Been quite a while since I last checked in on this thread. Lately, as I've been doing some catchup on Viv shenanigans, I've been pondering what could've been. Not the shows themselves, mind you, but what would've happened if the causes and effects behind HH and HB were just a little bit different.
For example, what would've happened if Covid never happened, Hazbin got picked up by a different network besides Amazon, didn't get locked behind streaming, was allowed to have a 20-30 episode season instead of a heavily serialized 8 episode one. Heck, what would've happened if HB never existed and Viv and Spindlehorse focused all their efforts on HH? Would the show have become a Simpsons/Spongebob-level success and have been nigh-inescapable online like MLP:FiM was?
Sure, the show is successful with the Hot Topic kids, but it really hasn't broken outside of that bubble, and that bubble is only so big at the moment. My tried-and-true "Profile Picture test" has told me that Hazbin really hasn't had the level of impact that I thought it was going to have back in 2019, for better or for worse.
Granted, I feel part of the reason for that is that Hazbin really doesn't have that much overlap with most of the communities/fandoms I keep tabs on. Compared to say, Undertale, where Toby was able to have a massive reach due to his relations in the Earthbound, ROM Hacking, and competitive Melee community. The most Viv had prior to HH dropping was her built-in fanbase from Zoophobia, and the general cartoon community at large cheering her on.