Magic The Gathering

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Volo is neither red nor black so he was mid in that limited set.
Yes, but Volo into Owlbear will effectively end the game.

. He's "fun" in commander
Just because he might be ((FUN)) doesn't mean he was designed for that format, especially given that the most ((FUN)) cards in the format are things specifically not designed for it.
 
Yes, but Volo into Owlbear will effectively end the game.
Yeah, if you hit every land draw and your opponent has terrible luck and can't deal with you taking turn 4 off to play a 3/2 do nothing. Volo is so objectively terrible on the vanilla test that I can't believe he was designed for limited. I can see a durdley commander in a color pair known for durdling but I can't see a 3/2 build around creature for 4 mana at rare, especially one that needs to be defensively stated because he has to make it to turn 5 to do anything. A few sets later 3/2 with upside was 2 mana at rare/uncommon and would play well offensively early and the rares would recur themselves and draw you an obscene amount of cards in grindy games.

I'm more willing to consider something like nuEriette as designed for limited because she at least is reasonable on the vanilla test and will help you live long enough to play bad auras to steal creatures.
 
I'm more willing to consider something like nuEriette as designed for limited because she at least is reasonable on the vanilla test
Nnnnahhh, vanillas and french vanillas don't cut it anymore, especially when they're gold. On 17lands, Eriette has a 51.6% Games Played winrate, which is abysmal and a D- level card. 17lands players tend to be above the curve, so their breakpoint is around 53-4% - that is a C-level card, with 50% being an F.

Now, granted, that's better than Fblthp. Fblthp is a 48.3%. Not the worst rare in the set (that is obeka lel), but really fucking bad.

In fairness, Eriette being 3 colors is probably what does her in. Well, and one of those colors not being Green, which is the nuts color of this set. Astor (2RW) has a 56.7% GPWR, which is like a C+/B- level card. DMU was also admittedly a weird, slow format where color fixing was really good.
 
OTJ as a set has a lot more stinkers than I’d first thought in the rare slot. I’m finally getting some arena reps in with quick draft being available now, and it’s clear to me that most of the rares in this set that don’t do something strong on their own are shit. Even among the secondary list of cards, most of them are shiny traps that are only mythics to drive up the number of wildcards people have to burn on arena.
 
OTJ as a set has a lot more stinkers than I’d first thought in the rare slot. I’m finally getting some arena reps in with quick draft being available now, and it’s clear to me that most of the rares in this set that don’t do something strong on their own are shit. Even among the secondary list of cards, most of them are shiny traps that are only mythics to drive up the number of wildcards people have to burn on arena.
Is there such a thing as an inverse prince format in limited? Where nearly every rare except for one or two chase cards are garbage for draft, but the commons define the format with uncommons just acting as support.
 
Is there no Joshua Graham (arguably the most known character out of Fallout to non-Fallout fans besides maybe the dog, and a cult favorite within the Fandom,) card because
1) They're going to do it as a secret lair later
2) He's super religious in-canon so icky no
3) He is too physically icky to depict
4) WOTC simply wants to deprive me of my single most desired card from a Fallout set

They reference him in a land but who gives a shit? He should be a legendary creature.
9ad503ae-45f1-406b-b1c6-06fcb9d2f2b1.jpg
 
Is there no Joshua Graham (arguably the most known character out of Fallout to non-Fallout fans besides maybe the dog, and a cult favorite within the Fandom,) card because
1) They're going to do it as a secret lair later
2) He's super religious in-canon so icky no
3) He is too physically icky to depict
4) WOTC simply wants to deprive me of my single most desired card from a Fallout set

They reference him in a land but who gives a shit? He should be a legendary creature.
View attachment 5944261
I can see him as a alt commander rather than House.
 
Is there no Joshua Graham (arguably the most known character out of Fallout to non-Fallout fans besides maybe the dog, and a cult favorite within the Fandom,) card because
1) They're going to do it as a secret lair later
2) He's super religious in-canon so icky no
3) He is too physically icky to depict
4) WOTC simply wants to deprive me of my single most desired card from a Fallout set

They reference him in a land but who gives a shit? He should be a legendary creature.
View attachment 5944261
Guys too strong. Here's what I would have made him as;
Screenshot_20240428-080835.jpg
 
Guys too strong. Here's what I would have made him as;
My concept would be it should be a flip card Joshua Graham, Malpais Legate // Joshua Graham, the Burned Man, mardu colors. Front side is offensively stated with lower toughness and trample you do not want it to hit your face for reasons (let's say if it hits your face you get damage * 1/1 soldiers or something) and if it dies from damage dealt by a source you don't control or from an effect you don't control you exile him instead and flip him to a defensively stated creature with deathtouch that can sacrifice creatures for him to deal damage to a target creature, if a creature dies from non combat damage he deals you draw a card or impulse draw it or something. I think that carries a lot of the flavor but also lends itself to making a bunch of shitty redirect damage cards into a deck which is the sort of thing commander players crave.
 
Feather and Inspiring Vantage are nice, rest are meh to trash, the Indian who wrote the prompt to generate Azuza should be straight up honor killed
1714445346748.png

Also a promo video, it's just vocaloid stuff though not really MtG related.

I don't think the Cowboy Bebop crossover was talked about, the promo cards are pretty nice and you can get the anglo version in US Standard Showdowns

1714445610352.png
 
Is it just me or is Miku doing crossovers like crazy right now? Kinda weird having her come to MTG but of all the UB stuff it's definitely not the worst. Though anime-based, she's the mascot for creative software so at least it's not completely mindless.
If anything I’m more surprised we didn’t get this back during neon dynasty. I’m pretty sure that there was a vocaloid mtg song for the set, so a sEcReT lAiR would have been perfect
 
Neon dynasty is still my favorite draft format, and I was around for Khans. I never had a bad draft with it even the ones I lost at.
It definitely was a solid format. Both NEO and All will be One were neck and neck for me, but I did force U/B proliferate and drafted a nasty G/B removal deck that looped 2-drops with tyvar. Saccing a prism to a one mana kill spell? Delightful.
 
Is there such a thing as an inverse prince format in limited? Where nearly every rare except for one or two chase cards are garbage for draft, but the commons define the format with uncommons just acting as support.
Pauper sets are ones in which the majority of games are won by synergy among the commons and uncommons. DMU was a good example of this, because it had so many duds like Astor. More importantly, there were fantastic removal options at common for most colors, and arguably the strongest draft archetype - defenders - didn't give a shit about the rare slot at all, having its busted payoff at uncommon and a tutor for said payoff at common. There's certainly still bombs in these sets - like Archangel of Wrath or Serra Paragon - but they aren't quite as obscene as in Prince sets.

Which still feels like what OTJ is heading towards, big time. It's a little skewed because U is once again so bad. UR is borderline unplayable, UW's mechanic just does not work, UB performs well for top-tier players and garbage for everyone else, and UG is tugged up from mediocrity by having G. But the bombs in the set are cards like Rakdos or Bonnie, just stupidly obscene and overstatted things that really don't look like constructed material and yet get to completely trivialize games the second they drop. MKM had a strong Rakdos bomb, too, but the fact that it was so much faster of a format overall diminished how ridiculous the card was.
 
DMU had one of these, too, speaking of.
That guy... literally just needed his last 2 lines.

Have a guy in our pod that built a deck around him. It's not bad, it just gets annoying when he blinks his commander over and over to just keep digging for vehicles and equipment.

Kindred is a lot better than typal, in that it actually is a word and describes a cycle. But you can tell it was a bunch of sheep following the thought-leader, who began to realize that 'typal' was, indeed, retarded cosmopolitan neologism to 'fix' a problem that doesn't exist. The move towards Kindred is one born of insecurity about having made such a big deal of literally nothing.
That's definitely the most grating thing when listening to MaRo's podcast is he just freely drops "typal" into his discussions and it's like "that's not a word."

Speaking of!
I feel like MaRo is a massive sperg they keep around as a joke. Even Patrick Sullivan, the soy champion, at one point recounts a story where he gave input about the Graft mechanic to MaRo who had a meltdown because he couldn't take criticism.
So no joke, if you enjoy autism you owe it to yourself to give a listen to this DTW episode.
It's a 30 min long episode and I swear he'll spend the first 10-15 minutes just defending himself and his thought process. I would bet his "meltdown" to Patrick was similar.

If anything it seems Mark has a bit of hyperactivity about him with a touch of autism so to any normal person it comes off as insane ramblings, but for MaRo he's still got several steps to go before reaching his meltdown stage.
 
Back
Top Bottom