Magic The Gathering

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
I'm annoyed that I'm more interested in a cactuar than named characters. I really hope the other villains and heroes are flavorful, good, and cool.
Aside from the Commander Face cards they have been pretty good.

Like you can have issues with Shiva from a cost perspective but Her Heavenly Strike stunning things does very much mimic her heavenly strike from 5.
 
Universes Beyond is legit the only thing I can manage to get hyped for, like Tarkir might have some decent dragons but aside from that.

Space Set? YAWN
Llorwyn 2? YAWN
Strixhaven 2? OMEGA YAWN.
I'd be excited for Lorwyn, but I know WotC will cock it up in every possible way, so my hype is dead. Shadowmoor was the more interesting half of Lorwyn anyway.

As for this set: never was a JRPG guy so I never played any of the FF games, and I refuse to consoom Universes Beyond products regardless, so my only engagement with these spoilers is through this thread.
 
I'd be excited for Lorwyn, but I know WotC will cock it up in every possible way, so my hype is dead. Shadowmoor was the more interesting half of Lorwyn anyway.
They almost need to make it Shadowmoor now anyway because otherwise what separates Lorwyn from Bloomburrow?
 
I'd be excited for Lorwyn, but I know WotC will cock it up in every possible way, so my hype is dead. Shadowmoor was the more interesting half of Lorwyn anyway.

As for this set: never was a JRPG guy so I never played any of the FF games, and I refuse to consoom Universes Beyond products regardless, so my only engagement with these spoilers is through this thread.
I despise Tribal Focused sets.
 
They almost need to make it Shadowmoor now anyway because otherwise what separates Lorwyn from Bloomburrow?
In my mind Lorwyn and Shadowmoor are a fluctuating state for the same plane but when they became one it became a twilight world that's neither Lorwyn nor Shadowmoor but both as one. Honestly, I think they'll make it shit and they'll not know what to do.
 
In my mind Lorwyn and Shadowmoor are a fluctuating state for the same plane but when they became one it became a twilight world that's neither Lorwyn nor Shadowmoor but both as one. Honestly, I think they'll make it shit and they'll not know what to do.

Lorimoor, instead of being their Lorwyn or shadowmoor counterparts everyone is trans. Notably I liked the books, but I'm not excited in the least. 15 years ago, now that would be a different story.
 
Universes Beyond is legit the only thing I can manage to get hyped for, like Tarkir might have some decent dragons but aside from that.

Space Set? YAWN
Llorwyn 2? YAWN
Strixhaven 2? OMEGA YAWN.
Edge of Eternities has potential imo. Astronomy has tons of big and cool stuff to pull from. Tarkir is also nice. Love me some Abzan gameplay.
The fact that so many people have no faith in Wizards doing a good job with the original Magic IP is so incredibly damning and explains why UB has been (and will likely continue to be) a massive success.
 
Edge of Eternities has potential imo. Astronomy has tons of big and cool stuff to pull from. Tarkir is also nice. Love me some Abzan gameplay.
The fact that so many people have no faith in Wizards doing a good job with the original Magic IP is so incredibly damning and explains why UB has been (and will likely continue to be) a massive success.
At this point I see Wizards literally increasing the number of universes beyond even more. The number of sets coming out every year is ridiculous though. Powercreep out the window.
 
In my mind Lorwyn and Shadowmoor are a fluctuating state for the same plane but when they became one it became a twilight world that's neither Lorwyn nor Shadowmoor but both as one. Honestly, I think they'll make it shit and they'll not know what to do.
That would cause alot of questions..because the Lorwyn/Shadowmoor thing is part of it's day/night cycle.

During the OG block Oona was controlling it and the Aurora that Happened was caused by the Mending..I don't think we ever found out what the actual duration of day/night is.

Edge of Eternities has potential imo. Astronomy has tons of big and cool stuff to pull from. Tarkir is also nice. Love me some Abzan gameplay.
The fact that so many people have no faith in Wizards doing a good job with the original Magic IP is so incredibly damning and explains why UB has been (and will likely continue to be) a massive success.
Tarkir could be nice, but I 100% believe they are gonna fuck it up by trying to bring back the Khans because the Khans were "Popular" Only reason I care about the set at all is cause I got a Boros Dragons deck and Tarkir is good for some Dragons.

Edge of Eternities is gonna be fucking Aetherdrift/Outlaws/Murders level cringe.

And yes, I stopped hating Universes Beyond because Wizards is such a fuckup when it comes to the IP that I can count on one hand the number of Stories that have been passable since MTG Origins. At least with Universes Beyond there is a chance at getting a card like Cecil that is powerful and a good Representative of the IP he came from.

Who's gonna be the one ring of this set?
I would imagine the Ultima Weapon (The weapon itself not the superboss) since it has a bunch of versions to make variants of so you can do a 1/1 for the FF7(Of course because FF7 Dick Riding) version.
 
At this point I see Wizards literally increasing the number of universes beyond even more. The number of sets coming out every year is ridiculous though. Powercreep out the window.
It's a sad state of affairs. The older stories were really interesting. I'm not going to pretend keeping a cohesive storyline intact over three decades is easy, but I'm allowed to be frustrated by the Marvel-ification of both the writing and design in the past few years. And I'm not nearly as into the lore as others.
Conversely, UB is easy. You don't have to come up with anything new, just adapt already existing media to the game system. People have been doing that on their own for years, myself included. Wizards simply decided that it was worth trying an official version to see how much money was in it. It was the next logical step after official alters/skins of 3rd party IPs. After all, people pay artists good money to draw on their cards, why not see how much money you can make with officially licensed alters of already existing cards?
Overall UB was inevitable given MTG is one of Hasbro's only IPs that's capable of printing money. I'm only mad because of how poorly it has been handled. One simple fix from the beginning was all it took to keep nearly everyone happy: make mechanically unique UB cards silver bordered. Casuals can still play with them, collectors can still collect them, and they don't interfere with the feeling and balance of tournament play.
Universes Within is a good compromise but shouldn't be necessary.

Power creep is a different beast. A little bit over time is necessary because without it the meta will be solved and the game will get stale. However, too much too fast and you end up like a physical gacha game where every new release is noticeably better than the last. That's too chaotic and makes people burn out.
Balancing power creep has to be one of the hardest things in any game that receives regular updates. If you scale back the power in response to going too far too fast, like Homelands and Fallen Empires were a response to Urza's block, people tend to hate it and it sells poorly. WOTC used to be good at managing it, imo until about 2019 when WAR came out, but a faster power creep tends to make more money so here we are.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom