Immersion is another way of saying “stupid time wasting bullshit.” I’m literally reading this thread while cooking in red dead redemption 2 because it’s dumb as hell and requires zero actual attention. I don’t care if it’s “immersive” I have to hunt down, watch Arthur slowly skin an animal for meat, then slowly cook it over a camp fire, to eat it to fill up meters.
All these “immersive crafting survival procedural generation open world realism” games we are bitching about are because our caveman brain literally enjoys the thought of going out and gathering supplies not to die because evolution taught us that. And procedural generation just means that the creators don’t have to design worlds. Just listen to the dwarf fortress guy talk about procedural generation/simulation and you’ll realize “just because it’s random doesn’t make it fun.”