JK Rowling and the Use of Pseudoscience to Justify Transphobia

[Mariposa Electrique]

For all of you who insist that there are only two sexes and gender is the same as sex: PROVE IT WITH A PEER REVIEWED PAPER PUBLISHED AFTER 2015.

Otherwise, put a sock in it and take a seat. Continue to harangue transgender people if you like, but don't fucking start sniveling about how mean they are back at you, you sexist sado-masochistic sycophants.

We don't have to prove common knowledge when you can't prove you didn't rape anyone or anything.

 

[Tragi-Chan]

What makes a person "male" or "female" is what sort of gamete their gonads produce. What makes a person a "man" or a "woman" is much more complex than that because you have to take cultural norms into consideration. The fatal flaw in this reasoning is the insistence that all people with penises must present as masculine men and all people with vaginas must present as feminine women. nature simply doesn't work that way. A substantial portion of the population is trans masculine or trans feminine to some degree. In some of us, it is so extreme that we're physically and psychologically better suited for the transgender role. Get used to it mighty white men. Queer bashing is becoming very unpopular.

For all of you who insist that there are only two sexes and gender is the same as sex: PROVE IT WITH A PEER REVIEWED PAPER PUBLISHED AFTER 2015.


Otherwise, put a sock in it and take a seat. Continue to harangue transgender people if you like, but don't fucking start sniveling about how mean they are back at you, you sexist sado-masochistic sycophants.

This is an argument in bad faith. You’re the one making the assertion that sex and gender are two separate things. The burden of proof is on you. And don’t try that “well YOU’RE asserting that they AREN’T” bullshit, that’s for high school.

If gender is, as you say, based on the individual’s feelings and culture, that’s outside the scope of science. You’re expecting us to find the science for something that you yourself are unable to categorise in scientific terms. Heck, you don’t even know what “harassment” is.

And to get it in early: drink every time Tommy says “sexist sado-masochist sycophants.” I think he’s proud of that one, so we’re going to see it a lot.

 

[7he47r0n]

Mr. Wasserberg, there are only two sexes. You are male. It would do what little crumbs of happiness you have left in the short lifespan remaining to you to come to terms with those two simple facts. "Gender" doesn't exist; it's a made up pseudoscientific term invented by a paedophile in a position of authority.

 

[Positron]

Actually, this dump is easy to stand up to. infantile imbeciles screaming insults at me really don't phase me much. redundant retards like dave and mariposa are to laugh at, not get upset about. Getting angry is just punishing myself for somebody else's bad behavior.

There are numerous sexually dimorphic structures in the brain, most notably the hippocampus and amygdala.

Brain Sex Differences Related to Gender Identity Development: Genes or Hormones?

You didn't read the paper did you? It is not my job to educate you but it is my pleasure, so let me show you:

"However, the relationship between gender behavioural differences and brain dimorphic areas is still not clear, since such differences may be the result not only of anatomical features but also life experiences. Furthermore, the popular explanation that there is a female and a male brain on the base of gender behavioural differences is not supported by a strong empirical background."​

OF FUCKING COURSE there are numerous differences between the male brain and the female brain -- there is a region called the "Sexually Dimorphic Nucleus" for crying out loud! But there is no evidence whatsoever that the brain of sexual degenerates such as yourself resembles the female brain -- or the normal male brain for that matter. What trannies have are diseased brains.

 

[Steinercard]

This discussion is tedious. You can not talk someone out of gender dysphoria the same way you can not talk someone out of schizophrenia. You can't convince people suffering real mental illnesses to take them off like a coat. People think you can because this site loves to argue with teenagers on Tumblr who think mental illness is a handbag to be proud of.

>Trannies have numerous mental illness some of which are misdiagnosed and treated with pills that affect their judgement (especially ADHD meds)
>They are manipulated into taking HRT and more pills by therapists and discord trannies that mess with their body and will require life long meds.
>Guess which global industry benefits most from that and encourages it
>cutting off contact with anyone sane because Trannies hate happy people. They don't want real treatment they want validation even if it makes them more miserable
>No matter how much you plead with them, They ARE going to get their dick slit.
>They will live a life of pain and agony despite being warned by several people not to get their dick slit
>they will only realise how messed up their lives are after going through all this pain
>41% eventually becomes 42% and onwards and trannies still insist the best treatment for dysphoria is to transition.

Life is shit.

 

[Dee Price]

Actually, this dump is easy to stand up to. infantile imbeciles screaming insults at me really don't phase me much. redundant retards like dave and mariposa are to laugh at, not get upset about. Getting angry is just punishing myself for somebody else's bad behavior.

There are numerous sexually dimorphic structures in the brain, most notably the hippocampus and amygdala.

Brain Sex Differences Related to Gender Identity Development: Genes or Hormones?

i get better responses here. there are only two people there who communicate with me respectfully.

yep , still a transphobic full of shit asshole who repeats lies about people he's intellectually incompetent to debate. bye, loser.

Graham Linehan? lol. https://acamh.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/camh.12437

you're definitely an idiot if you take dave seriously and laugh at me. the reputation he states is fabricated by professional disinformation specialists he's been groomed by and set on me. you're obviously another millennial mental midget with delusions of intellect and redeeming social worth.

Shut up tom. You are a moron. You only scream and spew out bullshit to try to placate yourself.

@Miss Tommie Jayne Wasserberg

I personally know of adult women who dress and act like men. Short hair, button-up shirt and trousers (dad-style phone holster on the belt, even), and they are attracted to women sexually. At face value you might think they would be "trans" but they are not: they go by their given female names and consider themselves women. So what makes someone objectively "trans"? The answer is that there is no standard.

What it really boils down to is the assertion that self-identification trumps outside observation. The issue at hand with TRA has gone past a call for tolerance and understanding and become a demand for unquestioning complicity, and as I pointed out above it's all founded on the conceit that a person is something solely based on the fact that they say so.

There is no objective standard to anything pushed by TRA ideology, yet it's found a way to influence almost every sphere of public life (including competitive sports where there DOES exist objective realities about the differences between male and female), and all this in the matter of a decade or so. That you and your kind are outraged by any push-back against your baseless assertions about the realities of biology and your social agenda speaks to the fact that it comes from the childish, immature mindset of a bully that expects to get his way no matter what.

Actually well put but somewhat wrong. Just so you understand. there is an objective standard. Always has been. When the neurological studies on transsexuals happened they used that objective standard. straight heterosexual couples age compliant. the trans being considered the abnormal biological test subject.

They actually did find dimorphic clusters that trans male to females even half that never took hormones that were definitely female in size and density. This propelled more studies. Now tom sperges about the doctor that was in charge of the first study but will praise the psychiatrist who was also involved. Tom is a moron he really has no clue about science.

Now I hope this helped you if you need to research the doctors name is Dr. Dick F. Swaab.

you're unworthy, derp. you are firmly standing on bullshit and Rowling is insignificant in the big picture. This is about what the actual science of sex and gender says today against what people who are literally attempting to commit genocide against queers are saying. you are standing with your head squarely up your ass on the wrong side of history, child man with delusions of intellect and redeeming social value. I leave the house most days and receive visitors several times a week.

No and my name is not Thomas and I really don't give a fuck what you think of me.

No tom your name is Thomas. And you have no clue about the science of sex and gender. You go by pseudoscience and social study majors. and scream at anyone that will not placate you.

Since you were reasonably polite here, I'm going to try and respectfully show you how you are and your kind, which i'm guessing to be white males who claim to be "super straight", are the bullies in these #Transwars.

Many of those adult women who dress and act like men have been transitioning since 2008, taking on male names, though the majority of them remain pretty steadfast butch lesbians. The fact is, trans men and women have been around in all cultures forever and it is no recent phenomenon by any stretch, but the climax of a 50 year struggle for queer equality that began at Stonewall when they dragged a butch lesbian out of the club and the the drag queens started throwing shot glasses and bricks at the cops.

There are pretty clearly defined medical criteria for intersex and transgender people that go well beyond the self identification. There are no real rules for gender expression, but there are standards of common courtesy that you don't seem to give a shit about. Just because you choose to conform to the standards of behavior for typical men or women, gives you no right to stand in judgement of people who don't. If you don't like it, don't look and certainly don't go out of your way to make somebody's life more difficult than it already is because of your misconceived prejudices. That's what this site is about: publicly and proudly tormenting gender non-conforming people , waving around total bullshit you call science, while projecting your deviant fantasies at us. The bottom line is you can either respect a person's identity, walk away graciously or be an asshole. There is no real debate. You are standing on false facts trying to deny people the right to #SelfDetermination and #BodyAutonomy.

When you talk about "TRA ideology" you are talking about militant enby and truscum freaks who do not represent the mainstream community advocacy in the least. They're just a bunch of armchair activists and keyboard commandos making a lot of noise on the social networks. The real change happens in courtrooms and legislative chambers and that's more rightly the province of the ACLU, Human Rights Campaign, PFLAG, National Center for Transgender Equality, Lambda Legal, Transgender Law Center, GLAAD and a number of others. The real community advocates are better known for their charm, wit and grace under fire while very coherently laying out the true facts of the science of sex and gender and the transgender experience. If there is one thing you can be sure about anybody calling themselves a TRA is that they are only representing themselves if they're not pushing one or more of the bigger groups' agendas.

You are the one who is tossing around junk science. Science is not religion. Our knowledge base changes over time. The XX/XY crap and all the ridiculous behavioral psychology of patriarchal perverts you pukes push is simply invalid. Show me one peer reviewed paper published after 2019 that claims there are only two sexes, two genders and that same sex attractions and transgender identities are not biologically based and are pathological or put a sock in and take a seat, please.

No one tom is going to read that wall of bullshit. And hush about a group of people you do not really belong to. and there you go using that word truscum that only proves to others and do get you are one of those militant freaks tom that transsexuals like myself would love to see shut up and dealt with harshly.

@FEETLOAF you're wrong.


@Duck Duck TUUURN What needs to happen in people's minds is to realize that "biological sex" does not always match an individual's "biological gender identity" and to force those people into an unnatural gender role because of their genitals is unspeakably cruel and the primary reason the suicide rate is so high.

What makes a person "male" or "female" is what sort of gamete their gonads produce. What makes a person a "man" or a "woman" is much more complex than that because you have to take cultural norms into consideration. The fatal flaw in this reasoning is the insistence that all people with penises must present as masculine men and all people with vaginas must present as feminine women. nature simply doesn't work that way. A substantial portion of the population is trans masculine or trans feminine to some degree. In some of us, it is so extreme that we're physically and psychologically better suited for the transgender role. Get used to it mighty white men. Queer bashing is becoming very unpopular.

For all of you who insist that there are only two sexes and gender is the same as sex: PROVE IT WITH A PEER REVIEWED PAPER PUBLISHED AFTER 2015.

Otherwise, put a sock in it and take a seat. Continue to harangue transgender people if you like, but don't fucking start sniveling about how mean they are back at you, you sexist sado-masochistic sycophants.

Old man you know there is a lot of science supporting the binary brain. Oh that is right you suck at biology, and you scream ghoul every time you are proven wrong. As you did with Dr. Sapolsky and Dr. Swaab.
Swaab having papers post even in 2017 2018 and 2019/

Mr. Wasserberg, there are only two sexes. You are male. It would do what little crumbs of happiness you have left in the short lifespan remaining to you to come to terms with those two simple facts. "Gender" doesn't exist; it's a made up pseudoscientific term invented by a paedophile in a position of authority.

You are correct there is only two sexes. But gender does exist it is the neurological part of male and female. and there are only two genders or brain sex if you so wish for ease of comprehension.

And actually DR. Money proved gender is not a social construct.

You didn't read the paper did you? It is not my job to educate you but it is my pleasure, so let me show you:

"However, the relationship between gender behavioural differences and brain dimorphic areas is still not clear, since such differences may be the result not only of anatomical features but also life experiences. Furthermore, the popular explanation that there is a female and a male brain on the base of gender behavioural differences is not supported by a strong empirical background."​

OF FUCKING COURSE there are numerous differences between the male brain and the female brain -- there is a region called the "Sexually Dimorphic Nucleus" for crying out loud! But there is no evidence whatsoever that the brain of sexual degenerates such as yourself resembles the female brain -- or the normal male brain for that matter. What trannies have are diseased brains.

Actually there a lot of work microscopically that tom has no clue about and he fails at. He calls the doctors ghouls. He refuses to look at the microscopic aspect of the brain.

But they have proven the male female brain which is why the word sexually dimorphic nucleus exist.

the question makes no sense. everybody is uniquely crafted and everybody defines themselves. how they do that is totally up to them and anybody who is going to refuse to respect people's pronouns because they are obviously not of that sex is nothing more than a bigoted, seriously misinformed asshole.

yes it does make sense. What does not make sense is why you finger fucked a dog. You did rape a child and that is repulsive enough on its own. But no you had to go all out and become a dog fucking pedophile.

You are also a retard. Do get if people do not question everything then critical thought does not exist.
So they make not know the correct answer but they know a lot more than you.

 

[7he47r0n]

You are correct there is only two sexes. But gender does exist it is the neurological part of male and female. and there are only two genders or brain sex if you so wish for ease of comprehension.

And actually DR. Money proved gender is not a social construct.

I do not consider sexual deviants to be an authoritative voice. Anything that spews forward from their mouths is to be ignored, and cremated in the oven of historical obsolescence.

 

[Dee Price]

I do not consider sexual deviants to be an authoritative voice. Anything that spews forward from their mouths is to be ignored, and cremated in the oven of historical obsolescence.

Dr. Dick F Swaab is not a sexual deviant. He is now an 80 year old heterosexual male holding two medical degrees. Who has kids grandkids and great grandkids.

You on the other hand must not have known this. He is a world famous neuro research doctor. At this moment is is working on a nonsexual problem caused by aging.

Now tom is a sexual deviant and a retard. The best part is tom is also a sperging ass clown. Nothing remotely close to the truth oozes from his foul male mouth. And in this case you are totally bullseye correct.

As for me well i tend to run from relationships and never had a desire for sex especially once i started taking care of the kids. But the one thing that i knew was that murder rate is from pre ops that do not get you do not go out socially or for any reason unless with friends on a non dating get together.

 

[7he47r0n]

Dr. Dick F Swaab is not a sexual deviant. He is now an 80 year old heterosexual male holding two medical degrees. Who has kids grandkids and great grandkids.

You on the other hand must not have known this. He is a world famous neuro research doctor. At this moment is is working on a nonsexual problem caused by aging.

Now tom is a sexual deviant and a retard. The best part is tom is also a sperging ass clown. Nothing remotely close to the truth oozes from his foul male mouth. And in this case you are totally bullseye correct.

As for me well i tend to run from relationships and never had a desire for sex especially once i started taking care of the kids. But the one thing that i knew was that murder rate is from pre ops that do not get you do not go out socially or for any reason unless with friends on a non dating get together.

Sir, I have said this before, and I will say so again - the words of sexual deviants hold no value to me. Go with Christ, and sin no more.

 

[Miss Tommie Jayne Wasserberg]

This discussion is tedious. You can not talk someone out of gender dysphoria the same way you can not talk someone out of schizophrenia. You can't convince people suffering real mental illnesses to take them off like a coat. People think you can because this site loves to argue with teenagers on Tumblr who think mental illness is a handbag to be proud of.

>Trannies have numerous mental illness some of which are misdiagnosed and treated with pills that affect their judgement (especially ADHD meds)
>They are manipulated into taking HRT and more pills by therapists and discord trannies that mess with their body and will require life long meds.
>Guess which global industry benefits most from that and encourages it
>cutting off contact with anyone sane because Trannies hate happy people. They don't want real treatment they want validation even if it makes them more miserable
>No matter how much you plead with them, They ARE going to get their dick slit.
>They will live a life of pain and agony despite being warned by several people not to get their dick slit
>they will only realise how messed up their lives are after going through all this pain
>41% eventually becomes 42% and onwards and trannies still insist the best treatment for dysphoria is to transition.

Life is shit.

This is pure fiction, dude. Back this bullshit with documentation or STFU.

First off, you are only talking about transsexuals, who comprise about 20% of the total gender non-conforming population. I'm intersex. They cut on my stuff when I was a baby. They're not cutting on me again, but the hormones beat the living shit out of the psych drugs they wanted me taking forever for managing my behavioral health deficiencies.

You only have to do that when something isn't actually real.

You believe it is not real. You cannot show proof of your belief because your belief is dead wrong. Post a link to a peer reviewed paper published after 2015 that supports your opinion or shut your ignorant transphobic mouth.

You didn't read the paper did you? It is not my job to educate you but it is my pleasure, so let me show you:

"However, the relationship between gender behavioural differences and brain dimorphic areas is still not clear, since such differences may be the result not only of anatomical features but also life experiences. Furthermore, the popular explanation that there is a female and a male brain on the base of gender behavioural differences is not supported by a strong empirical background."​

OF FUCKING COURSE there are numerous differences between the male brain and the female brain -- there is a region called the "Sexually Dimorphic Nucleus" for crying out loud! But there is no evidence whatsoever that the brain of sexual degenerates such as yourself resembles the female brain -- or the normal male brain for that matter. What trannies have are diseased brains.

Please don't embellish my statement with things i never stated. I was asked which regions of the brain are thought to be associated with gendered behavior, like the SDN, which is located in the hippocampus. Nothing is clear about the physiology of behavior in general, without trying to distinguish between male and female behaviors. Nobody has ever been able to definitively distinguish between male and female brains unless you happen to be Dave Price misinterpreting the work of Schwab and others.

 

[Troonwhisperer]

You believe it is not real. You cannot show proof of your belief because your belief is dead wrong. Post a link to a peer reviewed paper published after 2015 that supports your opinion or shut your ignorant transphobic mouth.

Please don't embellish my statement with things i never stated. I was asked which regions of the brain are thought to be associated with gendered behavior, like the SDN, which is located in the hippocampus. Nothing is clear about the physiology of behavior in general, without trying to distinguish between male and female behaviors. Nobody has ever been able to definitively distinguish between male and female brains unless you happen to be Dave Price misinterpreting the work of Schwab and others.

Mr. Wasserberg, might you please stop sperging in this forum and do something productive? How about getting a karyotype and prove to us your totally real intersex condition?

 

[EmpireOfTheClouds]

Please don't embellish my statement with things i never stated

You're a special kind of blind idiot this morning, aren't you?

 

[Steinercard]

This is pure fiction, dude. Back this bullshit with documentation or STFU.

Okay. You will die in agony and your parents will cry, then bury you with your real name. I conducted this study scientifically with a council of my peers. Who include the renowned physicist Rosey Palms and her five sisters.

 

[Dee Price]

Double post again? You never stop with the rage do you old shit stain.

This is pure fiction, dude. Back this bullshit with documentation or STFU.

First off, you are only talking about transsexuals, who comprise about 20% of the total gender non-conforming population. I'm intersex. They cut on my stuff when I was a baby. They're not cutting on me again, but the hormones beat the living shit out of the psych drugs they wanted me taking forever for managing my behavioral health deficiencies.

You really hate transsexuals and real natural born females tremendously. You old foul beast of a man.

And you do not belong on hormones you do belong on the psych drugs you schizophrenic pile of garbage eating dog fucking child raping pervert.

You believe it is not real. You cannot show proof of your belief because your belief is dead wrong. Post a link to a peer reviewed paper published after 2015 that supports your opinion or shut your ignorant transphobic mouth.

Please don't embellish my statement with things i never stated. I was asked which regions of the brain are thought to be associated with gendered behavior, like the SDN, which is located in the hippocampus. Nothing is clear about the physiology of behavior in general, without trying to distinguish between male and female behaviors. Nobody has ever been able to definitively distinguish between male and female brains unless you happen to be Dave Price misinterpreting the work of Schwab and others.

And neither can you of anything past psychology which by the way is not medical.

 

[MediocreMilt]

Dr. Dick F Swaab

If your name is Dick-Swab and you aren't going by "Richard" or "Rick" there's something a little off with you.

 

[Dee Price]

If your name is Dick-Swab and you aren't going by "Richard" or "Rick" there's something a little off with you.

But the main thing to remember is elementary school was rough for him. You know he had to get teased relentlessly.
But yes he has a very odd name to be honest.

 

[discombobulate]

transgender children and their parents

More like "abused children and their abusers."

 

[Dee Price]

More like "abused children and their abusers."

depends. I was i know that. Jazz maybe but mason child definitely. when you seek fame at the expense of your child outing them as trans you put them in the sights of violent bigots that may in turn kill them.

So you are totally correct it is abuse to try to use your kids neurological condition to gain fame.

Something are best left unseen and unheard. I salute you for the honest and true post.

 

[Mr Pancakes]

you're unworthy, derp. you are firmly standing on bullshit and Rowling is insignificant in the big picture. This is about what the actual science of sex and gender says today against what people who are literally attempting to commit genocide against queers are saying. you are standing with your head squarely up your ass on the wrong side of history, child man with delusions of intellect and redeeming social value. I leave the house most days and receive visitors several times a week.

Well I thought my very first post was kinda respectful but I guess I was wrong. I asked about JK rowling because of the thread title, but you now have changed the story saying shes insignificant which i would agree, she really hasnt done anything against transpeople but just specify there is a difference between sex and gender which I would think most people would agree with. I would also like to know who is committing genocide against "queers" because if this in indeed happening no one is talking about it and as you are very big on providing proof I would be very interested to see it.

 

[EmpireOfTheClouds]

Well I thought my very first post was kinda respectful but I guess I was wrong. I asked about JK rowling because of the thread title, but you now have changed the story saying shes insignificant which i would agree, she really hasnt done anything against transpeople but just specify there is a difference between sex and gender which I would think most people would agree with. I would also like to know who is committing genocide against "queers" because if this in indeed happening no one is talking about it and as you are very big on providing proof I would be very interested to see it.

Bruh, I'll have you know that Thomas is in no fucking position to be lecturing people, let alone making demands. Do not let him gaslight you; it doesn't work on us so I have no idea why it should on you.

Also, there is no "transgender genocide". Genocide as a word has officially lost all meaning.

you're unworthy, derp. you are firmly standing on bullshit and Rowling is insignificant in the big picture. This is about what the actual science of sex and gender says today against what people who are literally attempting to commit genocide against queers are saying. you are standing with your head squarely up your ass on the wrong side of history, child man with delusions of intellect and redeeming social value. I leave the house most days and receive visitors several times a week.

No and my name is not Thomas and I really don't give a fuck what you think of me.

You're a special kind of retard today, aren't you, Thomas?

If people are trying to commit genocide against queers, why am I still alive?

And no, "41%" ain't proof. Those people are doing it themselves, Thomas.