Your trusting nature in these cynical times is a balm to my wounded soul.”

You had God knows how much money lying around in case you ran into a wish fufilment character, and you were stringing along your ammo guy? Doesn't seem wise, Calamity.

The Artificer is obviously American, but he affects a slight accent. Maybe he thinks it makes him sound sophisticated.

What kind of accent? French? British? Australian? You sure he just isn't from another part of America, Danny?

He’s got eyes set deep in the hollows of his skull, and a fringe of thick black hair pulled back high from a severe widow’s peak. He’s wearing, and I swear to God that this is true and I’m not making it up, he’s wearing a double-breasted white lab coat and thick purple gloves.

No, really.

That’s what he’s wearing.

It's almost as though he's a fucking supervillain or something and that's the sort of weird shit they do in your world.

He notices me staring. “What’s the Legion’s pet doing in my humble shop, hm?”

“Uh—” Now how the hell did he know I’m with the Legion? I look at Calamity. She shrugs.

“Please, don’t delude yourself,” he says. “Only the Legion’s kiddie club wears throwaways.”

“Oh.” I’m starting to get the feeling the Legion are the only people in town who don’t realize that.

How'd they get the fucking idea in the first place? Do they think supervillains work like bulls? The Artisan's willing to try and figure out what Utopia is building, but in exchange he wants some non-Newtonian fluid. Don't worry, Calamity knows where they can get some. Namely, the local university:

“So then how—wait, we’re not going to steal this, are we?”

She looks at me like I’ve said something strange. “Of course. What do you think being a graycape means? We ain’t gonna let the law stand in the way of doing what’s right.”

“Stealing isn’t right!”

Remember kids, trans is punk. Although, Danny does have a point: engineering is one of the few things DEI initiatives haven't ruined yet.

“Look, if this stuff is that common to hypertech, I’m sure I can get some from Doc Impossible. Just hang on for—”

“NO!” Calamity’s shout echoes against the factory wall. “We are not going to the Legion for help!”

She’s so forceful I take a half step back and pause to collect my wits. When I find them, a slow burn of anger comes with them. “Why the hell not? I’ve been letting you call the shots so far, but this is stupid!”

Calamity swings her leg over the saddle of her bike. “The Legion’s not just gonna hand the stuff over.”

“How do we know? We haven’t even asked them!”

Is it me, or does Danny forget she hates the Legion a bunch.

“They ain’t trustworthy! It don’t matter what they do and don’t give us, there’ll be some hook behind the bait and we’ll end up frying!” She slams the helmet down on her head. “We’re doing it my way.”

So, we know why Danny (sometimes) hates the Legion: they won't fire a longtime member and friend for not lying about Danny's sex. What about Calamity?

“They arrested my dad.” Sarah’s voice is thick and choked. “The government framed him for murder, and the Legion just want along with it. He’s doing twenty to life in a federal pen.”

“That doesn’t make sense.” It feels like I understand all the words she’s using, just not the order in which she said them. Maybe I misheard her. “Why would the government want to frame him?”

You know, when woke types ask "why weren't we taught this in school" they usually just weren't listening.

“My dad was a cape, called Ricochet. He worked just above street level,” says Sarah. “He found proof the CIA was smuggling drugs for the Colombian cartels and pocketing the cash to fund their black operations.

And then they sold Soldier Boy to the Russians? Side-note, I love The Boys, but they should really have A-Train be replaced by an even worse speedster who uses they/them pronouns to get people shouted down on Twitter for talking about his crime-sprees.


He tried to go to Congress about it. The Legion arrested him a week later.”

“No, that…they must have been tricked.”

“They invited him to their tower and then ambushed him in an elevator.”

“They wouldn’t do that—”

"It'd be cramped, for starters!"


They did!” she shouts. “I only see my dad from the other side of a glass wall now! He missed my brother’s funeral, Danny!”

You know, maybe this is shitty of me to say, but if I carried a genetic curse that had a 50% chance of giving my kid blood cancer, I'd adopt or something.

“This is…I don’t know, Sarah this is not what I thought we were doing—”

“Then let go of my bike and get out of the way,” she growls.

I open my mouth to say—to say what? I don’t know. Something. Something I hope will make this okay again, and put us back where we used to be. Where it feels like we’re supposed to be.

In a sane world Calamity would be the main protagonist and Danny would be a tragic but dumb villain.

A flash, blue on white, and sharp black shadows racing to the horizon.

The pressure wave rips us from our feet and slams us across the gravel. I go end over end in a shower of rocks. Calamity’s bike spins and crunches into the ground inches from her skull. I reach out for her, find her hand in the dark. She squeezes back.

The night is broken by a pyre rising from the shattered factory. The mushroom blooms red and black over dancing flames.

A second flash. A piercing cobalt beam lances down from the sky and into the flames. New explosions blossom and thunder.

See, God Himself agrees with me!

The wind shifts and the smoke clears for a moment. A small figure floats down from the sky, wreathed in blue and silver.

Utopia.

Or Utopia, either works.
 
You know, I'm a dude with only the one sister, and I'm pretty conventional in my presentation or whatever you want to call it. Do most ladies actually get sat down by their mums or sisters and taught this stuff explicitly? I always got the impression most mothers allow their daughters to learn through trial and error, with the occasional comment about how they look like clown-hookers.

Short answer: it depends on the mother. My mom gave my sister the basics, but she didn't wear a lot in the first place. My more well-to-do aunt had to sit my sister down for the full Makeup 101, so to speak.
 
Man, I've got a lot more questions about Calamity's family now. Like, why did her dad not bring that evidence to the Legion? And if her dad had that good working relationship with the Legion, why didn't they take a moment to have Discount Poison Ivy spore him up and get confirmation? Hell, doesn't Valkyrie-Lass have a magic auto-lie-detection sense?

I know that the actual answer is that the author didn't think about it and that we are also not supposed to think about it beyond uwu black male conviction bad, but in a better book, this would be a great point for Danny to reflect on the individual members of the Legion he's met and contrast their shown actions to what he's told. We've seen no evidence that the Legion swoops in and picks on the street-level capes of any color (aheh), and so for them to do this, then every Legion member would have to go along with getting an order from a government handler and going along with it without question.

One of the things that makes capeshit so shitty is the casualness with setting elements get introduced to solve a momentary plot problem and then dropped without considering how those elements should affect everything in the future. In a well-written story, Calamity's version of events is extremely at odds with everything we've seen of the Legion so far, so either they're carefully lying to Danny, or Calamity is, or (most likely) Calamity is being lied to by her dad about exactly what happened, and whatever actually did happen was enough for the Legion to investigate, go "Cool motive, still murder." and wash their hands of him.

On the plus side, I am looking forward to seeing Utopia strut her stuff. Let's get some action with the one person shown to be able to put the protagonist in peril!
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Man, I've got a lot more questions about Calamity's family now. Like, why did her dad not bring that evidence to the Legion? And if her dad had that good working relationship with the Legion, why didn't they take a moment to have Discount Poison Ivy spore him up and get confirmation? Hell, doesn't Valkyrie-Lass have a magic auto-lie-detection sense?

We do actually get an explanation later. It doesn't reflect well on anyone involved.
 
When we last left our hero (Calamity) she and her dumb tag-along were watching Utopia--D3's killer-descend upon Calamity's tech-guy's lair.

Calamity gets to her knees and pulls her helmet off. It’s carpeted with gouges. The eye shield was up, so she’s got some cuts over her eyes and across the bridge of her nose. Calamity gingerly touches her face, blinks. “We ain’t running,” she says. Her voice is hard and steady.


“Are you insane?” I hiss. Glancing over, I can’t see Utopia anymore. She’s dropped down into the fire, probably to finish off the Artificer. “We’ve got to get out of here!”


Calamity is already on her feet, seeing what she can salvage from the twisted ruin of her motorcycle. “Why? Utopia didn’t show up here by accident; Gerald must have warned her we paid him a visit, then she got the same notion we did. Since she’s gone to all the trouble of keeping us from needing to track her down, it seems a mite bit inconsiderate to let that pass without so much as a how-do-ya-do.”

Gee, it's almost as though maybe you should've told the fucking Legion instead of just letting the supervillain minion report to his boss. From a writing perspective, I can forgive Calamity not doing that because she has old beef with them, but Danny's motivations are still a knot of contrivances.

“We are not ready for this kind of fight.” I step over to grab her, and in a single fluid move she has somehow locked my wrist against my elbow and thrown me clear over her shoulder. I land and slide for a yard or two.

“You get along home if you want to, but that woman just killed our last lead.” Calamity begins unloading her pistols and stowing the ammo in her pockets. “Without the Artificer we’ve got no prayer of heading off what she’s got planned. So if you want to avenge the guy who gave you that mantle, now is your one and only chance. But if you wanna quit the moment it gets hard, then I’ll not cry to see the back of you.”

So, just to illustrate a point, this, in isolation, isn't bad writing. Calamity wanting to throw-down with Utopia even though it's obviously suicide. She's a teenager, she just had an emotional argument with her best friend that dredged up bad memories, and she clearly has a certain bloodlust. Given she constantly lives with the possibility of her leakuemia returning, she might not well have a certain disregard for her long term safety. The problem with Danny meanwhile, is that he's constantly making mistakes and being a shithead, but most of the time, the author clearly doesn't think he is. Like, the thing with his mother. I can totally buy a teenager being self-centered, they get mad at their mum because she didn't read their mind. But Daniels clearly wants us to think Mrs Tozer was either too stupid or too cowardly to recognise the self-evident fact her son was actually a girl. Because he liked to draw and didn't manspread at the age of nine or something. Daniels' idea of giving his self-insert flaws is making him too noble and humble to realise he's actually a "good person."

I get to my feet. “We don’t even know if we can hurt her!”

She holds up a bullet with a very pointy tip. “Tungsten penetrators. These will kill anything.”

Is this gonna be like The Boys, which treated depleted uranium rounds as literal kryptonite for invulnerable superhumans?

A huge gout of sparks and embers leaps into the sky as something inside the fire collapses. Somewhere in there, Utopia is erasing her trail, or maybe stealing what she can use. This is an amazingly bad idea.


“We should call for backup,” I say, but I know there’s no point. By the time they get here, she’ll be long gone.


“Ain’t no cavalry coming.” Calamity finishes loading her weapons and snaps the cylinders shut. “We do this now, or we don’t do it.”

Actually, where the fuck are the Legion? A supervillain just exploded a factory. People probably heard it for miles around. You'd think this would be something they'd investigate. Christ, maybe Calamity is right about them.

Calamity’s plan is simple: split up but stay close enough to support each other. Whoever finds Utopia first starts fighting as hard as she can, and then the other comes and attacks from Utopia’s blind spot. In the close quarters down there, it seems unlikely she’ll use her anti-reality beam against us.

A reminder that this chick killed a guy with all of Danny's powers and decades more experience, and Calamity's powers are gymnastics and guns.

Calamity is in close, blasting away at point blank range. Utopia is dodging back, taking a round in her shoulder instead of her throat. Her left arm folds open into a submachine gun and burps fire at where Calamity had just been standing. Calamity has rolled behind her, jams the muzzle of her gun into Utopia’s back and fires. Utopia jerks with the impact, swivels one eighty degrees around the waist to face her—

"Burps" always a word that maintains tension.

“Wait!” she says. My fist jerks to a stop inches from her face. Her voice is trilling, musical, shaped by electronic undertones. Up close I can see her hair is synthetic fiber, and her face silicone pseudoflesh, pale and sparkling. “You must understand what is at stake.”

“You murdered Dreadnought.”

“I kill only when compelled to. He would not see reason.”

“What reason justifies murder?” I shout.

“The Nemesis is coming, and sooner than we think.”

“Who is the Nemesis?”

If you're exceptionally old, Helen of Troy's mum.

“Not who, what.” Utopia blinks, a strangely unsettling action. Her eyes have no whites, only a pair of glowing blue irises. “You wouldn’t believe me if I told you—”

“Do you have any idea what kind of month I’ve had?”

Utopia smiles. “I take your point. The Nemesis is the name I have given to a mass of exotic matter that is currently traversing the solar system. Should it arrive before I am ready, the consequences will be severe. For everyone.” She sounds honest and calm.

This is a world with magic and a "Kaiju Crisis" and Utopia thought that was too outlandish to be believed?

“I saw you hiding down there with Dreadnought,” she says quietly, barely louder than the snapping flames. “After killing two of your predecessors, I knew the mantle would pass on. It always does. I chose to let you have it, and to let you live.

You might have noticed that Utopia just spoiled one of this book's dumbass twists. Don't worry, Danny doesn't.

A cold, draining horror sucks at me. A supervillain knows who I am. Knows, probably, where I live. Could kill my family whenever she wants.

Yeah, I'm sure Danny would be absolutely shattered by that.

“For what it’s worth,” says Utopia, “I applaud your discretion in regards to refraining from announcing yourself as the Dreadnought. It demonstrates forethought and clarity of mind.”

Even the fucking villain is trying to big up Danny!

Calamity’s answer is immediate: “Let’s kill her.”

“No! We’re not killing anybody!”

“We can hardly let her go or drop her off with the cops if she knows your name. Ain’t got no real good options here, do we?”

“I—I don’t know.”

“There’s another factor to consider,” says Utopia as she reaches a sitting position. I stop pacing. “It takes some time to recharge my inversion beam, but it does recharge.”

Her chest cavity pops open, and the searing cobalt beam leaps out at me.

I jump clear in time.

Calamity doesn’t.

Figures.
 
So, Artificer calls Utopia saying "Hey, heroes are after you.", and a little later, Utopia shows up and blows shit up? If Utopia wanted to see if new Dreadnought was reasonable, why didn't she meet him early and chat? Why only talk at this point?

I'm glad to see some actual action and an interested in seeing what happens with Calamity, but I'm having a very hard time modeling "Character A wants B, has abilities 1,2,3, knows important details 4,5,6, and so this is why they did that."

I feel like we could have gotten a line from Utopia about Danny adapting to the mantle much faster than expected to explain why she considered him a non-factor up until now. Or maybe the entire bit about the strangelet cloud was purely a distraction to let her recharge.

Also, is Utopia new? If she's been around long enough to have sunk Dreadnought 2.0, that must make her decades old, right? Shouldn't she have a fairly different aesthetic if she was designed then? Has no one heard of her until now?

I hope that there are answers to some of these questions coming, but so far, Utopia's motivations don't seem mysterious, they seem arbitrary. If Utopia's not a meat-person, could the heroes even have killed her? She might be an easily-reproducible drone being remote-piloted, or an AI with backups everywhere, or any number of other things.

And the frustrating thing is that as you point out, making Calamity going in hard and aggressive a consequence of who she is would take the barest steps to set up and integrate. The book comes frustratingly close to competence at points; I feel like the author might be just auto-piloting the non-trans scenes to get through them, and in so, end up not making them worse by injecting his own bullshit into them overmuch, so they just end up sloppy copies of better writing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Resuming a lost post from before the outage:

At least Sarah's not talking about her first period or something.
That would complete the Jake Alley checklist of "just girly things" he missed out on. I mean, we've already hit everything else.

Anyway, let's take a little break from Danny, King Of The Jackasses for a little sidebar on the actual writing.

Holo-projectors and flat screens throw pale glows on the cement floors, and bright white banks of LEDs hug the ceiling. Huge dynamos and racks upon racks of computer servers dominate the walls to either side. Deeper into the Artificer’s lair—and this place is so obviously meant to be thought of as a lair—I can see individual experiments in progress. A half-refurbished matter fabber sits in a corner, its guts splayed out on the ground. Its functioning sister is humming quietly, steam leaking from its sealed production cubby.
Everything about the phrasing and imagery here is stupid. "Throw a glow" is nonsense, and "hugging the ceiling" is over-egging the pudding considering how common flush-mounted LED light fixtures are.
"I can see individual experiments" - like what?
"its guts splayed out on the ground" - like what? What's inside a matter fabber? If it's interesting enough to mention, it's interesting enough to describe.

I mean really, just make something up. "The floor is covered with a tangled mess of glowing fiber-optic cables and hypertech nodules spilling out of a half-disassembled matter fabber the size of my refrigerator. The housing around the miniature black hole powering the unit has been cut away, and a robotic arm is prodding the containment field with some sort of magnetic probe, making it bulge dangerously. Beyond that, the rest of the hallway is sealed off with a steel grating; a sign reads 'Project Ultimate Waifu: KEEP OUT'. I can see row upon row of cloning tanks back there but can't make out what's in them."

Anyway, now that we have this new update, I can see obviously the author didn't want to bother describing a factory that was just going to get blown up like 10 pages later. Don't get too attached, am I right?

Her chest cavity pops open, and the searing cobalt beam leaps out at me.
I jump clear in time.
Calamity doesn’t.

I choose to read this as Calamity standing directly behind Danny and getting fried because he dodged :lol:
 
  • Like
Reactions: spiritofamermaid
Also, is Utopia new? If she's been around long enough to have sunk Dreadnought 2.0, that must make her decades old, right? Shouldn't she have a fairly different aesthetic if she was designed then? Has no one heard of her until now?

Yeah, she's Mistress Malice--the OG supervillain who killed D1--under a new identity. I'll get into all the reasons this is stupid and pointless later.
 
Yeah, she's Mistress Malice--the OG supervillain who killed D1--under a new identity. I'll get into all the reasons this is stupid and pointless later.
So the same person killed all the Dreadnoughts and the Legion hasn't picked up on this? :lol: Guess they were too busy playing Hogwarts Legacy and reading the YWNBAW copypasta after inhaling helium to keep tabs on the one person in the world who can kill Superman-knockoffs.
 
Yeah, she's Mistress Malice--the OG supervillain who killed D1--under a new identity. I'll get into all the reasons this is stupid and pointless later.
Good god, that's roughly the equivalent of Doomsday killing Supes, then changing his identity to totally-not-Doomsday and that trick throwing the entire Justice League (which includes goddamn Batman) off his trail.
 
Gee, it's almost as though maybe you should've told the fucking Legion instead of just letting the supervillain minion report to his boss. From a writing perspective, I can forgive Calamity not doing that because she has old beef with them, but Danny's motivations are still a knot of contrivances.
You don't understand. One of their members wasn't immediately utterly accepting and approving of Danny and the rest of them refused to shun her utterly!
Seriously though, it really does just seem to be that one reason.

Actually, where the fuck are the Legion? A supervillain just exploded a factory. People probably heard it for miles around. You'd think this would be something they'd investigate. Christ, maybe Calamity is right about them.
A more competent writer would have had the legion off dealing with some crisis elsewhere at the time. Also why is Utopia attacking this place, exactly? Didn't

"Burps" always a word that maintains tension.
Note only that, it's double wrong. A machinegun would not "burp fire." It would perhaps "spew" or "spray" but only bullets. Even if flamethrower, which does shoot fire, would not be described as "burping" or even "belching" it. A "Belch of Fire" is a recognized phrase, but it means a short, intense burst of flame, almost always short in range.

This is a world with magic and a "Kaiju Crisis" and Utopia thought that was too outlandish to be believed?
It might help if she didn't give it a dumb nickname. "You have to stop the Antagonist!" "The what?" "A giant meteor about to hit us!"

You might have noticed that Utopia just spoiled one of this book's dumbass twists. Don't worry, Danny doesn't.
So, who or what killed the one she didn't gank?

Yeah, I'm sure Danny would be absolutely shattered by that.
Of course he would. He'd have to change his pity party entirely and he's been working the "My family doesn't understand!" angle his entire life.

Of course. Can't have a more likable character sticking around making Danny look bad.
 
So the same person killed all the Dreadnoughts and the Legion hasn't picked up on this? :lol: Guess they were too busy playing Hogwarts Legacy and reading the YWNBAW copypasta after inhaling helium to keep tabs on the one person in the world who can kill Superman-knockoffs.

Two of them, D2 seems to have been killed in unrelated circumstances. Not that that's much better.

It might help if she didn't give it a dumb nickname. "You have to stop the Antagonist!" "The what?" "A giant meteor about to hit us!"

Yeah, "Nemesis" kind of implies like, a monster or a sapient creature, not a dangerous rock.

So, who or what killed the one she didn't gank?

Apparently he died during the afforementioned Kaiju Crisis, so I'm guessing Godzilla.
 
The blast flings me into some fallen machinery. The beam’s fuzzy green after-image swims in my eyes and blots out the world. I shut them and try to see through the lattice instead. Utopia’s weapon, the inversion beam she called it, has shredded reality in here. Torn, dangling ends of the lattice seem to writhe in pain. Nausea bubbles in my stomach. With a conviction I can’t account for, I know that nothing will ever really work quite right in this place again. Machinery will fail, animals will cower, and people will feel unaccountably disturbed.


Utopia has found her feet, her nimbus of blue and silver beginning to flicker back to life. She turns towards me. There is an infinitely small and infinitely bright point of light hanging inside the open cavity of her chest, like a fleck of a blue star ripped from the cosmos and hung between her ribs. She still has some of her organs in there, run through with plastic tubing and synthetic replacements for her lost biology.

Better than using her colon at least.

“The key component of this weapon was material salvaged from the asteroid the Legion Pacifica stopped last year,” she says. “That asteroid was part of the Nemesis once, flung ahead of its master by the tides of gravity. This is what a single kilogram of that thing can do to the world, Danielle. Imagine what thirty million tons of it could unleash if it even passed by our moon.”


I push a fallen industrial lathe off of me and clamber to my feet. “Then come with me and tell the world what you know so we can defend ourselves.”


“My long experience with the governments of humanity has left me with no confidence in them. I dislike killing children, Danielle.” Utopia points to something behind me. “Attend to your friend, or she will die.”

If you're wondering if we ever find out what Utopia's deal is--how she found out about Nemesis, why the governments of the world didn't listen to her, why she's a cyborg--remember, we don't even know what D3's first name was.

“What?” The fear in my chest explodes into ice. I look around frantically. Calamity lies on her back, hat knocked away. Her breath is coming in short, hard gasps. The left side of her body is a ruin. Her charred skin weeps at the cracks. Her arm…oh God…her arm. It’s nothing but ash and gore, more bone than flesh. The melted remains of her pistol have fused with what was her hand.

Okay, if Utopia's gun deletes or unravels reality, shouldn't Calamity's side be less charred and burnt and more... absent. She should be an r-rated version of one of Spindly Klutz's victims:

1684133629248.png



A stupid, feeble protest bursts from my lips. “No!”


It’s not fair. That’s what gets to me. It’s not fair. This isn’t right. She was the one who knew what she was doing.
She ran into a burning factory to fight a supervillain who killed Dani's seasoned veteran predecessor and could unravel the fabric of existence. With her handguns.
She was the one who had training and experience. She was the one who was really a hero, who didn’t flinch to go into danger. This doesn’t make sense. It’s not supposed to go this way. Calamity is too smart to lose, too brave to die.

Brave people are immune to death. Bit of an ontological paradox. In fact, the leading of cause of death on the battlefield is people shouting this fact at their enemies, causing them to no longer have anything to fear, and thus be incapable of bravery.

I am a child. In one hideous epiphany I realize that powers or not, I’m just an idiot little girl who is in way over her head.

Trust Danny to fumble the epiphany at the end-zone. Utopia tells Danny not to bug her again or he dies, leaving him to tend to Calamity's confusing set of injuries.

“Take me home,” she mumbles against my chest.

“I’m taking you to a hospital.”

“No hospital. I’d get…” She has to swallow. It’s costing her a visible effort to speak. “I’d get put into the foster system. Never see them again. Take me home. I want my family.”

Um, why? Calamity's injuries don't really scream "parental abuse" so much as "got caught in a fucking explosion like the one that just happened downtown." Is she afraid they'll pick up on her dodgy super-serum blood? Because surely if that was an issue it would've come up when she was being treated for leukemia.

“You’re going to die!”

“Danny.” Even saying this much seems to exhaust her. “I’ve been ready to die since I was four years old. Take me home.”

Again, why isn't Sarah the main hero? Danny remembers he has four fifths of a superhero team at his beck and call, including a doctor:

We come to Legion Tower at speed and I don’t slow down before the long skid across the landing pad that barely brings me down to a running pace before I hit the glass doors. One of them shatters under my boot, and I punch the elevator call button.

“Come on.” The elevator is taking forever. “COME ON!”

An intercom clicks on. It’s Graywytch. “What are you doing?”

“It’s my friend! She’s really hurt!”

“I’m sending an elevator and waking Doctor Impossible,” says Graywytch.

Given how Daniels generally writes characters he doesn't like, I'm surprised Graywytch didn't laugh and call Sarah obsolete farm equiptment, because all TERFs are also white nationalists.

“I’m going to have to take her into surgery,” says Doc Impossible. She is clipped and distant. “Wait upstairs in the lounge.” She strides off deeper into her lab. The robots follow with Calamity.

The airlock closes behind me with a thu-thunk of magnetic bolts, and it’s hard to shake the feeling that I’m never going to see her again.

Sarah is not nearly that lucky.

Next chapter, Danny's explaining the whole stupid chain of events to Magma.

“I know, I screwed up. I should have come to you the moment we were done with Gerald.”

“Yes, you should have, but I was going to say you did the best you could under difficult circumstances, and I think we owe you an apology for not being a more hospitable source of guidance for you.”

"I mean, we pretty much all defended you from our colleague's insults, and gave you free clothes and super-gear, and offered you provisional membership, but still, we should've done more."

I look up at him, not quite sure if I should believe what he says. “Really?”


“Yes. Absolutely. And if I’d known Calamity was Ricochet’s daughter I would have contacted her as well. This isn’t high school. We don’t give detention for sticking your nose in where it doesn’t belong.

"We don't actually have any fucking rules."

If I’d known you were this close to being ready, I’d have found something for you to do. Sidelining someone as strong as you, with as little experience as you have, was a damned dangerous mistake. Power is difficult to live with sometimes, especially when you’re young. You shouldn’t have been left on your own to learn things the hard way.

The only reason he was was because he constantly turned you guys away! If anything was actually your fault, it was taking "no" for an answer! Some crying later, and it's time to hear the Legion's side of the story regarding Ricochet:

Doc Impossible tilts her head back and shoots a pillar of smoke into the air. “He was an associate member. Part-time, only pulled in for the big stuff. We were fine to let him do his own thing, but he started going after the government.”


“She said he had proof the CIA was smuggling for the cartels.”


“He was probably right,” says Doc Impossible. She shrugs. “That guy he killed worked for them. We sent a delegation to his funeral to mend some fences.”


“Why?” I feel like I’ve been kicked in the gut.


“Look, we know the government is dirty. Parts of it, at least.”

A reminder that the Legion receive their funding and pay directly from the United States government.

“That doesn’t change the fact that he crossed a lot of lines we can’t let one of our own cross. You think tonight was bad? Things that are ten thousand times worse happen when capes try to police the government. It would turn us into a police state overnight, and if we were really lucky that’s all it would do to us. It’s happened elsewhere, and it almost happened here once.

We never hear anything about those cases, because that would be interesting.

Ricochet shouldn’t have killed that man, no matter how crooked he was. Too many things rely on us and the government “Look, we know the government is dirty. Parts of it, at least.” Doc Impossible’s shoulders sag a little, and disgust is written all over her face. “That doesn’t change the fact that he crossed a lot of lines we can’t let one of our own cross. You think tonight was bad? Things that are ten thousand times worse happen when capes try to police the government. It would turn us into a police state overnight, and if we were really lucky that’s all it would do to us. It’s happened elsewhere, and it almost happened here once. Ricochet shouldn’t have killed that man, no matter how crooked he was. Too many things rely on us and the government staying out of each other’s way. Even when it sucks. Or, especially then. Government corruption is out of our jurisdiction, and he knew it.”

You are all government employees!

“He wasn’t.” She shakes her head. “The video that convicted him wasn’t faked; I know, I examined it myself. Ricochet handcuffed a CIA officer, and then shot him in the back of the head. It doesn’t get more premeditated than that, and we do not let our people sink down to that level.” She takes a long drag, taps her cigarette in an ashtray. “But no, that doesn’t make it any better for his kids.”

So, the Legion refused to do anything about the government--their employers--poisoning its own citizens, and Ricochet threw his life away with an act of pointless violence that changed nothing, abandoning his cancer-riddled little kids in the process. Everyone in this world sucks.

Does it make me a horrible person that I feel nothing but relief from hearing her say this? Calamity has done so much for me, believed in me more than I ever did myself. I should be loyal to her and her family. But I don’t want Doc Impossible to be one of the bad guys. I don’t want Magma or Valkyrja to be people I can’t trust. I don’t think I could stand that. Not right now, and probably not ever.

I love it, this whole subplot is basically a nascent tranny-jannie learning that the state is actually their friend and ally.

Tomorrow it might get complicated again. Tonight, I just want it to be simple. They’re the good guys. They’re helping Sarah. That’s the important part.


“Danny, why do you want to be a superhero?” Doc Impossible looks at me. She seems so incredibly tired.


“I don’t.” The answer comes before I think about it, and I feel vaguely guilty about it.


“You wouldn’t have been out there tonight if this isn’t what you wanted,” she says. “You just haven’t given yourself permission to admit it.”

Because teenagers never do stupid shit they think is a bad idea because their friends are into it. On the other hand, the author thinks being sliced and diced and drugged is the one thing kids can consent to, so I shouldn't be shocked.

I think of Charlie, and how reluctant he was to come with us, and I realize she’s right. There’s too much self-loathing bottled up inside me. It gets in the way, keeps me from seeing myself, and what I really want.

So finally, finally, I tell her the truth and hope it doesn’t sound vain. “I want to help people.”


“And that is beautiful, and you’re amazing.” She takes my hand and squeezes it. “But there are a million things you could do to help people that don’t involve pissing off superpowered psychopaths. You could be the best firefighter in the history of fire. You could be a one-woman space program and explore Mars for us. Every single person who has put on the mantle and used it to fight has been killed in action. Every one of them. It is a job with a one hundred percent mortality rate. You could be anyone you want to be, do anything you want to do. Why do you want to get murdered?”

I'm kind of with Doc Impossible: April Daniels clearly isn't interested in superheroes, so why is he so intent on writing them?

“I don’t! I just…I got pushed around a lot when I was little. Even after it eased up when I hit my growth spurt, I still don’t feel safe at school unless I’m hiding in a corner where nobody goes. But now, I’ve got these powers so nobody—” My father looms in my mind’s eye. “—can push me around anymore. And I don’t want to let them hurt anyone else, either.”


“Damn,” says Doc Impossible quietly.


“What?”


“That’s one of the classics, all right. You might be in the right place after all.” She smiles. “God help you, kid.”

See, maybe actually showing Danny stand up for the little guy would've given this some poignancy.

The way she says it makes something click. For a moment I stare into my cocoa and try to figure out how I want to phrase this. “Doc, can I ask you kind of a personal question?”


“Go ahead.”


“How long have you known you’ve made the wrong choice?”


Doctor Impossible grunts. “Ouch. Ya got me.” Her cigarette flares orange in the dim light. “It’s been five years.”


“Have you ever tried to get out? Go back to being nonpartisan, I mean?”


She shakes her head. “Can’t. I made an enemy who will follow me no matter where I go or what I do. It’s not real safe for me to leave the Tower, so I do my work from here. Sometimes we make choices, and we don’t realize they’re permanent until it’s too late.”

And this is why teenagers should get their tits chopped off to look like anime boys.


“I’m fine. I’ve made peace with it. I just want you to know what your choices mean before you make them.”

“Um, thanks, but I don’t think I have a choice anymore,” I say. Doc Impossible looks at me, confused. “Utopia knows my real name.”

Well, his real-fake name, but still.

“Yeah,” I say. “Is there something we can do to keep her quiet once we beat her? Maybe offer her a nicer prison cell?”


“Unfortunately, yes, that’s about the best…we can…huh.” Doc’s face goes blank. I can see the wheels turning in her head. A half-second later, she bolts up off the couch, staring off into nowhere. Her hands come up to her mouth in horror. Her voice is quiet and shaking. “Oh. I can—I can fix this.”


“You can? How?” If there’s some way to keep her from attacking me at school or something, I’m all for it.

I feel like in any realistic scenario the answer would be "we kill her, say it was self-defense, and probably hardly even be lying."

Doc Impossible looks at me, confused for a moment before she seems to remember where she is. “I mean…well, she hasn’t come at you at home yet, so she probably won’t unless you push her. We can make her silence part of a plea deal or…I don’t know…we’ll fix this. Okay? We’ll fix it. There’s some guest condos on the fifteenth floor, you can sleep here tonight.”

Remember this for next chapter.

Danny of course turns down this generous offer, because he for some reason wants to return to his hateful, boring family. This entire book is like if Harry turned down Hogwarts so he could go to Stonewall Secondary.

Next time, the second most retarded thing in the book!
 
Back