Man, was What If disappointing. I didn’t even need to watch the newest episodes—just reading the titles and seeing a clip of Agatha Harkness, of all people, defeating and stealing the powers of not one, but two Celestials, and all the eternals, was enough to make me roll my eyes and avoid it altogether.
I loved the concept of an anthology exploring crazy, different Marvel universes. Some ideas, like Strange Supreme, were great. Some had potential like Marvel Zombies. And it was nice to see Storm. But it basically ended up being the MCU again, just with more girl bosses and Mary Sues.
I’m not even exaggerating how often they regurgitated the MCU with a new coat of paint. Want to know how Agatha defeated one of Marvel’s most powerful cosmic entities? With a reference to WandaVision! (Never mind the fact that the rune thing, which stops witches, shouldn’t work on cosmic beings.) And of course, each season ends with a team-up to defeat a bigger villain, except with constant Captain Carter shilling, as is tradition with MCU team up movies.
It didn’t feel like limitless possibilities, it felt like you were thrown constant memeberberries of other MCU projects. Member Black panther? Member Thor’s girlfriend‘s silly friend? Member Wandavision? Member the Grandmaster?
I’m not going to be weeping over its cancellation.