What I don't get about reddit is how people can take it so seriously. Like it's fucking reddit, yes its a site that millions use everyday and it can be a place for people to share and create ideas. It's a place for cultured discussion on art and atheism, it's a place for political discourse.
I don't know when it was but all of a sudden people using reddit started to take themselves far more seriously and then thought they were better than everyone else but now people want it to be balanced in their way. That's not fairness or objectivity its "I-want-my-own-way-ism". Fucking newsflash, that happens to every single site that has a membership and karma system.
It's a fucking image hosting site that got big and now people think it's some sort of higher power.
It's power, and people with pathetic existences in real life with no control over themselves suddenly getting an ounce of control on a site that millions of people use, and it instantly going to their head. Nevermind that the millions who browse reddit are equally shut in individuals, boomers, kids and teenagers, the soy-liberal crowd, and overall just some of the dullest people you would meet outside of maybe a few hobby subreddits. They have some power to moderate these unwashed masses, and it definitely gets to their head.
When I used to use the site near a decade ago, for very specific hobby subreddits, the site was somewhat fine. Over the past decade something did change and around the election of Trump these people's need for purging wrongthink just accelerated drastically. In subreddits that should have nothing to do with politics, you get political slants or interpretations of the subreddits main theme. I wouldn't be opposed to that in and of itself, but there's typically a slant to allow "how trans people are reinventing the sport of extreme underwater basket weaving" vs shutting down anything even vaguely counter to that. You even have the recent example of various subreddits having pro-lockdown propaganda plastered to the top of the subreddit.
History subreddits are an utter cancer, as with many religion or other social subreddits. Wasn't always necessarily the case, but queue my bemusement when the majority of these subreddits now have discords associated with them as well now, and its full of people who have very, very little subject matter knowledge on the subreddit they moderate, often very bad politicized opinions, and I just don't think seem to care or even have decent reasons to follow what it is that they do. There's numerous subreddit discords I've explored, where it turns out a mod got into history through playing command and conquer and larps as a communist, then bans all other dissent (good commitment to the larp, I guess, because that is ironically pretty communist). One subreddit, for Shinto, had a bunch of people who got into the religion due to playing the Okami game, spoke in completely broken Japanese, publicized politicized articles non-stop about how inclusive Shinto was and how there were Shinto shrines in Korea and the PNW, and had the most insane power complex with an automatic ragepit or banning for any sniff of dissent.
I would say Tumblr was worse. Reddit is about as reactive as magnesium in water, but Tumblr somehow appears as a powder keg to me.
Reddit has the creepy rapists that slide into anyone with a hint of being a female's DMs, weird groomer troonies, and too much child pornography. Tumblr was way too sex positive for comfort. There's breaking the shame of being sexually repressed and then there's too far. In the case of Tumblr, it was an open secret that <18s were engaging in erotic roleplay and viewing NSFW blogs. There were also a lot of "totally 18s" ruining roleplay groups. It didn't matter if the kid lied, and this caused a lot of drama. Outside of the roleplay drama, there's the people going way too obsessive over what characters looked like. Sure, you might get death threats for saying "maybe cops aren't bad" on Reddit, but on Tumblr...
well... it was bad. If you drew a character too skinny or not dark enough, you would have the hate brigade in your mailbox and they wouldn't leave until they had your head on a pike. These fanatics were a different breed of crazy.
Everything you said here is sadly applicable for Tumblr as well and it is what led to normal people disassociating with the website and leaving behind the lunatics. I seriously wonder if the Reddit power trannies got bored of how not mainstream Tumblr was (lol) and set their sights on Reddit because it's pretty much mainstream. You just can't control what people say on the internet like you can on Reddit. If someone says something retarded on Twitter, you can mass report them and hope it works. On Tumblr, you could "only" harass someone into deleting their blog after angrily hammering up a smear campaign on your blog and putting in all the hashtags. On Reddit you can just censor someone directly.
Reddit basically turned into Tumblr, imo.
I don't think that Tumblr was ever really great and always had its own problems. Saying that, I did manage to meet some interesting people on the site.
What I remember from early Tumblr was that it used to be full of kids with suicidal ideation, teenagers cutting themselves, bad emo poetry, fanfictions, eating disorders, and a lot of pornography. This is before homestuck, and then at some point in maybe 2013 or 2014 more politics, trans stuff, and other
current day issues started to take over the site's zeitgeist a lot more (they were lurking there prior, of course, but never so prominent). It was interesting to see Tumblr move from being full of edgy emo/goth kids to former emo/goth kids high on progressive politics, and then the site collapse.
There were some interesting art communities on the site, but it definitely got worse, and worse, and worse, and many artists I knew went from maybe posting something political once in a blue moon, to 2/5 posts having some political slant, to almost every post having to have some politicized message forced in and "this tumblr is trans oriented, if you cant deal with that, fuck off bigot".