- Joined
- Nov 22, 2021
Denny Hamlin took to the stand for Day 2 of the Michael Jordan vs. NASCAR trial, among others:
One conclusion that may be drawn from the proceedings so far is that NASCAR and the France family should go broke.
Hamlin first relayed how, in 2023, he had expressed concerns about the negotiations for the 2025 charter agreement — the franchise-like system for guaranteeing revenues to teams that is at the heart of the dispute — to then-NASCAR president Steve Phelps, who advised Hamlin to speak with NASCAR chairman and CEO Jim France.
Hamlin said he spotted France eating alone at lunch during the NASCAR Awards week in Nashville, so Hamlin joined France — and came away “very, very discouraged” by their conversation.
“He told me directly the problem in NASCAR is teams spend too much money,” Hamlin recounted, adding France said teams should only be spending $10 million per season to run their cars rather than the current $20 million average.
Hamlin responded by saying it was not realistic to cut his costs in half.
“We’ve cut this grass so short, we’re down to the dirt,” Hamlin said of cost-cutting by the teams.
Hamlin said he told France he was “not trying to be a statistic” and add to the many owners who have gone out of business, and Hamlin asked France how he could recoup his investment in the sport.
“He had no answer,” Hamlin said.
Buterman then noted Hamlin went on former driver Kenny Wallace’s podcast and said the Next Gen car, which requires teams to source parts from a single supplier in an effort to bring parity, was a positive for the sport — something the teams have now used as a key point in trying to prove NASCAR illegally abused its monopoly power.
An animated Hamlin responded by saying he was doing NASCAR a favor by telling fans such things on a podcast and “painting a rosy picture” about what NASCAR wanted drivers to say publicly.
“All my public (comments) are out of context,” Hamlin said about Buterman’s exhibits, adding that if he was negative publicly, “you guys have an issue with that” and there would be repercussions for him at the racetrack.
“You’re able to essentially dictate how I do,” Hamlin said.
Buterman then asked if that means people cannot trust what Hamlin says publicly.
“That’s nonsense,” Hamlin said. “What I do publicly is put out (positive messages). That’s my job. You give me talking points, I say it to make fans feel happy.”
Kessler showed a NASCAR sanction agreement with one SM track — Las Vegas Motor Speedway — which carried a two-year exclusivity clause beyond the term of the agreement. In other words, the track would not be allowed to host any potential rival stock car series for two years after the agreement expired — through 2026, which overlapped with the window in which a new series was most likely to be formed.
Kessler then showed a document from Prime that planned for a meeting between senior executives and France which laid out two pathways — the first of which was “NASCAR has all the leverage and the teams will almost have to sign the terms we put in front of them.”
Prime said he disagreed with that path and pushed for a compromise with the teams, which other executives agreed with. The jury was shown text messages from Phelps, then the NASCAR president, citing a chart that had “zero wins for teams,” and then-NASCAR COO Steve O’Donnell saying the lack of support for the teams would result in a “1998, f— the teams dictatorship, redneck, Southern, tiny sport.”
One conclusion that may be drawn from the proceedings so far is that NASCAR and the France family should go broke.












