My biggest complaint was that it was extremely floppy in the middle,
I don't mean to pick on you specifically, but I feel like Dave Portnoy is the Jamie Oliver of pizza.
When he does his reviews he has weird, specific ideas about how pizza should be. He thinks it should have no "flop." If it has flop, meaning it's not like a matzo pizza, then that's really bad. Cooking it normal is really bad, you should cook it longer until it's "well done" / burnt, probably to emulate coal fire ovens or the new haven style he's obsessed with. Also, adding any type of cheese besides mozarella, like parmesan, is really really bad.
The guy is drugged to his gills on Adderall and whatever other amphetamines/stimulants he's taking. He doesn't even have an appetite, and appears to not really like food. He seems annoyed with the fact he has to eat every day to survive. He's not a foodie.
But still, pizza places take his word like it's gospel.
The one near me, they have all kinds of creations, but you rarely see ones that include parmesan now since he's become popular. To make matters worse, they will often burn your pizza now. Especially young workers there who probably watch Portnoy on tiktok. Sometimes an older person will bring me the pizza, realize it's burnt, and then they'll ask me if I still want it, or if it's too burnt.
I want to tell them to try to not make it well done, but you know they'd probably just undercook it since now a "crisp undercarriage" is the norm, thanks to this idiot.
I'm pretty sure he usually gives low scores to Naples style pizzas because they have flop, aren't burnt, and so on.