fist_of_khonshu
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2025
Super late to the gist but I actually am working on a paper similar to this topic for a class im in. However, it's on how Superhero Media reflects the decline of our modern society. It's not done and needs more work and polishing. But Ive added it below.I think that part of this is due to a decline in media literacy and people trying too hard to be socially correct. An example that immediately comes to mind is The Coffin of Andy and Leyley. People got mad cuz it features incest, even though incest was used as a way to express the degeneracy of the sibling's relationship. A lack of media literacy and self-policing makes us dumber as a population, as it eliminates free thought and the nuanced exploration of controversial idea
The current state of superhero media can be described in simple terms as uninspired and complacent. Utilizing overused and outdated formulas, in which it did help create, with no regard for telling a compelling or thought provoking story. Instead, it would rather have the viewer remain complacent and be reinforced with ideas that are a comfort to the viewer rather than challenge their narratives or viewpoints.
Some would counter this by saying the current state of superhero media does, in fact, have substance and nuance. While this is true, it is a rarity in the formula. Most often or not you will see superhero media utilize plots and themes that seem deep, but when explored on a deeper level have little to prop up this talking point. Rather, the viewer is spoon fed the narrative and is told that it is deep and complex so that they have little to nothing to think about.
One could blame the Marvel Cinematic Universe for this problem in media, as it did set the groundwork for these formulas and treating the viewer as if they are not capable of independent thought. Comics, while always having been political, never only just explored what modern society viewed as “the right thing to do.”. In fact, a lot of our beloved reformed characters are creations that started with the intent to criticize or understand the opposition of society at the time of their conception. This understanding led to writing that redeemed or reformed these characters into better assets over the course of their existence.
This type of complexity and understanding of characters and themes is little to none in the current era of comic book adaptations and writing. Black and white viewpoints have seeped into the space and corrupted it for the worse in terms of storytelling and creativity in the form of understanding ideologies that we may not agree with. This is not an argument for accepting these viewpoints, however the education and understanding of why these views are harmful can lead us to a path where we are better equipped to criticize or handle them.
The current era of comic book media would rather spoon feed us fluffy, nice stories about domestic life, gender identity or government corruption rather than actually have something to say. While those topics can be important, there are other issues, ideologies and topics we can use comics to explore and criticize or even lift up.
In a world where it's “Us Against Them”, compassion is lost and this shows in our media as we lose sight of our connections with other people and our capabilities to understand how people may fall into these lines of thinking. It is inherently dangerous, and shows in our lack of diverse media topics especially in comics, to forget that we should always educate and see others viewpoints in order to better criticize and understand them.