Might also be able to make a case for The Classic Game Room but that guy seems to try and reinvent himself every few years before giving up and going back to making game reviews.
I thought that ended? I know at some point it was more about his comic books than actual game reviews.
I decided to check for this post, and while there is a podcast, the rest appears to be trying to promote his music and some old comic book reviews.
SFDebris is a Star Trek reviewer that had videos all the way back to 2010 and is still going. There are videos and a blog before that, but I've never seen them, and I assume are lost media. There were some great bits, like this explanation of World War 2 according to genre films and TV.
I really like hardcore history,
I've never listened to Hardcore History. I've heard nothing but good things. I had no idea it went that far back.
Podcasts are an interesting one. I mentioned Vinesauce in the OP, but it's kind of the same thing with podcasts. I've tried a few times to re-listen to the old Giant Bomb podcast which goes back to 2008, and while technically still around, it went down hill at some point. There's lots of times and places we could point to but as the exact cause. The CBS buyout, Ryan's death, Patrick being hired. We could also go back to the GameSpot podcast before Giant Bomb.
Anyway, it used to be 1-3 hours of gaming talk and news every week. Though how much holds up today is arguable.
Skeptics Guide to the Universe goes back to 2005. I remember liking it back in the day, but it got repetitive. Scientific skeptism, but only towards the same few topics repeatedly. Low hanging fruit like homeopathy and ghosts.
