Nearly 40% of web pages from 10 years ago are no longer accessible - Maybe the internet doesn't last forever?

L | A
By Christianna Silva
hero-image.fill.size_1248x702.v1.jpg
Is this the future of the internet?

Every young person is undoubtedly given the advice: Be careful what you put on the internet because the internet is forever.

This advice is pretty good. Posting online can still have grave consequences, from getting suspended from school to losing your job. But life online might not be quite as eternal as we think.

According to new research from the Pew Research Center, 38 percent of web pages from 2013 are no longer accessible, and a quarter of all web pages that existed from 2013 to 2023 are no longer available. This trend is undoubtedly more aggressive for older content, which, I suppose, does make sense. For instance, just eight percent of pages that existed in 2023 are no longer available.

This phenomenon is called "digital decay," a sensation in which links to content across the internet, on government and news websites, on the "references" section of Wikipedia, and even X (then known as Twitter) no longer work. The 404 message is becoming all too common.

For instance, about a fifth of all tweets are no longer visible on the site a few months after being posted, either because the account went private, was suspended, or deleted. Tweets written in Turkish or Arabic were more likely to vanish than tweets written in other languages.

As the Columbia Journalism Review wrote, "The fragility of the Web poses an issue for any area of work or interest that relies on written records. Loss of reference material, negative SEO impacts, and malicious hijacking of valuable outlinks are among the adverse effects of a broken URL. More fundamentally, it leaves articles from decades past as shells of their former selves, cut off from their original sourcing and context. And the problem goes beyond journalism. In a 2014 study, for example, researchers (including some on this team) found that nearly half of all hyperlinks in Supreme Court opinions led to content that had either changed since its original publication or disappeared from the internet."

Link rot and digital decay can make some parts of the internet virtually unusable. Have you ever clicked on a news story and found that most of the tweets embedded in the post are blank, and the hyperlinks are no longer active? It's frustrating — and can hurt our ability to understand subjects and issues with context.
 
Sometimes I genuinely feel like I can go back, that these old sites in the corners of my mind are still there frozen in time and all I have to do is look them up, but that isn't the case
All the old tweets, forums, webpages, youtube videos, old 4chan board culture
There's no going back, archive only goes so far
*sigh*
But this site is still relatively the same if not better!
I know what you mean. Some days, I close my eyes, and it's almost like I'm back there. Living it.

We must return to tradition.


 
  • Like
Reactions: Brenda Holiday
Makes you wonder. How much would it cost the US government to prop up a public equivalent of Internet Archive, scrape basically everything and preserve it? Even assuming some bloating of cost due to corruption, how long could $1 billion fund that operation? 10 years? If it cost $10 million a year to run, that's 100 years of running a digital archive for like 0.3% of the money we've thrown at Ukraine in the last couple years. Optimistic, but create it with an ironclad directive that they don't editorialize what gets archived or not, none of this politifaggotry that keeps the Farms off of archives.

Even like half of what I just described would be a great positive for the country. Imagine if we had actual public works instead of people getting felonies for driving over the latest city-funded pride street mural.
you just described the NSA. They do it, but only to spy on you.
 
38 percent of web pages from 2013 are no longer accessible, and a quarter of all web pages that existed from 2013 to 2023 are no longer available.
Thats nuts if you think about it.

I was going back to an old list of links and tried checking them out. Most were blogs or things I thought were cool at the time, old photos. Only a handful of them were active and the few surviving have so much content nuked. Same with youtube videos, copyrighted, deleted and gone off the face of the earth. They are ghosts of their former selves. I regret not saving tons of photos and gifs and videos.
 
Back