Here’s a question for you all
Do you think decadence is a legitimate cycle in history, and if so, does it belong as a mechanic and how? Not referring specifically to Islamic decadence.
Asking because of Complacency, which I think is very real and kind of similar.
My impression is it is a midwit theory that is all things to all people. You can vaguely gesture to Rome and be “ooh they fell because of their d e c a d e n c e” while real historians talk about things like systems collapse and autistic theological slapfights tearing it apart.
I’m not sure I can even think of a single case of decadence in the moralist way.
As I understand Jena-Auerstadt is textbook "Complacency." I recently set myself a small project of getting the cliffs notes version of the Wars of the Coalition down, not just the Napoleonic Era as a vague thing. I didn't know the exact tale. Turned out it's not that complicated if you spend a day or two just drilling yourself on it. Anyways, I lived most of my adult life with a completely delusional take on European army's fitness levels. Me, contrarian midwit, thought that the British were a suck-ass second-rate army and the whole "Americans beat the greatest army in the world" thing was propaganda. I just plain did not know, did not get, that the British really did have a tiny but extremely good army because at some other point Prussian space marines and the French got drilled into my head, not getting that the thing was that the French were more balanced (not real huge until levee en masse, not real well trained but not Russian orcs, Napoleon was a massive force multiplier) and the Prussian space marines, well, bringing it back to my point, that's only true in two eras (Frederick and Wilhelmine).
So what happens, as I read it, is the Prussians get high on their success (which ultimately hinged on a miracle as they were losing anyways), proceed to sit on their ass for the next several decades while their army rots, it becomes the land version of the Spanish Armada when this Great Power is shown to be a complete sham, total destruction, Prussia BTFO, and it wasn't until Leipzig that they proved they had gotten their shit together and wasn't until Motlke that the army was actually good.
Complacency -> Nation loses catastrophically