US Social Security Administration to require in-person identity checks for new and existing recipients

By FATIMA HUSSEIN
Updated 10:48 PM UTC, March 18, 2025

1742398327706.png
Demonstrators gather outside of the Edward A. Garmatz United States District Courthouse in Baltimore, on Friday, March 14, 2025, before a hearing regarding the Department of Government Efficiency’s access to Social Security data. (AP Photo/Stephanie Scarbrough)

WASHINGTON (AP) — In an effort to limit fraudulent claims, the Social Security Administration will impose tighter identity-proofing measures — which will require millions of recipients and applicants to visit agency field offices rather than interact with the agency over the phone.

Beginning March 31st, people will no longer be able to verify their identity to the SSA over the phone and those who cannot properly verify their identity over the agency’s “my Social Security” online service, will be required to visit an agency field office in person to complete the verification process, agency leadership told reporters Tuesday.

The change will apply to new Social Security applicants and existing recipients who want to change their direct deposit information.

Retiree advocates warn that the change will negatively impact older Americans in rural areas, including those with disabilities, mobility limitations, those who live far from SSA offices and have limited internet access.

The plan also comes as the agency plans to shutter dozens of Social Security offices throughout the country and has already laid out plans to lay off thousands of workers.

In addition to the identity verification change, the agency announced that it plans to expedite processing of recipients’ direct deposit change requests – both in person and online – to one business day. Previously, online direct deposit changes were held for 30 days.

“The Social Security Administration is losing over $100 million a year in direct deposit fraud,” Leland Dudek, the agency’s acting commissioner, said on a Tuesday evening call with reporters — his first call with the media. “Social Security can better protect Americans while expediting service.”

He said a problem with eliminating fraudulent claims is that “the information that we use through knowledge-based authentication is already in the public domain.”

“This is a common sense measure,” Dudek added.

More than 72.5 million people, including retirees and children, receive retirement and disability benefits through the Social Security Administration.

Connecticut Rep. John Larson, the top Democrat on the House Ways and Means Social Security Subcommittee, said in a statement that “by requiring seniors and disabled Americans to enroll online or in person at the same field offices they are trying to close, rather than over the phone, Trump and Musk are trying to create chaos and inefficiencies at SSA so they can privatize the system.”

The DOGE website says that leases for 47 Social Security field offices across the country, including in Arkansas, Texas, Louisiana, Florida, Kentucky and North Carolina, have been or will be ended. However, Dudek downplayed the impact of its offices shuttering, saying many were small remote hearing sites that served few members of the public.

Many Americans have been concerned that SSA office closures and massive layoffs of federal workers — part of an effort by President Donald Trump and Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency to shrink the size of the federal government — will make getting benefits even more difficult.

Musk has pushed debunked theories about Social Security and described the federal benefit programs as rife with fraud, and called it a “Ponzi scheme” suggesting the program will be a primary target in his crusade to reduce government spending.

Voters have flooded town halls across the country to question Republican lawmakers about the Trump administration’s cuts, including its plans for the old-age benefits program.

In addition a group of labor unions last week sued and asked a federal court for an emergency order to stop DOGE from accessing the sensitive Social Security data of millions of Americans.

Source (Archive)
 
I could see that being inconvenient if you're a genuine cripple and can't drive to the SocSec office on your own. But surely they'd have people to drive them anyway, so I see no downside here.
I've been "Crippled" for long periods before due to broken bones and surgery recovery.... it's not fun or easy to run errands in a wheelchair/walker, or with a leg splinted up, but if the alternative is no food and no money? You can find a way to make it to an office or store and meet someone face-to-face once or twice a week.



But you and I both know the left will spin this as some kind of impossible feat like I'm being asked to build a pyramid by myself or something.
 
Musk has pushed debunked theories about Social Security and described the federal benefit programs as rife with fraud,

Nobody knows whether it is or not, I think, on the retirement side. I'm guesssing it exists, but probably isn't rampant.

However I gotta think a lot of the people sailing around in SSDI tugboats could work at something. But courtesy of a sympathetic physican they've got their stipend.

and called it a “Ponzi scheme” suggesting the program will be a primary target in his crusade to reduce government spending.

It kind of is, though. Current payouts are funded by current contributions and the system only functions as long as you've got people paying in. I think there's some sort of weird treasury bond social security is required to buy, but all that does is cover the national debt. And I'm not even sure the surplus used to fund such things exists any longer.

The other issue is simply increasing lifespans. When the program started in the 1930s I don't think the average lifespan was 65. I'm a bit surprised we don't get the Jesse Jacksons of the world screeching about the fact that black males have shorter lifespans than every group out there, excluding maybe Native Americans. Assuming they're contributing to social security they're basically paying for white and Asian women to receive benefits.

Location, race and income affect life spans in U.S.

You don't even qualify for full benefits until 67 if you're born after 1960 now. And the average lifespan of an "urban black male" is 66 years and change, with Asian women in some US localities living on average into their 90s.
 
I could see that being inconvenient if you're a genuine cripple and can't drive to the SocSec office on your own. But surely they'd have people to drive them anyway, so I see no downside here.

They shuttered some offices and it greatly impacted the local recipients, especially in rural areas. Some people don't realise how hard it can be to travel long distances. The powers that be don't care if granny can't travel long distances. They don't care if a disabled person can't travel. It can be hard to find a ride. Maybe some people qualify for paratransit services if they are available in the area.

I understand the issue with changing direct deposit info. There's so many scammers. I had to use the My Social Security website to get a new card issued a few years ago because I needed a fuckton of proof of ID. I can't imagine an elderly person being able to figure out how to verify themselves online to get a new card let alone change bank info.
 
Also is it just more or would 1-day turnaround on changes to DD more than offset the inconvenience of having to go to an office to change it? 30 days is kind of a big deal for fixed income people which arguably requires more planning around than having to make a trip somewhere one time.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: mold
They shuttered some offices and it greatly impacted the local recipients, especially in rural areas. Some people don't realise how hard it can be to travel long distances. The powers that be don't care if granny can't travel long distances. They don't care if a disabled person can't travel. It can be hard to find a ride. Maybe some people qualify for paratransit services if they are available in the area.

I understand the issue with changing direct deposit info. There's so many scammers. I had to use the My Social Security website to get a new card issued a few years ago because I needed a fuckton of proof of ID. I can't imagine an elderly person being able to figure out how to verify themselves online to get a new card let alone change bank info.
Yeah the office shuttering seems like a boneheaded move. I get that it's to cut down the amount of spending and probably oust incompetents from their positions, but I wouldn't want to have to go to LA for anything, let alone for a pilgrimage to beg the government for shekels so that I don't starve like I'm Oliver Twist.
 
Is this a joke? we didn't have this before? every country I been to demanded that every once in a while people had to show up at the social security office to prove they aren't dead, how the hell was this not the case in the evil capitalist hellhole that is America according to the people who live in those socialist paradises where you also need an ID card to vote?
I could see that being inconvenient if you're a genuine cripple and can't drive to the SocSec office
In those rare cases they would send a social worker to check on you, but the vast majority can go, I see 90yo people going to the bank every day...
 
Aren't expats getting their passports renewed every 10 yrs, with a new photo, etc? This is probably on the same level of inconvenience (or less).
Nah, it is way more inconvenient. You can renew your passport at the embassy. With this you need to fly all the way back stateside to take care of it.
 
I guess I'll have to help my elderly relatives register on this website. A few of them don't have birth certificates though because they were born at home.
 
If you can't show up then get fucked. I'm sure the waste and abuse is more than we suspect.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Nitro!
I view this type of shit with increasing suspicion, because it shows that Trump, Elon, and their team are either too rich and removed from everyday society to fully understand the problem, or is just bullshit to make it  look like they're doing something without actualy fixing the problem. Yes, illegals have been gaming SS for years- they're the drivers of identity fraud in this country after all. But if they're already getting into the system in droves with their fake IDs and SSN cards because of apathetic, impotent, and often downright traitorous workers, what good will forcing people to go back to those same workers do? More than SS, illegals get their bennies by being the parents of anchor babies which entitles them, as the legal guardians, to housing, food, cellphones, certain medical care, and a host of other things. Either ICE needs to be expanded to post people that check immigration status for anyone that walks into any SSA building in the country regardless if they're there for WIC or retirement, or another agency that does the same thing needs to be established. Either way, it also needs to be watched like a hawk for sabotuers and corruption.
 
this is going to be very annoying for anyone actually unable to leave the house. otherwise its no different than having to visit the DMV when its time to get a new drivers license. i wonder how this will effect anyone who gets their payments via debit card.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lil Yappy
The simple answer here isn't the one musk is smart enough to enact.

1. Get rid of the phone system if prone to fraud sure
But 2. Leave the offices alone at first and, hire home visit SSA people who can handle the exception cases. Yes this means more outlay initially.

3. Skeleton crews are often more inefficient than proper staffed office on a per capital basis. Wait for 1 and 2 to settle, and then figure out proper staffing per office

4. Make government employees not suck so fucking hard at their jobs.aybe the pay is better and it's easier to fire. Idk. Figure it out. Then do it.

5. Be satisfied with not being penny wise and pound foolish. The system will not be 100% efficient or fraud free. Find a better balance and call it a win.
 
Back