I'm in the same boat of having played both Ico and Shadow of the Colossus and falling in love with Ueda's work long before The Last Guardian came out. Shortly after the first trailer was released, I stumbled across it on Youtube and watched it on a whim; I didn't realize it was a Team Ico game at first. It was the first shot of the boy that gave it away. He invoked such strong memories of Ico and Wander, and sounded exactly like Ico when he made sounds. Then I checked the description of the video and saw that my hunch was right. I was ecstatic.
Waiting all those years, I was worried. It was sort of a tie between everyone saying that Trico was definitely going to die because "all cute animal sidekicks die" (my insistence that this was not Ueda's style fell on deaf ears), and just how long production was taking. Ico and Shadow of the Colossus pushed their tech to the limits and were surreal, incredible experiences because of it and Ueda's amazing storytelling abilities. But could The Last Guardian, a game with such high expectations, ever deliver as well as its predecessors?
I lost track of development as real life sort of took me away from the gaming world, and suddenly, The Last Guardian had been released. I was very careful not to spoil myself, and a month or so after we got our PS4, my boyfriend surprised me with it as a gift.
I think the most telling thing about the experience is that I walked away with one solitary complaint. One. And that's that the camera was wonky and didn't like to play along. All the same, if you've played Shadow of the Colossus, it's more or less the same exact camera.
Everything else about The Last Guardian blew my mind away.
The scenery, the story, the puzzles, the fights, Trico's AI, Trico's physics - everything was what I had hoped for and more. Though I wish it had been a longer game simply so I could have enjoyed it longer, by the end I was not left wanting. It was so very much a perfect blend of Ico and Shadow of the Colossus while also being its own thing. I also have to say I agree with the comparison to Journey; though very different experiences, The Last Guardian and Journey do share in expansive adventure, beautiful scenery, and a deeply emotional atmosphere.
Gaming and game design are passions of mine, and to put it simply, The Last Guardian is an inspiration. I love it deeply and will treasure it as much as I've treasured the games that came before it, if not moreso. I'm grateful for the experience and will be happy to go through it again for the achievements and extras... when I can emotionally handle it.