"All I care about is [...] white people" is a direct quote of Sam's from the Bradley Martyn podcast. In saying that, it directly indicates he doesn't care about people who aren't white, which is directly contradicted by his having people such as Damiel, Christ Dillinger, Ryan Katsu Rivera etc. in his circle.
Even merely saying that white people should have "group cohesion", as you imaginatively stretch his apparent beliefs to, does not really tie in with your created cohesive group actually being multi-ethnic. Likewise, claiming in words to be "antisemitic" (as he has) makes little sense when in action you choose to collaborate with lots of jews (as he does). It's like saying that you are vegetarian and anti the killing of animals for food, when you eat steak once a week.
where you can't even understand nuance.
"Nuance" doesn't come in to it. There is no "nuance" to wriggle your way out of how claiming you shouldn't make money from gambling, at the same time as you make money from ball lotteries, isn't pure and simple hypocrisy.
You'd also have to be incredibly generous to claim that Fishtank is not in other ways "degenerate", when it's a show that encourages people to chug milk and smoke until they puke, puts cameras in the bathrooms, pays big fat guys to physically assault small women, invites on OnlyFans strippers and deviants of all shades for the viewers' "entertainment" etc.
But I'm also not the kind of person who thinks "hypocrisy" is some crazy, unbelievably outlandish act.
You're attempting to shift the goal-posts here. The main point in question was whether he is hypocritical (which he is and which I have indeed given clear "examples" for) - not whether being hypocritical matters or not.
But to humour your additional assertion, why should anyone listen to and pay any serious heed to the words of someone who is hypocritical in that their chosen actions are so often at odds with those words? It's one thing to merely talk the talk, it's another to actually walk the walk. Talk is cheap, especially when what you spew is bogus.
What Sam often does is no different from the celebrities and world leaders who travel via gas-guzzling private jets to conferences where they then lecture the masses on the perils of greenhouse gas emissions and climate change. Or who sing the virtues of immigration and mixed societies while living in homogenous gated communities. It's superficial virtue signalling with no real grounding in how they actually live their lives. Sam's shallow, performative virtue signalling is just of a different political flavour.