- Joined
- Aug 24, 2018
I didn't have the benefit of knowing this thread existed until I spontaneously looked it up a couple of days ago so this is late and gay but I read through the whole thing and it's interesting to see different perspectives and opinions and the autismo part of my brain wants to put all the information into a chart to see the general consensus of episodes. I remember watching and enjoying the pilot but for some reason I never stuck around to watch the rest of S1 until S2 premiered but I'm really glad I did.
It does surprise me how many people who decidedly and consistently dislike this type of humor give SF a pass. Maybe it's a tin-foil hat scenario where people say "you don't like any shows because you hate good things" and they say "nuh uh I like Smiling Friends so". I'm really hoping (not going to be surprised by, but hoping) that if things do change, it'll be for the better or more cohesive for the crew and, by extension, the audience. I think the length of the episodes are fine (maybe include two a block though, like most other 11min cartoons do) and I don't mind the meandering, improvisational tone that more of S2 used and I'm an enjoyer of seeing several different animation styles showcased.
That all being said, I too want to list the S2 episodes because all the cool kids were doing it.
1. Gwimbly
2. Allan Adventure
3. Spamtopia
4. The Halloween one
5. The Aliens one
6. Christmas
7. Brother's Egg
8. Mr. President
And none of the episodes was bad, as others have said. I'm just one of those spergs who thought Jimbly was too consistently gross and made my skin crawl after a while. Allan's my fave but Pim's adorable and while more Glep would be fun, I kinda like that he seems to literally just be there stir shit up / be a dick when the others' shenanigans drag him into them. Glep gives me "teen girl who doesn't wanna be there" energy
It does surprise me how many people who decidedly and consistently dislike this type of humor give SF a pass. Maybe it's a tin-foil hat scenario where people say "you don't like any shows because you hate good things" and they say "nuh uh I like Smiling Friends so". I'm really hoping (not going to be surprised by, but hoping) that if things do change, it'll be for the better or more cohesive for the crew and, by extension, the audience. I think the length of the episodes are fine (maybe include two a block though, like most other 11min cartoons do) and I don't mind the meandering, improvisational tone that more of S2 used and I'm an enjoyer of seeing several different animation styles showcased.
That all being said, I too want to list the S2 episodes because all the cool kids were doing it.
1. Gwimbly
2. Allan Adventure
3. Spamtopia
4. The Halloween one
5. The Aliens one
6. Christmas
7. Brother's Egg
8. Mr. President
And none of the episodes was bad, as others have said. I'm just one of those spergs who thought Jimbly was too consistently gross and made my skin crawl after a while. Allan's my fave but Pim's adorable and while more Glep would be fun, I kinda like that he seems to literally just be there stir shit up / be a dick when the others' shenanigans drag him into them. Glep gives me "teen girl who doesn't wanna be there" energy