GPUs & CPUs & Enthusiast hardware: Questions, Discussion and fanboy slap-fights - Nvidia & AMD & Intel - Separe but Equal. Intel rides in the back of the bus.

120mm AIO cooler
Those are garbage, though. 140mm too. You really need 240 or more for modern processors. (I say as I sit next to a computer that runs a 7950X and 4090 on a single 140mm, but that’s a 60mm thick radiator with two 3krpm fans and it’s really only there as a backup to make the computer usable at all with the huge external radiator not plugged in.)
 
I have a case with no intake on the front, only on the side where the CPU and GPU sit. Would a 120mm AIO be better than the top-down cpu fan inside? It's an OEM desktop with an odd motherboard so a new case is out of the question.
 
Those are garbage, though. 140mm too. You really need 240 or more for modern processors. (I say as I sit next to a computer that runs a 7950X and 4090 on a single 140mm, but that’s a 60mm thick radiator with two 3krpm fans and it’s really only there as a backup to make the computer usable at all with the huge external radiator not plugged in.)
I'm running a single 120, and it's doing just fine with my I7 12000K. I'll probably upgrade it to a 240, but the point still stands that with all the cheap cases with extensive rad mounting options beyond 120. If you were building a new rig right now, you're telling me you would go for a giant noctua cooler over a case and 240 AIO setup?
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Gog & Magog
I have a case with no intake on the front, only on the side where the CPU and GPU sit. Would a 120mm AIO be better than the top-down cpu fan inside? It's an OEM desktop with an odd motherboard so a new case is out of the question.
In benchmarks a decent air cooler generally beats a 120/140mm AIO at a given noise level. It’s about the radiator surface area, when the water radiator gets that small its surface area is generally less than that of the tower air cooler. You still get some benefit from having the larger amount of water to sink heat into, which means your fans won’t spin up and down as frequently (assuming you can control them from water temperature rather than from core temper), but if 120mm AIO or 90mm+ tower air cooler were my options, I’d go for the air cooler.
I'm running a single 120, and it's doing just fine with my I7 12000K. I'll probably upgrade it to a 240, but the point still stands that with all the cheap cases with extensive rad mounting options beyond 120. If you were building a new rig right now, you're telling me you would go for a giant noctua cooler over a case and 240 AIO setup?
No, I’d go for the 240mm water cooler. I love Noctua, but high-end processors put out too much heat these days for air coolers to be reasonable.
My computer is a custom loop with a 140mm radiator permanently plugged in, and an optional 720mm external radiator I can plug in with quick disconnects, and it works fine even without the external radiator. But that 140mm radiator is so thick and high density it’s basically equal to a 360mm AIO radiator, and it’s running two 3krpm fans, so the noise level whenever it’s actually doing something can be considerable. With the external radiator plugged in it goes from about 1200rpm to 200, and temperatures drop to a ΔT of 8 degrees, from one of almost twenty.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Gog & Magog
Review

Review for the new cooler is out. I'll give em credit, they beat the pa120 by a degree.

The pa140 and 130mm "royal Praetor" will probably push it back from being in the lead.

(Can't figure out video thumbnail links on mobile)
 
No, I’d go for the 240mm water cooler. I love Noctua, but high-end processors put out too much heat these days for air coolers to be reasonable.
My computer is a custom loop with a 140mm radiator permanently plugged in, and an optional 720mm external radiator I can plug in with quick disconnects, and it works fine even without the external radiator. But that 140mm radiator is so thick and high density it’s basically equal to a 360mm AIO radiator, and it’s running two 3krpm fans, so the noise level whenever it’s actually doing something can be considerable. With the external radiator plugged in it goes from about 1200rpm to 200, and temperatures drop to a ΔT of 8 degrees, from one of almost twenty.
But that's my entire point. For the same or close enough price point to that noctua, you could have a 240, even cheaper with current sales at even bestbuy. If the price point was $100, or you didn't have a case with rad mounts, I could understand. But like I said before, with the availability of cheap cases with rad mounts and the price point of AIOs (even the 240s), what's the point of spending $150 on a tower cooler?
 
But that's my entire point. For the same or close enough price point to that noctua, you could have a 240, even cheaper with current sales at even bestbuy. If the price point was $100, or you didn't have a case with rad mounts, I could understand. But like I said before, with the availability of cheap cases with rad mounts and the price point of AIOs (even the 240s), what's the point of spending $150 on a tower cooler?
Absolutely zero point. At best the new noctua is a tad quieter for a bit more cooling.

Towers have been overpriced for a while now. PC users crank out the usual car analogies (recently had a guy compare buying a Noctua to a Bugatti, lmao)

It's all just brand shilling and thinking that saving money for similar performance is something only "poors" do. They literally think just throwing money away is what smart people with money do.
 

Washer mod not recommended. Don't buy it for value.

But nowadays? My wife's cheap $80 case came with 480mm worth of top radiator mounting area. AIO liquid coolers are cheap and fairly reliable.
I'd spring for a real loop which can be made for a few dollars more than a shitty AIO. Pump res, 1 rad 240+mm rad ( per component, for cpu just get a 360), barrow fittings from aliexpress, and epdm tubes, It may cost a little more but its reusable and serviceable and will work much better. But who am I to talk, I have a Lian-li v3000+ I got off ebay for $200, 2 d5, 1 360mm+2 480mm rads, far too many quick disconnects cooling a 11900k and 3080. But barring intel changing its socket mount holes I can continue to use this block. I've kept it from a 7700k up to my 11900k. AIO are garbage and are overpriced junk.
 
Last edited:

Washer mod not recommended. Don't buy it for value.


I'd spring for a real loop which can be made for a few dollars more than a shitty AIO. Pump res, 1 rad 240+mm rad ( per component, for cpu just get a 360), barrow fittings from aliexpress, and epdm tubes, It may cost a little more but its reusable and serviceable and will work much better. But who am I to talk, I have a Lian-li v3000+ I got off ebay for $200, 2 d5, 1 360mm+2 480mm rads, far too many quick disconnects cooling a 11900k and 3080. But barring intel changing its socket mount holes I can continue to use this block. I've kept it from a 7700k up to my 11900k. AIO are garbage and are overpriced junk.
Oh hey, a fellow v3000+ user. Enjoying it?

Also how's the edpm tubing working out for you? I was gonna switch over to that before I lost time to redo my custom loop for the new case. Still interested in it for the future.

Our loop ideas are pretty damn similar lol.
 
Last edited:
Oh hey, a fellow v3000+ user. Enjoying it?
Overkill but it was $200 on ebay so i couldn't pass it up.
Also how's the edpm tubing working out for you?
Zero plasticizer clogging up my shit, very low permeation. Using Clear DP ultra.
Our loop ideas are pretty damn similar lol.
I need to move my res somewhere else but I threw it together and can't be bothered to move it.
 
Overkill but it was $200 on ebay so i couldn't pass it up.

Zero plasticizer clogging up my shit, very low permeation. Using Clear DP ultra.

I need to move my res somewhere else but I threw it together and can't be bothered to move it.
Right on. How tight can you bend it, and does it kink?
 
The wife's 4060 came in today. Plugged it into my motherboard while we are waiting for a 2x6pin to 1x8pin adapter to come in. Holy shit is this an upgrade from my old 980ti. Now I'm thinking it's time to upgrade, like I've been a frog in boiling water.

I only do 1080p, but I would like any card to last as long as my 980ti did without me having to reduce to medium/low settings. In my older age, I'm not chasing the top of the line anymore, just wanting to have ultra on 1080p for the foreseeable future. Do prices still drop when the next generations come out? 3090ti's came out 2 years ago, and they are still like $2k? I know I've been out of the game for a long time, but damn!
 
Do prices still drop when the next generations come out? 3090ti's came out 2 years ago, and they are still like $2k? I know I've been out of the game for a long time, but damn!
3090s are kind of a different beast because even though they are a generation old, they still have 24gb of VRAM which is very important for AI applications. You’ll probably notice 3070s and 3080s are definitely less than original MSRP.

The 7900xtx also has 24gb of VRAM, however, because it’s AMD, it’s gimped as fuck for AI applications because it lacks CUDA.
 
3090s are kind of a different beast because even though they are a generation old, they still have 24gb of VRAM which is very important for AI applications. You’ll probably notice 3070s and 3080s are definitely less than original MSRP.

The 7900xtx also has 24gb of VRAM, however, because it’s AMD, it’s gimped as fuck for AI applications because it lacks CUDA.
So I should stay lower in the VRAM to avoid the AI tax like the old crypto tax? I was thinking about getting the 4070ti Super or 4080 after next gen drops.
 
So I should stay lower in the VRAM to avoid the AI tax like the old crypto tax? I was thinking about getting the 4070ti Super or 4080 after next gen drops.
3080s (10 GB models specifically) are going in the low 300s used on eBay. I've had mostly great luck buying used computer stuff on there. Just avoid anyone with zero feedback as those are fake dummy listings and it will take eBay 15 days to get you your money back.
 
3080s (10 GB models specifically) are going in the low 300s used on eBay. I've had mostly great luck buying used computer stuff on there. Just avoid anyone with zero feedback as those are fake dummy listings and it will take eBay 15 days to get you your money back.
I'm looking at 40 series, not 30 series. I won't buy until the next gen is out though. Get the DLSS 3. I can hang on to my 980ti for a little while longer. I'm not playing any really demanding games right now.
 
The 7900xtx also has 24gb of VRAM, however, because it’s AMD, it’s gimped as fuck for AI applications because it lacks CUDA.

All the cool python-based AI stuff the kids run these days have been ported to ROCm. The problem is that AMD's ROCm support for its gaming GPUs is terrible.

The FP64 performance on NVIDIA's desktop cards is gimped, but this doesn't matter for AI. When you consider that two generations ago, the V100 had 32 GB of RAM, a 24 GB gaming card is a great AI play (until it explodes into flames, or you buy a bunch, put them in a datacenter, and NVIDIA C&Ds you).

I'm looking at 40 series, not 30 series. I won't buy until the next gen is out though. Get the DLSS 3. I can hang on to my 980ti for a little while longer. I'm not playing any really demanding games right now.

I wouldn't buy a 30 series, either. Each generation of DLSS is almost like an extra generation of hardware improvement. AMD's not in the same league.
 
Back