UN Israel's 'biggest ever' protests as Benjamin Netanyahu's government persists with reforms

Archive Article

Israel's 'biggest ever' protests as Benjamin Netanyahu's government persists with reforms​


Hundreds of thousands of Israelis demonstrated across the country on Saturday night in the 10th consecutive week of protests against their hard-right government's controversial legal reforms.

The demonstrations come as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government prepares to press on with its legislative agenda next week, shunning calls for a pause to allow for negotiations on the divisive plan.

The judicial overhaul is a cornerstone of Mr Netanyahu's administration, an alliance with ultra-Orthodox Jewish and extreme-right parties which took office at the end of last year. Critics say it threatens democracy and would result in less checks and balances.

The latest protests saw up to 500,000 people take to the streets, according to organisers. One journalist was among the people questioned by police for making anti-Netanyahu statements and at least three protesters were arrested.

The Israeli Haaretz newspaper reported opposition leader Yair Lapid said in a speech during demonstrations that Israel "is facing the greatest crisis in its history".

"A wave of terrorism is hitting us, our economy is crashing, money is escaping the country. Iran just signed yesterday a new agreement with Saudi Arabia. But the only thing this government cares about is crushing Israeli democracy," he said.
The biggest demonstration, in the coastal city of Tel Aviv, drew some 100,000 protesters, according to estimates given by Israeli media.
Many of them were waving blue and white Israeli flags.

"I'm demonstrating because the measures that the new government wants to take represent a real and immediate threat to Israeli democracy," one protester, tech entrepreneur Ran Shahor, told AFP.

Demonstrations were held in other cities and towns in the country of more than nine million.

Some 50,000 Israelis protested in the northern city of Haifa and 10,000 in Beersheba - the biggest yet in both - according to Israeli media.
The rallies broke up without major incident, although police arrested three protesters who were blocking traffic on Tel Aviv's ring road. Social media also suggested one man had been arrested for confronting protesters with a hammer, while local journalists reported other onlookers through eggs at the crowds.

The chair of parliament's law committee, Simcha Rotman, has scheduled daily hearings on parts of the government's reforms from Sunday through Wednesday ahead of votes.

Justice Minister Yariv Levin has said the coalition plans to pass key elements of the reforms before parliament goes into recess on April 2.
The proposed legislation would give more weight to the government in the committee that selects judges and would deny the Supreme Court the right to strike down any amendments to so-called Basic Laws, Israel's quasi-constitution.
The government has been pushing for changes that would limit the Supreme Court’s powers to rule against the legislature and the executive, giving the Israeli parliament (the Knesset) the power to override Supreme Court decisions with a simple majority of 61 votes out of the 120-seat Knesset.

These provisions have already been endorsed by lawmakers at first reading.

Israeli President Issac Herzog - who, in his largely ceremonial role, has tried to broker dialogue - on Thursday called on the coalition the halt the legislation, dubbing it "a threat to the foundations of democracy".

Another element of the reforms would give the 120-member parliament power to overrule Supreme Court decisions with a simple majority of 61 votes.
 
not a jew but here's some relevant background information:

their supreme court is very powerful.
new members to the court are appointed by a committee.
that committee is made up of a combination of government officials, members of parliament, sitting judges on the court, and bar association leaders.
the way this is all structured has the effect that the court judges alone have enough power to veto any candidate they don't like from passing the committee.
imagine if the US supreme court judges could veto a new judge being appointed to their court after the senate and president already approved him. that's how it works in israel.
critics say that the court having this kind of control over its own composition makes it undemocratic, nepotistic, and corrupt.
defenders say that this is a good thing because it makes the court ultra independent from the government.

netanyahu and his right wing allies don't like the court because the court currently leans left, so he is now trying to give parliament veto power over the court.
netanyahus opponents (leftists) don't like parliament because parliament currently leans right, so they want their court to be remain independent of it.

tl;dr if this reform goes through, then the leftoids in israel will lose a LOT of power, that's why they're so up in arms about it.
Important to note that the right actually waited to reform the courts until they overstepped their authority. Netanyahu has been feuding with the supreme court for years. Every year they recommend charging Netanyahu with corruption, every year he dodges any potential charges by being the most powerful man in the nation.

For decades the right wing has tolerated the courts as long as they only strike down common laws or executive decisions they deem in breach of Israel's basic laws. Basic laws function like their constitution, and can only be amended with a supermajority.

Recently the right wing achieved enough support to amend a basic law through a supermajority. The supreme court vetoed the amendment. The right wing has now decided the courts have overstepped its authority, and seeks change to the institution. If the supreme court gets to elect its own members and veto supermajority decisions from parliament then they've become technocrats.
 
Important to note that the right actually waited to reform the courts until they overstepped their authority. Netanyahu has been feuding with the supreme court for years. Every year they recommend charging Netanyahu with corruption, every year he dodges any potential charges by being the most powerful man in the nation.

For decades the right wing has tolerated the courts as long as they only strike down common laws or executive decisions they deem in breach of Israel's basic laws. Basic laws function like their constitution, and can only be amended with a supermajority.

Recently the right wing achieved enough support to amend a basic law through a supermajority. The supreme court vetoed the amendment. The right wing has now decided the courts have overstepped its authority, and seeks change to the institution. If the supreme court gets to elect its own members and veto supermajority decisions from parliament then they've become technocrats.

Yup, as I said before on this.. The western media and political elite are having a meltdown over Israels attempt to reform their system to one more in line with our own. One more sane and democratic, as well as less corrupt and elitist. A change spelled out quite clearly before an election won outright by it's supporters.

Another case of the same old story of the left being on the other side of democracy and absolutely flipping their shit over not getting their way. "To "save" democracy we have to ignore it this time!"

Technocratism is an issue that doesn't get much attention but is vastly important to elites and progressives power structure. It needs to have light shown on it ASAP. People mistakenly think it's just about bureaucracy, but it is in fact much more! It's about putting absolute power/say into the hands "experts" (i.e. modern approved intellectuals and academics) and other people who "know better" than the people and politics. I remember reading a screed from some UK college brat, absolutely melting down over brexit and saying the quiet part out loud. About how democratic rule is over anyway and the future is people who know better than you telling you how to live. And thus how it will be "all the same" inside the EU and outside. This is what we are up against, and why the elites are so butthurt over this attempted change. It's reversing something that should be started every place else.
 
Last edited:
How is this any of your business, unless you know you are fucking over your neighbors and if they ever stop bickering amongst themselves they might start dealing with the one country screwing over the whole region.

I used to believe the majority of Israeli Jews can't be as bad as their government, then I found out there are many orthodox and greater Israel fanatics who are even worse than their government. I still held on to the believe that there are some moderate Israeli Jews, that was just me projecting they all know exactly what their government is doing and usually only criticize it if they aren't hawkish enough.
Those Orthodox Jews will inherit Israel. Almost 7 kids per woman, don't pay taxes, (normally) don't serve in the IVF. But they'll still demand US money and weapons. Oh, and they'll still cite Iran as a threat despite the whole Dimona reactor thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Tall Man
Back