- Joined
- Aug 3, 2021
You can check Tolkien's letters and they're very similar to humans. They mature mentally quicker than humans, though physically they age slower (physical maturity is at like age 50 iirc) the main difference is spiritual versus anything physical. They're deeply connected to magic and to Middle Earth itself, assuming they aren't slain or die of some outside factor, they remain a part of the World until Eru Illuvatar brings the world to an end.View attachment 3570420
For context, this is Robert replying a post where the Critical Drinker bitches about Galadriel doing some wire-fu in the new amazon Lord of the Rings shit.
And again, this is another situation that I don't know if Robert is serious or just trolling, because if serious, can't Robert read or understand simple figure of speach?
I'm no Tolkien expert (I've only read the main 3 books and I sorta remember the Hobbit as a kid), but it was very clear that whenever Tolkien described elves, it was as if they were these ethereal, elegant creatures as a way to separate them from humans, but it was more a figure of speach in how the Elves presented themselves, as being these immaculate pristine beings.
So when Tolkien wrote that Legolas barely left foot prints, it doesn't mean that the guy has the weight of a feather, it just means that Legolas is extremely swift and dextrous, and even kids understand that, because to take it literally would mean that even a gust of wind would sweep a Elf away.
Also no Robert, Elves aren't stronger than humans. I can't recall if Tolkien ever wrote in the books about the Elves "power level" manga style, but the only thing it was made clear was that elves, Legolas in particular, was more agile and swift than the others, that's about it.
For the Tolkien heads here, feel free to correct me if I'm wrong,
One thing the books mention but isn't as apparent in the films is that destroying The One Ring will cause magic to fade away meaning the elves will have no choice but to go to the undying lands, whereas in the movies, they just kinda do it for reasons that are a bit more vague.
Honestly when they show off superior skill, I think its less a racial trait and more that they've literally had millenia to practice their skills and they don't have to worry about age affecting their abilities.
Either way, the only thing about LotR RoP that I care about are all the memes.