- Joined
- Jan 15, 2014
Well, that looks fucking shit.
The problem with these "adult" takes on kids' characters is that 99% of the time, they seem to have been created by people who don't understand what being an adult is. It's just "oh hey hur hur lets make them swear and have sex." It can be done well. Avenue Q does have some very adult humour, but the jokes are good and the observations are pretty spot-on. The concept is basically taking Sesame Street and applying it to adult life. Team America relied on Gerry Anderson-style puppets for a lot of its humour, but it also had some very solid satire and raised some intelligent points. Who Framed Roger Rabbit very cleverly deconstructed cartoon conventions and had a decent story built around it.
If you're going to do an "adult take on kids' medium" movie, it either needs to put a new spin on the kids' medium (Avenue Q, Meet the Feebles, Who Framed Roger Rabbit), or using that medium needs to put a new spin on an old formula (Team America with action movies, Roger Rabbit with film noir). Otherwise, what's the point? The Happytime Murders, based on this trailer, does neither of those things. Nothing here says "this is a story that wouldn't work unless we used puppets." What it says is "this is a story that just doesn't work, here's a character jizzing silly string for half an hour."
Apparently it's been in development since 2008. Make of that what you will.
The problem with these "adult" takes on kids' characters is that 99% of the time, they seem to have been created by people who don't understand what being an adult is. It's just "oh hey hur hur lets make them swear and have sex." It can be done well. Avenue Q does have some very adult humour, but the jokes are good and the observations are pretty spot-on. The concept is basically taking Sesame Street and applying it to adult life. Team America relied on Gerry Anderson-style puppets for a lot of its humour, but it also had some very solid satire and raised some intelligent points. Who Framed Roger Rabbit very cleverly deconstructed cartoon conventions and had a decent story built around it.
If you're going to do an "adult take on kids' medium" movie, it either needs to put a new spin on the kids' medium (Avenue Q, Meet the Feebles, Who Framed Roger Rabbit), or using that medium needs to put a new spin on an old formula (Team America with action movies, Roger Rabbit with film noir). Otherwise, what's the point? The Happytime Murders, based on this trailer, does neither of those things. Nothing here says "this is a story that wouldn't work unless we used puppets." What it says is "this is a story that just doesn't work, here's a character jizzing silly string for half an hour."
Apparently it's been in development since 2008. Make of that what you will.