If you cant tell by my avatar, im something of a huge fanboy for this franchise.
Played all the games. Even F.E.A.R online!
1 is legit great, not as insane as 2, but it has some great atmosphere and delightful fights. Played and beat the ps3 version. I cant say I recommend it over the PC, as the surround sound design is kinda fucked up. Everything sounds like its right behind you, when its staring you in the face. Otherwise its perfectly fine. Exclusive shotgun is bitching, and the bonus level with playable Delta force is cool.
(The expansions are technically not canon, but there's really nothing that contradicts the main games too much, aside from one character that died being alive and well in 3.)
Extraction Point: VERY good. Definitely a step up from 1, as its really fucks with your head and makes you wonder how much of it is taking place in the real world or your mind.
Perseus mandate: Very big guilty pleasure. Its' not as scary as the others and I understand the Nightcrawlers could have been a bit more fleshed out, but I really loved how it developed into an action packed cluster fuck, of everyone from Delta force, F.E.A.R, Replicas, Nightcrawlers, Armacham, Alma and nightmare spawn fighting each other. (Has an interesting enough ending to spin a sequel off of).
F.E.A.R 2: Im honestly surprised how much people dont like it. This is legit my favorite one. (Although I did play on console)
Beautifully destroyed environments, frantic gunplay, mechs, and increased presence of Alma that completely scared the shit out of me. If felt like every time I turned my head in this game, something was behind me and it was uniquely terrifying. Definitely has the best cinematic set pieces and mind screwy shit of the franchise.
F.E.A.R 3. Meh. It's plot actually does give a satisfying enough ending to the franchise, but its way too haphazard in level design. There's no flow. one minute your at the bottom of a blood red ocean, and the next min your in an airport. Scares are minimal, Alma lacks a presence. Final boss is lame. I mean the multiplayer was interesting, but it really hamstrung what they could do. Also the leveling system completely broke immersion.
F.E.A.R Online: I legit enjoyed this while it lasted. Yeah, it was a shitty Chinese counter strike clone with the engine from 2, but It ran well on my crappy computer and it was free. The flavor text and single player missions were fun if perfunctory. Fondest memory is a mode that was basically team death-match, but one guy was randomly a monster that killed everyone. For a month anyway, then the dev's buffed the shit out of the monster and made it unbeatable.
Hopeful we can get a semi decent sequel in my lifetime, but if anybody's looking for a really good FREE substitute, I whole heartily recommend Underhell.
Go in bind and get the fuck out of the starting ghost house.
https://youtu.be/vJuw8uuG2Jc
Bonus: its quite the experience to actually listen to Alma's lines unfiltered.
https://youtu.be/WRvrwECbSGI