Captain Lhurgoyf
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2014
So I used to roleplay on the MS Paint Adventures forums because I was into the fantroll community (I'll note that I'm not a Homestuck, and in fact strongly dislike them, but I do find all the worldbuilding they put into the trolls fascinating and got into that scene). They used to have a "cafe" thread there where people could randomly drop in and RP their characters with other people. It was all really fun, until it gradually got taken over by douchebags.
After a while the mods started being actively hostile towards the RPers there and started raising shit-fits because they didn't like the trolls that some people were playing. A lot of times this was because they contradicted their fanon ideas of what trolls were like, regardless of whether or not this was backed up by canon. They started up a blog to bash the characters of people who used their thread (keep in mind these were the moderators). Eventually they made it so that you couldn't post in the thread unless you submitted your troll to the mods and they thought it was "good" enough (even though the entire point of this thread was that it was supposed to be a casual RP with no applications). That was the point that I finally quit, but honestly, looking back, I'm surprised that I stuck around as long as I did because the people running the thing were absolutely insane.
A brief list of things they thought were unforgivable in a character (some of these may not make any sense to those unfamiliar with Homestuck, but trust me, they're frickin' idiotic reasons to keep someone out):
One last note: At one point I brought it up that my character was the troll equivalent of Jewish. I will establish that I had decided this for quite some time now, it just hadn't come up in the RP, and that the author of the comic did allude to it being something that existed before. The admin of the thread - not a mod, not some random retard, but the admin - messaged me saying that he was offended because my character "didn't act like a Jew". Yeah, that was something that happened.
EDIT: Oh, I nearly forgot! The aforementioned troll ended up on that blog because someone thought that I had copied another user's troll just because they looked similar. I created said troll before I even knew of the cafe thread's existence, no less that of the troll everyone thought I had stolen.
After a while the mods started being actively hostile towards the RPers there and started raising shit-fits because they didn't like the trolls that some people were playing. A lot of times this was because they contradicted their fanon ideas of what trolls were like, regardless of whether or not this was backed up by canon. They started up a blog to bash the characters of people who used their thread (keep in mind these were the moderators). Eventually they made it so that you couldn't post in the thread unless you submitted your troll to the mods and they thought it was "good" enough (even though the entire point of this thread was that it was supposed to be a casual RP with no applications). That was the point that I finally quit, but honestly, looking back, I'm surprised that I stuck around as long as I did because the people running the thing were absolutely insane.
A brief list of things they thought were unforgivable in a character (some of these may not make any sense to those unfamiliar with Homestuck, but trust me, they're frickin' idiotic reasons to keep someone out):
- Trolls with snake themes (thought they were overdone and all the same)
- Subjugglators (thought they were all the same and invariably Gamzee ripoffs no matter how well they were written individually)
- Trolls who weren't assholes (thought they were "not real trolls" and "grey humans". I do acknowledge that many of the trolls we see in canon ARE assholes, but the comic makes it clear that this is far from universal)
- Anonblood seadwellers (in one case I actually saw one of the mods kill off a user's anonblood seadweller. Just because they thought the concept was overdone. Mind you, the user in question agreed to this, but in other cases they killed other people's characters without permission)
- Female trolls with large breasts (thought they were automatically vapid, personalityless fanservice bimbos regardless of how they were actually played)
- Sprites that were well-drawn (thought that people were showing off if their art was too good or that it "didn't fit the style")
- Sprites that came from a generator on dA (this may admittedly be fair, but many of them didn't even look that bad)
One last note: At one point I brought it up that my character was the troll equivalent of Jewish. I will establish that I had decided this for quite some time now, it just hadn't come up in the RP, and that the author of the comic did allude to it being something that existed before. The admin of the thread - not a mod, not some random retard, but the admin - messaged me saying that he was offended because my character "didn't act like a Jew". Yeah, that was something that happened.
EDIT: Oh, I nearly forgot! The aforementioned troll ended up on that blog because someone thought that I had copied another user's troll just because they looked similar. I created said troll before I even knew of the cafe thread's existence, no less that of the troll everyone thought I had stolen.
Last edited: