wasn't part of it also because some of the people running those sites were genuinely just gaudy people/normal people with a bad eye for colors and design? whereas stuff like
this or
this (literally has "y2k" and "webcore" in its tags) on neocities is purely derivative and more done to look "retro" than because the owner actually thought it would look good/represent themselves well
I'm reminded of the RedLetterMedia guys when they try to describe what makes a "good bad movie", a movie that is bad but still enjoyable. It happens when the director is honestly trying their hardest to make the best possible movie, but falls hilariously short due to limitations of talent or resources. You can still see the care and earnest effort, like the one good idea that's meticulously shot (while the other 90% of the movie is padding), or in one big scene that clearly took up most of the budget.
By contrast, there's irony-heavy movies that try to intentionally make a funny bad movie, but fail because they're fundamentally lying about what they're doing. It's not enough to wink and smirk at the limitations other people faced, that takes the heart out of it. The whole effort feels dishonest.
That's what the newer NeoCities pages feel like. I've browsed NC over the years and found some genuinely fun sites with the old-school spirit. But the troon stuff feels like the worst kind of narcissistic otaku behavior: slavish attention to some aesthethic detail drawn from the source material, but ultimately trying to show off their own "cred" instead of honoring or expanding the source.
There
is a middle ground on NC though. Some pages are used to host projects, becoming a mix between subject matter and personal focus that works. Our own
@CrunkLord420 puts his
TempleOS games on NC, it's a good example of keeping the old web spirit with more modern aesthetics.
And that makes the troon pages even more pathetic and unnecessary, because it means
they have nothing to offer the world other than their narcissism. The Super Mario Bros fan who spergs in 640x480 about easter eggs across 30 years of games, has some deep knowledge to share with the world. People posting projects are creating and giving away useful or fun things. But the alphabet ally with a dozen pixelated pronouns has nothing to give, and nothing to inform you of, other than their terminally inward seethings.