I actually liked Voidburger when she did those text only lps of silent hill, then she started talking and it just went all down hill for me.
It's because Voidburger, as with most text LPs in general, let the game do the talking. Half because you're aware that the game's atmosphere speaks for itself when you decide to do text, and half because writing text for every single moment of the game is probably incredibly tedious.
Speaking of text-based LPs, I'm reminded of a monstrously horrible screenshot LP of one of the Megaman Zero games. The guy was trying way,
way too hard to be funny and wrapped around to being hilariously bad. Through text, he was commentating over the opening cutscene to the game where a character's first line of dialogue as they ran away is "*pant* *pant* *gasp*." Cue the guy writing a paragraph for a single. 240p picture that basically went (by no exaggeration):
"Here we see the female lead playing my favorite childhood game, 'pant pant gasp.' It's like 'duck duck goose' but instead of saying 'duck' you pant and instead of saying 'goose' you gasp. When you gasp, the person you gasped at has to chase you before you sit down in their spot while you pant, pant, and gasp while running away. If you sit down in their spot, you win, and now they have to play 'pant pant gasp' in your place."
Every screenshot had jokes precisely like this (in length and verbosity), and I believe it was the creator's very first (and only) post in the entire forum. He didn't even get to actual gameplay, it was just the short, two-minute cutscene at the start and he called it quits. He went dead silent as people posted shocked bemusement at his bowel movement, peaking with a video demonstrating how wordy his LP was. The video was just the screenshots he posted, shown on-screen for three seconds at a time, with the text for each screenshot overlaid on top. A majority of the screenshots were completely covered by word after unfunny word which were unreadable due to the sheer density of it all.
It got locked the very day it was posted by Slowbeef, I think, who also commented basically saying the posts in response were much funnier than the actual LP. He might have even given the guy an ultimatum of post more or get banned. I don't know if it's possible to find that thread again, which is a shame because it's one of the moments of SA which stick out the most to me.