don’t follow DMCA requests
One thing that's really fascinating to me is that, I'm not aware of any website that actually follows the DMCA - what I mean is, follow the law as it's actually written.
What the law actually says is the following:
(1) a copyright holder (Disney, for example) sends a DMCA notification to a publisher (Youtube, for example).
(2) the publisher
is supposed to forward the notification to a content creator.
(3) the content creator is then (by the letter of the law)
allowed to deny the request by stating, "this content is protected under 'fair use'"
(4) if the content creator does that, then the publisher is allowed to leave the content in place.
(5) the copyright holder is then supposed to initiate a lawsuit against the creator. The publisher is
not a party to the lawsuit. The publisher is protected by having followed the DMCA.
(6) the question of fair use is then decided in a court of law. If the court finds that the material violates copyright, the publisher takes it down.
That's ...not a bad process actually. But as far as I can tell, the way it actually works in the real world is:
(1) Disney tells Youtube to take a video down (or to leave it up but given Disney the ad revenue)
(2) Youtube does what they're told