🐟 Fishtank Fishtank.Live General - Jet Neptune's Pisces Aquarium Internet Reality Show w/ Host Bam Margera

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Official KF Fishtank livechat here!

With a (questionable) W from James Drake, how would you rate season 5 of Fishtank?

  • 1 Star — Absolute disaster. Unwatchable, boring, production fucked it up bad, the fish were lame

    Votes: 56 7.3%
  • 2 Stars — Pretty bad. Some funny moments, dragged, too many vibe repair days. Barely worth checking.

    Votes: 87 11.4%
  • 3 Stars — Average. Solid entertainment in spots, some good chaos and crashouts, but nothing special

    Votes: 169 22.1%
  • 4 Stars — Really good. Lots of hilarious moments, strong fish personalities, solid content and vibes

    Votes: 405 53.0%
  • 5 Stars — Peak Fishtank / Masterpiece. Non-stop insanity, legendary fish and production, pure chaos

    Votes: 47 6.2%

  • Total voters
    764
Direnc is trying to convince the planet to leave. I wonder how quick production is going to shut it down.
Edit: She gave up, but now she's cleaning up B3 for Rachel. TTS came through telling her that she's being manipulated and she froze for 30 seconds trying to compute the situation lol
1750091424970.webp

On a side note, I'm starting to think this whole season's purpose is purely to justify making Arye a main character in Bloodgames 2 lmao
 
Last edited:
Arye a main character in Bloodgames 2 lmao
He's actually perfectly suited for it. He's autistic enough to really get into the roleplay. Of this entire group, I think he'd be the one that fits in that setting the most. The other autists seem to think they'd be too above something like that. Maybe Wrench and Elle could do it.
 
Follow up, how much do we think the other contestants have seen? To me it seems like none of them have watched all 3 seasons (let alone bloodgames and bitchtank) and none of them have watched it live. If I had to guess I'd say Daniel and Jin know the most about it and even they seem like recap watchers who haven't watched all the seasons. Freddy and Rachel know the least. Direnc said she found out about it through a friend so I wouldn't be surprised if she hasn't seen it at all aside from a couple clips.
Daniel, Ellie and Angie have all talked about season 1 in depth and season 2 a little bit from what ive seen. Its safe to say some of the others are hiding their powerlevel after all seeing the massive backlash Angie got for soying out. Jin seems like a sprurned s2 fan who has gripes with production because of that season. Both Angie and Ellie have talked about what big fans of Letty they are. Angie has admitted to Dm'ing Jimmy and both Dan and Angie talked bout Letty's IRL streams and her relationship with Ice poseidon so they are big enough fans to follow the fish outside of fishtank.

Either Dan or Jin made a comment about the girls attractiveness, and said something along the lines of "Atleast we didnt get stuck in here with 4 Tayleighs"

Rachel made comments about only watching either all of season 3 or only the second half, but Dumbgay also revealed she dm'ed him months ago so shes aware of more than just the third season but is just so self absorbed she didnt think she would get hassled at all.
 
Last edited:
Yea, and it was boring compared to other seasons
I am still amazed by the people who shit on season 3. It had the best first 4 week run out of any season right up until Alex B left.
The initial concept had the best execution and pay off and seeing "normies" have to handle Fishtank was amazing. It is such a shame it ended like it did because it would have easily been the best season.
 
He's actually perfectly suited for it. He's autistic enough to really get into the roleplay. Of this entire group, I think he'd be the one that fits in that setting the most. The other autists seem to think they'd be too above something like that. Maybe Wrench and Elle could do it.
Have you watched any of the show so far? Most of them got really into the analog horror shoot, in fact Aryeh was the only one who didn't because he was too busy spiralling over brony shit. He's the most likely to derail any sort of LARP shit over an autistic meltdown considering he already did it within three days.
 
I am still amazed by the people who shit on season 3. It had the best first 4 week run out of any season right up until Alex B left.
The initial concept had the best execution and pay off and seeing "normies" have to handle Fishtank was amazing. It is such a shame it ended like it did because it would have easily been the best season.
I've talked to a few buddies who watch Fishtank more casually and they didn't really like Season 3 because of how slow it started. If you're casually just tuning in and they're sitting around and nobody is being fucked with (to the usual Fishtank level) the season doesn't actually seem as interesting
 
I hate it and I wish it weren't true, but Direnc has totally won me over. Hoping to see some vicious plays from her as the game goes on, assuming we don't see the whole cast replaced after the twist.

Now that there's been enough time spent with this cast, who do you guys want to see in BG2?
 
He's actually perfectly suited for it. He's autistic enough to really get into the roleplay. Of this entire group, I think he'd be the one that fits in that setting the most. The other autists seem to think they'd be too above something like that. Maybe Wrench and Elle could do it.

Have you watched any of the show so far? Most of them got really into the analog horror shoot, in fact Aryeh was the only one who didn't because he was too busy spiralling over brony shit. He's the most likely to derail any sort of LARP shit over an autistic meltdown considering he already did it within three days.
Typed up exactly what I was going to lol. This jew can be funny but he's the worst kind of autist.
 
I've talked to a few buddies who watch Fishtank more casually and they didn't really like Season 3 because of how slow it started. If you're casually just tuning in and they're sitting around and nobody is being fucked with (to the usual Fishtank level) the season doesn't actually seem as interesting
See I have had the opposite reaction. I feel like I have had more people get the hype more from Season 3. Season 1 and 2 were just so inconsistant. One was carried by how it felt like the wheels could come off at any moment. Two was carried by the freeloaders. I remember how many days were such a slog in season two because no one wanted to do anything to each other. Three had more organic events and happenings due to the nature of the contestants being so self absorbed and fame hungry.
 
Has it been found out who Rachel's dad is yet? She's said he's a prolific music journalist who "found" Biggie Smalls.
 
See I have had the opposite reaction. I feel like I have had more people get the hype more from Season 3. Season 1 and 2 were just so inconsistant. One was carried by how it felt like the wheels could come off at any moment. Two was carried by the freeloaders. I remember how many days were such a slog in season two because no one wanted to do anything to each other. Three had more organic events and happenings due to the nature of the contestants being so self absorbed and fame hungry.
I agree, I think season 3 surpasses season 2. For some people though, those last two weeks of the RV, Vegas arc, and extremely underwhelming FH 2.0 payoff ruined it for them. The amazing start it had can actually work against it because of the amount of whiplash one experienced going from famous house kino to a shitty rv stream. I do not understand how you start with Burt, Alex, a perfect heel in Simbal, Luke, and 6 pieces of simp hate then still manage to fumble the season later on.
 
freddy, daniel and angie recruited jin to steal anyones panties, jin stole (probably direnc's) panties, took the fishbuck from angie (that she stole from rachel), and then put the panties back :story:
1750095225434.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom