RU Russia To Introducing Islamic Banking System

Link (Archive)

Russia To Introducing Islamic Banking System​

In a surprising turn of events, Russia is working to bring Islamic Banking into the country.

This banking is decided to be introduced in four regions Chechnya, Dagestan, Tatarstan, and Russian Bashkiria which are Muslim-majority areas. Russia’s decision to bring Islamic banking will have a big impact on the financial system.

Islamic banking follows rules based on Islamic law or Sharia. One of the key rules is that it doesn’t allow the paying or charging of interest, which is called “Riba” in Arabic. Instead, Islamic banks use different methods:
  • Installment Plans: They give loans without interest, and borrowers pay back the money in fixed amounts over time.
  • Equity Financing: Islamic banks become partners in businesses, sharing profits and losses.
  • Leasing: Instead of lending money, they rent out assets, and customers pay to use them.

Russia’s Plan for Islamic Banking​

The State Duma, Russia’s parliament, is creating a law to make Islamic banking official in the country. This new law will not only make it legal but also regulate how it works. It will begin in the four regions mentioned earlier.

This change is significant because it’s different from how regular banking works in Russia. The goal is to cater to the needs of Russia’s Muslim population and attract investors from countries in the Middle East and Asia. These investors have shown interest in Russia but haven’t invested due to religious reasons.

The chairman of the State Duma Committee on Financial Market, Anatoly Aksakov thinks this plan if successful can spread to the whole country. This idea could open doors for investors from Muslim-majority nations to invest in Russia which can be a game-changer

One big reason behind Russia’s decision is the Western sanctions it’s facing because of its actions in Ukraine. By introducing Islamic banking, Russia hopes to attract investments from Muslim countries as an alternative to Western funding.

Islamic banking is growing worldwide, with an annual growth rate of about 14 percent. It’s estimated to be worth $1.99 trillion, making up about six percent of the global banking industry.

Islamic banks operate differently from traditional banks. They follow religious and ethical rules that forbid interest payments and risky financial activities.

In Russia, these Islamic banks, called Financing Partnership Organizations (FPOs), will offer various services. They’ll give loans without charging interest, finance trade through special contracts, and support businesses by becoming partners and providing guarantees.

This aligns with Islamic law, which doesn’t allow traditional lending with interest. Instead, it offers alternatives like installment plans, equity financing, and leasing.

The Central Bank of Russia will oversee these FPOs to ensure they follow the rules. However, there’s a need for deep discussions before this new system goes fully into effect. So, it’ll start in a few regions over two years, and certain FPO operations will be exempt from certain taxes.

Why Islamic Banking Matters​

Islamic banking is gaining attention worldwide, not only in Muslim-majority countries but also in Western nations. This is because it’s seen as a stable and ethical way of banking. Unlike traditional banks that aim to maximize profits through interest-based loans, Islamic banks focus on partnerships and sharing risks. Many doubted it at first, but Islamic banking has grown rapidly and become a crucial part of the world’s financial system.

Russia’s step into Islamic banking is significant and strategic. It shows Russia’s willingness to diversify its financial system and attract investments from Muslim-majority countries. While it’s still in the early stages, this move could have a big impact on Russia’s economy and its ties with the Muslim world.
 
They replaced interest with a "fee" that just coincidentally happens to be approximately the same amount as compounding interest over the term of the loan.
Exactly. It's no less hebrew than any other banking system, they just don't calculate interest as a percentage of the loan so that makes it somehow ok.
 
The issue is that there isn't really an alternative. Not reducing money value will just get it hoarded and the economy to stagnate. Issue is printing a fuckton and immediately handing it to billionaires.

The economy is not more important than the country or the people. Sometimes slow and steady wins the race, inshallah.
 
Anyone who watches MMA knows that the Chechnya's and Dagistanis get a shit load of support from the Saudis and Middle East on behalf of being the only competent Muslim combat sports athletes. Kadyrov (Chechnya's dictator/leader) loves travelling around there and shaking hands with all the sheiks from that region. Likely to set up Islamic banking and have these guys run over for more of that sweet Saudi money.
 
It is. In reality Muslim and Christian loan institutions in the middle ages would use late payment penalties to profit from loans as usury was illgeal. If you made every payment and avoided having late fees you would be blacklisted. It only makes sense, a bank is a business and needs to profit somehow.
Even if usury is illegal, there are plenty of ways to still get a profit. Hell, look at credit cards, you can pay it off every month and pay no interest, even get money from cash back, but then you look at the profits of Mastercard and Visa.
 
That sounds too good to be true. Like, it's the most un-Jewish way to do business, so I don't understand how it works.
It really doesn't, at least not any differently from how normal banking works. They just rearrange words so it technically isn't violating the Koran. IIRC the Ottomans had some pretty strict requirements, like all profits must go towards charitable causes, but we both know how laughably easy a requirement like that is to game.

Also didn't stop the Orthodox or Jewish minorities from running interest-based banks, so unsurprisingly the Jews and Armenians wound up controlling a lot of the Ottoman money supply.
 
How does it work exactly? Just inflation by itself will mean that anything short of a day loan will always lose money. Like I get the appeal but the loan system is designed so the bank can get money out of it and not lose the money invested in it.
Yes because the system was devised over a thousand years ago and it's essentially incompatible with modern economic systems.

Most Islamic countries that use it have.... bad results and it's incredibly open to abuse and theft.
 
So if I turn to islam, I can apply for 0% interest loans? What the hell is this thing.
It's my understanding that in a somewhat-semitic way they are very particular about there not being compounding interest. However, there might be a fixed interest included in the loan in one way or another. This might be as simple as 11 $10K payments on a $100K loan. It might be a more convoluted thing like an inflated principal with kickbacks or specification of who you must spend it with.

Most importantly it relies very much on reputation and good will. You need someone the lender holds in high esteem and while personal relationships help effect how much, you're usually paying said person for their endorsement/introduction. If the banker enables this individual to make money this way, it naturally follows that this person would be incentivized to give a kickback to bankers.

Like many other reputation/honor-based systems in Islam, it's not a simple faux pas to contravene them. These people are likely to know your family, attend your mosque, know your Imam, and have a far greater standing in the community. If you don't make good they will cover the bank since they vouched for you, and they will extend the (not-so) soft pressure they can leverage to convince you. This might be ostracizing/shunning/disowning, or you might just take a tumble off a tall building. Your own associates/family are likely to facilitate this to maintain their own honor.

TL;DR- the cost is much the same but the form, schedule, and practices vary from traditional banking.
 
A simple way to help stave off the cost of running a bank is/was service charges. You never really heard of them, but some banks would charge you for physically going to the bank and having the teller perform an action on your behalf; I'm sure they still exist somewhere, just not sure where. An easier way to do this would be to have a service charge tied to every credit card transaction (since most money is moved electronically now). The problem being, people don't like being charged for using their money, and would prefer the Interest charging bank because they don't nickel and dime you; and the pain is only visible if/when/should you take out a loan, which depending on your lifestyle, you may never do.

I'd like to think I'm pretty good with my money, so even if there was a service charge for using my card, I wouldn't be killing myself via one-thousand paper cuts; and would honestly prefer a no-interest banking system (without praying five times a day).
 
The issue is that there isn't really an alternative. Not reducing money value will just get it hoarded and the economy to stagnate. Issue is printing a fuckton and immediately handing it to billionaires.
I suspect the "economy will stagnate" is somewhat cope for people refusing to consider alternatives to the current economic system we have. As it is now, the focus on perpetual growth and other, modern capitalistic follies are running into troubles. Eventually the theory and reality will diverge irreparably. I'm not informed enough to say what, but we need some degree of overhaul of our current economic system, and by re-structuring our economy we could achieve zero inflation and thus enable wealth-preservation for the common man.
 
Back