Meanwhile, the redditor's thinking that failed to realize that insulin is also for another life. Assuming any of the story is true, with shit that's going on if they didn't know of a person not being able think clearly because "HOLY FUCK THERE'S A FIRE, I GOTTA GET WHAT I CAN THAT'S ESSENTIAL!!!" At least another
Reddit board saw this and realized this lady isn't really as evil as AITA redditors think of her to be while a number of redditors on that same board are also thinking "bullshit" on the entire story.
lbr a lot of those responses are because AITA, like the rest of reddit, is ridiculously misogynistic. They expect women to be perfect and exemplify femininity and stereotypical motherhood and womanhood at all times and demonize them if they don't. They responded the way they did because the step-son is a
boy, and thus automatically more important than the five year old
girl who clearly doesn't
really need her insulin. OP's wife is evil because she failed to perform perfect motherhood and remain calm and in control and run back into the fire and die saving her step-son, and also because she dared to prioritize female children over a male child - nevermind that the female children were all too young to manage by themselves while the male child was plenty old enough to escape on his own.
Like... there are legitimately people in the comments arguing that the
five year old girl was old enough and mature enough to escape on her own so OP should have just let her see herself out of the burning building, so that OP could go and.. carry? escort? the twelve year old boy out. It's pretty obvious that what they actually mean is that the little girl's survival isn't as
important as the boy's. Same with the insulin thing - she didn't personally escort her step-son out of the building so she's "left him to die," but if her daughter died because her insulin burned up in the fire and her parents couldn't afford more that would be understandable and just how life works I guess, no great loss because she's just a girl. (There were even commenters saying that OP's wife should have left the insulin behind because "if something happens and she needs insulin you can just take her to the hospital," like that's a super easy solution with no negative consequences. Sure, we'll just let the girl go into shock or something, nbd, it's not like diabetics not managing their insulin causes serious health effects or anything.)
The obvious, incredibly clear bottom line is that OP's wife panicked, which is totally understandable under the circumstances, and was focused on doing everything she could to prevent a major tragedy. She legitimately believed that her step-son had left through his own exit after she yelled for him to do so, so of course she didn't go looking for him when she ran back in to get the insulin that her daughter needs to survive and which they cannot afford more of. And to top it all off, this all took place in
three minutes start to finish, so she didn't even have time to really look for her step-son like everyone is blaming her for not doing, especially if the house is a typical row home where the basement entrance/exit is on the other side of the house from the front door so he would potentially be the next street over. The standards they're holding this poor woman to are
absurd - she would have had to literally be Superwoman and capable of supersonic flight to accomplish everything they demanded of her in the only three minutes before the firemen arrived. Even the firefighters said in their
official report that she was a hero who saved
multiple lives while risking her own to do it, including the life of her five year old diabetic daughter who could have died a horrible death without her insulin. But AITA can't see that because all
they see is an imperfect woman and mother who put
girls before a boy, who "failed" to give her actual life to save a (male) child, and for that she's an evil sinner who should be punished for the rest of her life.
I'm not sure what the most frustrating and egregious comments are, but the ones saying they would "forgive" OP's wife for her horrible "failure" if she groveled and begged his son's forgiveness on her knees and declared herself to be a terrible selfish evil person for getting her babies and kindergartener out first are definitely in the top five.
That AmItheAngel post is an absolute blessing, I almost linked it because that comment about how fires work in rowhomes was such a welcome surprise. I remember reading it when that shitshow of a post first went up - yes, I'm going on at such length about this because this is like... pent up aggravation with AITA that's an entire year old lol. It's lovely to see sane people on Reddit, however occasionally.
(I'm not like.. pulling the misogyny from nowhere btw. If you're familiar with AITA, it's really obvious. They love to attack women, especially mothers and
especially step-mothers. I've literally seen them advocate for a man to financially abuse his wife - I mean literally refusing to give her
any access to family funds whatsoever when she was a SAHM. And their habit of prioritizing male children over female children is also pretty clear overall. They're repulsive that way.)